Bengal faught with formidable british for freedom of India with their blood,sweat and tears. They have been denied share of power not only at the center but also in their own leftist party.
CPIM has been hijacked by rootless and power hungry fellows like Karat ,Yechury ..who have not won even a muncipal election... These obnoxious fellows do not want any bengali to occupy any position of power not only at center but also in the party. Just like they prevented Jyoti Babu from becoming PM in 1996 and prevented Somnath Da from contesting Vice Prez post!!!These fellows are against bengals progress..just behaving like Greg Chappel .. what he did to Sourav and showed finger to Kolkata ...these scoundrels are deriving power from MPs of bengal and working against bengals progress..
Bengal is sending 70% of left MPs and they share not even 10% of power at center..
If bengal could throw the British out ..why not these anti bengal..antinational Karat,Yechury & the likes.. I fail to understand as to how long it would take for bongs to realise this..
DEMOCRACY DEMOCRACY DEMOCRACY DEMOCRACY iN A PARTY BASED DEMOCRACY NO INDIVIDUALS ARE BIGGER THAN THE PARTY TO WHAT EXTENT HE MAY BE BIG.WITH HIS EDUCATION AND EXPERIENCE HE SHOUL KNOW THAT HE SHOULD STAND WITH THE PARTY WHEN THE PARTY WANTS HIM MORE.THE WORST THING IS THE SO CALLED UPA STALWARTS(HYPOCRATS)ARE SIDING WITH GREED AND SUPPORTING INDSIPLINE .MOST UNFURTUNATE INDEEED FOR COUNTRY AND FOR DEMOCRACY.
RE:Somanath chatterjee
by Guest on Jul 24, 2008 02:44 PM Permalink
First things first. CPIM has no democracy. In Bengal villages they beat up the poor and stone those who voice any angst against them. who are these red flag foxes/bearers to talk of democracy. they know no rules themselves. Bunch of jokers indeed
RE:Somanath chatterjee
by charvak on Jul 24, 2008 05:27 PM Permalink
Ah! What a take!! What level of intelligence!! CPI(M) "beating and stoning" the poor in Bengal and still winning the polls! Where was the Election Commission during the last Assembly Election (2006)? It was so meticulous that the state witnessed the longest election in the country, in five phases. Still the Left won with a thumping majority. The "poor" (who constitute the majority) should have either been patently stupid or under the impact of cocaine to accept the Left though they are being abused and beaten day in and day out. How interesting! I congratulate Karat for taking such a bold step. The Speaker was wrong. If he thought that he was "above" politics and performing a constitutional duty, why didn't he resign from the party just when he was elected the Speaker? He refused to follow the party line, and CPI(M) has no place for those who embarrass the party in public. Without the party Mr. Chatterjee would have been one of India's few thousand lawyers who crowd our courts. Mr. Chatterjee got the exposure and the respect that he earned also because of the unstinting support of thousands who worked tirelessly to get him elected. He completely forgot about them for the sake of his "constitutional position". Let him enjoy the position as long as he can. Don't forget that the Left are the only parties in the country who are never expected to dance to the tune of bags full of black money. The Congress could never boast that, the BJP is pathetically exposed.
RE:Somanath chatterjee
by pise mosai on Jul 24, 2008 02:39 PM Permalink
The basic issue is of aligning with communal forces, which is the root cause of terrorism in today’s world. As Subhas Chakraborty has rightly pointed out that voting along side BJP is actually an act against the party line adopted in last party congress. Prakash Karat decision is really against party line. CPM’s decision to align with BJP & Janta party in the past had created the today’s BJP a big tiger from a little mouse. Somnath Chatterjee’s decision of refusing voting with BJP is a right one. I like to wish him “ Happy Birthday a real Leo by birth”
RE:RE:Somanath chatterjee
by trikarn on Jul 24, 2008 08:24 PM Permalink
so the commies developed the BJP? MAN WHAT NEXT? REALLY THESE COMMIES HAVE LOST THEIR MENTAL MARBLES!
RE:Time will prove it all..
by sanjay on Jul 24, 2008 02:29 PM Permalink
tell us why the hurry in nuclear deal when it just gives us 3% more energy after 20 years. why cant UPA let the public know about the cost of the electricity ( some say it will be 17 Rs per unit ) and the investment ( estimates 19,00, 000 Crores) which will go in.
i sincerely believe there is more to the deal that is the reason bush,Sonia Gandhi( Bofors Scam), laloo (Fodder scam) Mulayam ( Reliance janta Party ) is in a hurry to get the deal done.
RE:RE:Time will prove it all..
by Gumpy on Jul 24, 2008 02:32 PM Permalink
Please get your facts right. Have u even read the neuclear deal draft ??
The cost of neuclear power generated is marginally higher than that fm coal (Rs 4.5 vs. Rs 3.5)..but coal will stay only for another 40 years or so..So, what will you leave for your children..?? DRAKNESS ??
RE:Time will prove it all..
by anil mahajan on Jul 24, 2008 03:12 PM Permalink
Mr Gumpy, There is no doubt that Nuclear power is a long lasting solution then thermal power but Hydel Power is a much better and practically ever lasting solution. But we should not forget the risks involved in generating nuclear power, disposal of waste and continous supply. Any misadventure by any mad nation can cripple our raw material supplies without any fault on our part. We should not forget what happened in Bhopal gas leak case. Nuclear mishap is going to be thousands of times more dangerous.
RE:Time will prove it all..
by Gumpy on Jul 24, 2008 02:30 PM Permalink
very well written. Most of us writing here on rediff are the ones enjoying Manmohan Singh's eocnomic reforms in 1992 and getting access to the world thru better jobs and opportunities...
Lets have a thing Gratitude, which moist of us dont have, it seems..!
RE:RE:Time will prove it all..
by Ashok Gobindram Lulla on Jul 24, 2008 03:45 PM Permalink
RE:Time will prove it all.. by Ashok Gobindram Lulla on Jul 24, 2008 03:38 PM "Manmohan Singh started Indian economic reforms...? Are you sure of your facts? His boss that time was Mr. P V Narasimha Rao. Barring Babri Masjid debacle, he was the true architect of those reforms. This was the man who had a shrewd undderstanding of the nation's needs, and despite a slim 'manufactured' majority, he ran the country well. He was an administrator in the Chanakya mould. He could have chosen to make Dr Manmohan Singh a 'darbari' the way Sonia Gandhi did; but he did not. Dr. Manmohan Singh did not have, and still does not have any vision about India. As for his being 'honest, upright, man of integrity' and all those shibboleths, we have all seen a display of his integrity and Congress values in the Trust vote.
Incidentally, Mr. Narasimha Rao represents only the non-Family member of the Congress to have completed a full 5-year tenure as Prime Minister. A fact that has stuck in the throat of the Signora Sonia Gandhi, nee Maino. When he died, the Congress, under instructions of this family, hustled his body out of Delhi and hastily cremated it, so that a memorial to Narasimha Rao could not be erected. Had his body been kept in state, for a few days, then a public demand would gone out that he was a worthy son of India, who merited a memorial. The (naqli) Gandhis believes it is solely the pre- rogative of the Gandhis to have memorials of their kith and kin in Delhi. Imagine the irony, a C
RE:Time will prove it all..
by Ashok Gobindram Lulla on Jul 24, 2008 03:38 PM Permalink
"Manmohan Singh started Indian economic reforms...? Are you sure of your facts? His boss that time was Mr. P V Narasimha Rao. Barring Babri Masjid debacle, he was the true architect of those reforms. This was the man who had a shrewd undderstanding of the nation's needs, and despite a slim 'manufactured' majority, he ran the country well. He was an administrator in the Chanakya mould. He could have chosen to make Dr Manmohan Singh a 'darbari' the way Sonia Gandhi did; but he did not. Dr. Manmohan Singh did not have, and still does not have any vision about India. As for his being 'honest, upright, man of integrity' and all those shibboleths, we have all seen a display of his integrity and Congress values in the Trust vote.
Incidentally, Mr. Narasimha Rao represents only the non-Family member of the Congress to have completed a full 5-year tenure as Prime Minister. A fact that has stuck in the throat of the Signora Sonia Gandhi, nee Maino. When he died, the Congress, under instructions of this family, hustled his body out of Delhi and hastily cremated it, so that a memorial to Narasimha Rao could not be erected. Had his body been kept in state, for a few days, then a public demand would gone out that he was a worthy son of India, who merited a memorial. The (naqli) Gandhis believes it is solely the pre- rogative of the Gandhis to have memorials of their kith and kin in Delhi. Imagine the irony, a Charan Singh gets a samadhi in his memory. But not a full-term CONGRESS PM.
RE:Time will prove it all..
by subir sengupta on Jul 24, 2008 02:48 PM Permalink
Kajolika, there is no doubt about the economic reform started by the then finance minister Manmohan Singh, that does not mean that his keen interest in the nuclear deal is a correct move. There are a few nuclear expert (Ex-BARC) who openly expressed their apprehension about this deal. Moreover the exhorbitant cost involves to increse appx. 4 to 6 percent energy is a blunder, I believe. Our politicians play games as per their convenience in life. India is bound to have problems from this deal. The simple reason is that, we will be completely dependent on the suppliers of nuclear fuels like uranium and there they will dictate terms to us. You might say we also import a bulk need oil for our domestic need. True, but in this case if any country refuses to supply the same, we shall only have to curtail our use. In nuclear energy, we need to invest huge in the infrastructure that will not only go waste, the burden of this huge loss would go to the common man.
RE:Time will prove it all..
by Rajesh Jadhav on Jul 24, 2008 03:00 PM Permalink
What about the opinion of Lgendary Scientist Mr. APJ Abdul Kalam? He also supported N-Deal.
RE:Time will prove it all..
by sanjay Mor on Jul 24, 2008 03:59 PM Permalink
You are thinking too much for future, till that time we will have our own technology
And the Indian communist constitution was drafted by China, policies endorsed by it and its functions funded by it. See how easily China is fomenting terrorism in the Indian communists dominated North East just as the Pakistan fed Muslim wolves are biting the Indian society in J & K and from Bangladesh soil.
NDA blames UPA for horse trading. Is Indian Public going to believe party who has own record of shame ? BJP Chief was caught taking money under table and asking for us dollors to be deposited in swiss bank. NO BODY "DOODH KA DHULA'' Its all eye wash...all parties do horse trading
No dobut Somnath fooled his party. It is like the son throw his parents out after he attain a position and b his own legs. Now Somnath will be offered membership from Congress, he might accept it and contest under HAND SYMBOL from West Bengal. Somnath proven himself he is selfish and his personal needs are beyond the party's interest. Who bothered all the enthics??? Karat, this is a lesson, dont suggest any partymen to a key post from where they can enjoy life....communists always stand for people's interest, but Somnath is the example that thoese are all in paper only. Somnath should not have himself degraded like this, shameful!
RE:SOMNATH CHEATED HIS PARTY WHO MADE HIM GROWN
by Akshay Kumar on Jul 24, 2008 02:22 PM Permalink
There is no COngress in West Bengal. So he cannot contest from there in Congress ticket. But Lalu may offer him a seat from Bihar on RJD ticket along with most respected Pappu Yadav etc. !!!!!
RE:SOMNATH CHEATED HIS PARTY WHO MADE HIM GROWN
by palash ghosh on Jul 24, 2008 02:37 PM Permalink
I agree fully. Mr KArat please throw out that junk Subhas Chakrabarty . He is much more dangerous than the fat man(SC)
RE:SOMNATH CHEATED HIS PARTY WHO MADE HIM GROWN
by Rajesh Jadhav on Jul 24, 2008 03:12 PM Permalink
There is a very good dialouge in movie "Page-3", "To change the system, you have to be in system". Why Communist leaders want to act like remote control? Take part in the Government, change the system the way you want. Popatpanchi is not good for anybody.
RE:SOMNATH CHEATED HIS PARTY WHO MADE HIM GROWN
by debesh kanungo on Jul 24, 2008 02:29 PM Permalink
KOI BHI PARTY KHANA NAHI DETE KISIKO PARTY DESH CHALANE KELIYE HAIN
Communist Party ever considered "The Party is above all individulas". The party is having histories like this. Folks, no need to blame any individual for Somnath's expulsion.
It is see that many are using unacceptable/abusive languages while expressing their views. It is a fact persons using such websites are mainly youngsters who do not know whats the real life of the countryman. they may be thinking that mobiles and pizas are flowing in our country. Before you critisise anybody you should know the dignity of that man. I saw one fellow wrote Prakash Karat an idiot who is enjoying with Brinda in western world. Pls tell them whats their qualification and why they left their job and whats their bank balance. Tell them to compare their life style and financial status with other leaders of other political parties, except left. Many ministers in West Bengal are carrying tea in the flask from their residence and serve to guests coming to their office. This is not reported by a CPM paper but BJP supported Indian Express and Times. When these guys use abusive languages definitely others supporting left parties will not keep mum. So, pls use such a method that, when an abusive language comes it should not be printed.
