Indian should have confidence for their scientists to achieve nuclear technology. Relying on others, especially US, India will never shining or rise as a real power. Obviously, US is using Hyde Act to control India as its toy. India will shining with indian scientist, not others.
RE:believe Indian
by lancer on Feb 16, 2008 12:44 AM Permalink
grove indian nuclear science is far superior than american's(ask americans) but where do we have uranium? how to close the fuel cycle ?
RE:believe Indian
by Manish Ahuja on Feb 16, 2008 01:08 AM Permalink
Lancer, could you tell me which American says that Indian nuclear science is far superior. I would like to read that article. Thanks!
RE:believe Indian
by A S on Feb 16, 2008 01:15 AM Permalink
You must be one the jokers who circulate mails which say 35% of all NASA scientists and 110% of all doctors in America are Indians ; not to forget the 30% programmers in Microsoft being Indians.
RE:believe Indian
by raj sreedhar on Feb 16, 2008 01:38 AM Permalink
CarrotAndStick , You are right. Far exagurated figures. Empty vessals makes more noise. Don't forget US is still the land of opportunity for Indians. NOT RUSSIA and CHINA.
RE:RE:believe Indian
by raj sreedhar on Feb 16, 2008 01:40 AM Permalink
lancer , Which American told you that. One hell of BS story. America have contributed a lot in scientific field. Don't be egostic.
RE:believe Indian
by Maharaj Malik on Feb 16, 2008 03:23 AM Permalink
gulti raj..kabhi tu porai kiya nehi..hamedsha US uS korke bhagta raha...aur US jake 5 in one room korke raha..dimak to hai nehi kuch programing kor leta hoga..apni desh ka history bhi por liya kor..nehi to US ka history pore..woh jada nehi 400 sal ki hai
RE:believe Indian
by Loan Shark on Feb 15, 2008 11:53 PM Permalink
US is not planning to control India in any way ... there is no point in reinventing the wheel ... the technology is there ... it is not new technology ... US is willing to share and we don't have to waste time in creating it.
Imagine if we waited for our own guys to develop computers rather than buy designs and technology from US to build them in India ... if that had happened, India would be so far behind in IT.
RE:believe Indian
by Somesh Kataria on Feb 16, 2008 12:44 AM Permalink
i feel in the short term it will solve our energy problem but in the long term we should have our own new reactors using thorium as the fuel. we cannot depend upon others for uranium. for eg if India conducts pokhran 3 i am sure India will be denied nuclear fuel (economic sanctions)...so what is the point of making such a big spending on the infrastructure now ?
RE:believe Indian
by shailesh iyer on Feb 16, 2008 07:21 AM Permalink
i dont think it is a question of reinventing wheel - it is how much we need? how much we can provide from our side? what is the best deal that i can get for the rest? blaming our scientist is not a wise thing whereas creating a new nuclear industry without or little foriegn help is good. it is always good to eat within means rather than borow and eat from others.
RE:believe Indian
by Xiao Grove on Feb 16, 2008 01:31 AM Permalink
While US did not say that in paper, the Hyde Act in fact would limited India to develop nuclear strategic force or options. Inventing Nuclear technology is much complicate than inventing wheel. Such comparison is improper and misleading. Fundamentally, India need to rely on indian scientist for nuclear technology. If india focus on developing nuclear technology, I believe much better nuclear deal will surface. If you are waiting on other's food to feed you, the price of food would definitely much higher than you have your own supply, just need something else from others.
