DEAR FRIENDS. India is a Major country in the world. we can develop our own, technologies without U.S.A HELP. For power,NOT ONLY NUCLEAR , WIND POWER IS A SUCCESS FULL STORY, WE HAVE ENHANCE THE SAME.
SECONDLY, WE SHOULD NOT AGREE FOR NOT TESTING ATOMIC BOMB. WHY WE SHOULD. PL NOTE AMERICANS WANTS BUSINESS. NOT INDIA.
PL NOTE EVERY BODY THOUGHT, WE CAN NOT COMPETE, IN FREE ECONOMY. INDIANS SUCCESSFULLY, COMPETED, NOW WE ARE MAJOR, IN STEEL, ALUMINIUM, OTHER METAL INDUSTIES.
WE ARE FAILURE IN ONLY, FUEL INDUSTRY, PL NOTE CHINA IS ALREADY STARTED DRILLING IN CUBA,SUDAN,NIGERIA FOR FUTURE FUEL. why we can not start.
We shuld be futuristic, at least for 25 years.
Regards MAHESHWAR HOGARTI BE(Mech).MBA. PGDCP
WORKING IN AFRICAN COUNTRY MY EMAIL ID:- maheshhogarti@rediffmail.com seconf:-mahogarti@yahoomail.com
RE:nuclear deal with u.s.a.
by kapil on Aug 21, 2007 11:27 AM Permalink
who will invest our own technologies? You or your family? Think practically man....
RE:nuclear deal with u.s.a.
by wani bhardwaj on Aug 21, 2007 04:15 PM Permalink
Take unaccounted money of Indian Industrialists and politicains. It is enough for all the developements for India
RE:nuclear deal with u.s.a.
by Amrit Singh on Aug 21, 2007 11:47 AM Permalink
Off course the govt will. The deal is worth 150 billion dollars. Who is spending that You or your family? dont ask idiot questions
RE:RE:nuclear deal with u.s.a.
by Raj on Aug 21, 2007 02:32 PM Permalink
But the investment saves India 150 billion dollars in 10 years. We will spend that much money if we keep paying @ 65 dollars per barrel, and mybe 1000 times more if the oil price rises in the next 10 years....u idiot
RE:nuclear deal with u.s.a.
by bhushan mudholkar on Aug 21, 2007 11:32 AM Permalink
check the things to reality...... india is generation behind the US technologies.so don't live in a bubbly world.we see the things coming out of a factory in india but most of the machneries and the technologies are still imported.if india wants to keep pace with the world leading countries , join with US otherwise make the generation gap two fold in coming future.
RE:nuclear deal with u.s.a.
by Amrit Singh on Aug 21, 2007 11:53 AM Permalink
Y dont u believe in our scientists. India is not getting space technology from US. Still we are one of the nine nations to have sattelite and rocket launching capability. Dont underestimate. where there is a will there is a way. After seeing the amricans use the Atom bombn. Russians in just four years developed there own. Its the will man. I think the will rite now of the govt is to sign the deal not to develop the technology indigeneouly as has been advocated by APJ abdul kalam,
RE:nuclear deal with u.s.a.
by vikas sethi on Aug 21, 2007 12:00 PM Permalink
My contention to all those who oppose the deal is very simple and plain. If someone has already invented a circle, why should we waste time, money and effort to reinvent the same. Buy off the technology and then use our brains and money to move forward from there. We will reach up higher,faster and surer. We need to think of our growth and of our self interest.A ship is always safe at the shores or in the dockyard but that is not what it is built for. Let us show more confidence and belief in our own country and in its abilities.
RE:RE:nuclear deal with u.s.a.
by vikas sethi on Aug 21, 2007 12:11 PM Permalink
The N deal opens up dual use tech for use of ISRO, defence industry and Civilian nuclear section.
ISRO is handicapped due to denial of advanced technology(we made progress but the progress is limited and very slow to say the least.), our indigenious defence projects r stymied bcos we do not get dual use tech.Ever thought why after 20 yrs, we still do not have our own planes (for training r lying in junkyards), tanks (arjun tank is a failure)or ships.
No one is denying that our scientists r well qualified & we r all proud of them. They have done well with all the known limitations.But with latest available tech, they will come to world standards and then compete with the best in the world. Imagine the progress they will make & their contribution when they have the latest technology to back their brains. Please do not rest on past laurels. Sky is the limit.
RE:RE:nuclear deal with u.s.a.
by bhaskar datta on Aug 21, 2007 01:32 PM Permalink
But y do we need to re-invent a technology when we are being offered a developed one?
RE:nuclear deal with u.s.a.
by Surjyabrat Buragohain on Aug 21, 2007 12:28 PM Permalink
Who says India is forbidden to conduct N-Tests? The agreement does not say that India cannot conduct N-Tests. It has a provision which says that in the event India conducts a N-Test, US can come out of the treaty and that too only after the reasons for the test provided by India are untenable. Then the US can give notice to India. There is nothing wrong in it. If you have gone to a business school (as you mention that you have done MBA), I am sure you learnt that in negotiations there are always give and take. US govt. is also accountable to its citizens and has to justify why they accept India conducting a N-Test. So if India can provide good reasons which allow the US govt to convince their citizens, they will not scrap the deal. So there is no ban on India conducting N-Test. It is the leftists and the rightists of our country who are spreading these wrong notions.
RE:nuclear deal with u.s.a.
by vikas sethi on Aug 21, 2007 12:51 PM Permalink
2 add to Mr Surjyabrat,even 2day if we conduct test, we face sanctions as any other country in world. We faced sanctions & came out of it in two years. 2day,world is interdependent. US is also dependent on India for many things. So costs of imposing sanctions on India will effect US 2. It is not 1way street anymore. What we r doing by this deal is increasing the costs for the US to go against us. India cannot remain in isolation in world if we want to rise. We 've not signed NPT.U must realise that the world cannot change laws just to accomodate India. Yet this is precisely what is being done with NDeal.It favors India even when we hv not signed NPT.
RE:RE:nuclear deal with u.s.a.
by vikas sethi on Aug 21, 2007 12:51 PM Permalink
Remember, every negotiation involves an element of give & take. 2nd we do not need permission from US to conduct tests. BJP after the 1998 N tests committed to unilateral moratorium on N testing. But we reserve right to test if China/Pak do it. So, we can still test N device if Pak/China do it, but US will act as per its laws which is its right. What the N deal says is that US cannot immediately withdraw fuel from us but gives a 1 year period (this is cooling period when things will cool down, a byepass so to say). Also, US must 1st give reason. If reason is due to Pak/China tests then the US must take that into consideration.(If these two test then sanctions will apply on them also).If still US wants to withdraw then it makes alternative arrangements for India & cannot withdraw till other arrangements r made. Under the compulsions this is a good deal.What else do you want in it?
RE:nuclear deal with u.s.a.
by Surjyabrat Buragohain on Aug 21, 2007 01:26 PM Permalink
Mr. Sethi, thanks for elaborating further on the N-Test matter and also highlighting the relevant terms of the 123 agreement. This is what the Leftists and the Rightists are trying to hide away from common man's eyes by their rhetorical statements. In today's world we cannot only get everything without giving away something and this N-Deal is actually all about India getting the most without giving much.
