Any discussion between a country and a world body is confidential. No outside third party can have access to it. That is the law, especially in IAEA. What is the point of discussing on it over and over again when it is amply clear that third party access is not permitted? Mr. Mukherjee said VERY CLEARLY that any one want to have access to the document will have to join the government in the process. The attitude of the left leaders have always been the same: don't be involved in any process in a responsible manner but always create trouble for those who are working on something. There could be only one response to this: f... off and that is exactly what Congress is saying to the left.
RE:Confidentiality
by bhujanga subannachar on Jul 09, 2008 11:12 AM Permalink
If IAEA document is a confidential one then no CONGRESS man including madam Italian Gandhi PM in defacto should have any access to it. If any Government joining the process can have the access to it why not the entire parliament?.Any TOM DICK and HARRY can be a minister, Party President of ruling party in such a case how can such document become confidential document from execution poit of view.Once the document is signed the consequences are on the entire country hence the entire parliament is responsible.Thus such documents can not come under the perview of confidetiality.Lookmwhat happened in case of Bofors confidentiality. Entire country was cheated but still the personilities of Bofors scandal have been provided the reigns though by birth one of them is not Indian National.Mr. Mukharjee has been misleading the nation by such statements.Government is duty bound to keep the entire document to the parliament so that at least few sensitive parliamentarians can understand the implication of such documents and provide a right lead. Such sensible people do exist in tresury benches as well as in opposition. Cheap political game at this hour is shameful
RE:Confidentiality
by Sudip Bhattacharjee on Jul 09, 2008 12:39 PM Permalink
In ideal world the document should be accessible to the entire nation. I agree with your on that point. But we live in a world less than perfect. So why complaining? BTW: party president don't have access to the document. ONLY those who are involved in negotiations have the access. That is why Mr Mukherjee is asking the left to do: join in the process. Why do you want to poke your nose without taking any responsibility?
