This Dak guy is absolutely correct in one respect - Indian democracy has failed the masses abysmally - it created more folks living in abject poverty than existed before independence. But is it the fault of democracy or the fault of govt run by uncaring, useless, gutless, inept, self-centered, criminally-corrupt megalomanic politicians who've purlioned and perverted the entire democratic process for their own selfish ends? He may be also right in saying that the caste system will never be eliminated vluntarily. But does Indian need to go their 60s Cultural Revolution route and butcher tens of millions of civilians like Mao did?? The questions need no answer - purely rhetorical, right?
I am a Chinese lived in the east of China. My brother had many business affiars with his India parternars. I beleive that it is a peaceful trend that China and India become friendly neighbour in this centry. It is due to the profits of our two nations. The Dalai Lama is not a trust person as he had shown to the international society. Before 1949, Dalai and his clique controled the terrain and serf in tibet. After people's Republic of China was founded, the slavery regime had to be abolished. So their exil experiece is due to their political aim and profits actually. Several decades passed, the 2nd and 3rd generations of exil Tibetans become hoodlum and gangster. Dalai clique lead the violent in Tibet at first, many guiltless civilians was killed and hurt. But the western media hadn`t reported the trues. Indeed, the western cournties does no like to see a stronger China and a stronger India. The western media is sevice for the benifit for their own courty but no the justice and truth. Most of the video and photo about the Tibet rebellion had been recombinated and modified. China government has no choice but only to limit this event even to use army. Both Dalai lama and Chines government claim that Tibet is a part of China, no country in the world admits tibet as an independent courty. China will try its best to solve the border issue with India by dialouge but not army.
RE:Peaceful Protests should not be suppressed
by David Dak on Mar 22, 2008 05:13 PM Permalink
Are you blind? they were not peaceful but brutal. They killed Chinese and burnt shops and schools. Western media lie. There are more than 100 countries have express supports to China. Nancy Pelosi is a fool. She does not know how to handle the foriegn affairs. She is an arrrogent fool. Bush has not said anything. He is USA president. Only he can represent USA. By the way up to now only a few western countries tried to stir up Tibet issues. Most developing countries including Russia have voiced support to China's effort to against Tibetan terrorists. It is wise that India did not stand with the west. It serves India's interests not against China on Tibet Issue. Only those ill-informed and uneducated Indian follow the west to bash China.
The fact that so many US officials have been meeting Dalai Lama,itself is a testimony of the importance they attach to the recent protests in Lhasa vis-a-vis the brutal force used by China to quel the riots.It appears that the world attention started its focus on the development in Tibet and Chinese cannot ignore it. Once the world opinion goes against it, then things will be too hot for them to handle.It is in the fitness of things that they should act fast and invite Dalai Lama for talks.He has already expressed his willingness to talk to the Chinese to find a solution.The political leadership in China should not let this chance go out of their hands.Indpendence demands may be watered down but then they have to agreed to grant some sort of autonomy to the roof of the world.Chinese must understand that in this era of globalization,they cannot hold fast to anything with brutal force.Once the public opinion goes against them, then many dormant ethnic groups will rise against them. The Chinese are unot unitary country and multiple cultures and ethnic groups forming their populace,it would be easy for them to rise against the authoritarian regime.China has done well in the recent times when they open up their economy following widespread changes in the world.Its welcomed by the world at large and the Chinese goods once boycotted found its market all over the world.These goods became popular both for quality and price.This one factor should work for a solution in Tibet.Act fast.
World should boycott olympic 2008 to be held in China. it is cruelty of chines govt. not only in Tibet but also in China, India should take lead in boycotting 2008 olympic in China. Don't participate under the pretex of this or that, but be firm to boycott 2008 games. Opportunity will come today or tomorrow, but Chines cruelity will not stop unless we people teach them lesson. BOYCOTT 2008 OLYMPICS IN CHINA. BOYCOTT 2008 OLYMPICS IN CHINA. BOYCOTT 2008 OLYMPICS IN CHINA. BOYCOTT 2008 OLYMPICS IN CHINA. BOYCOTT 2008 OLYMPICS IN CHINA.
RE:Boycott olympic 2008
by BIJU KRISHNAN on Mar 21, 2008 01:44 PM Permalink
India shd boycott - atleast we dont suffer the shame of being not able to bring even a single gold. I too take the blame since I too cant bring one.
Communism as an ideology is dead.It does not exist anywhere in the world. World has found out that communism is practically worse than fascism. The type communism that exists in China and Cuba are dictatorship and Fascism. There is not an iota of ideology existing there. The same thing exists in India also. Indian communists are more fascist than their foreign counterpart.Look at Kerala Communist leaders and Bengal leaders. They live the life of Capitalist. They amass weal;th and kill their opponents
RE:Communism is worse than fascism..Communist leaders are worse than Hitler and Mussolini
by al balkiah on Mar 21, 2008 01:11 PM Permalink
Do only the communists live such a life? In fact, all the govts. in the world are more or less corrupt. Is there any democracy in India also, in the true sense of the term? You come out to speak the truth and you will be jailed.
RE:Communism is worse than fascism..Communist leaders are worse than Hitler and Mussolini
by David Dak on Mar 22, 2008 04:58 PM Permalink
You are dreaming, my India friend. Communism has not died. Communism is the future of India. India can not eliminate caste system unless India has a Cultural Revolution like China in 60 and 70's. India can not develop with the speed like China unless India become a communism country because only communism care those poor Indian. Indian has so big poor population and only communism can save India. India's democracy is a failed one and not one poor country can be successful with democratic system, not one in the world. Only when the country gets rich and wealthy, democracy can apply. Indian are intellegent people. You should figure out such fact and truth by yourself by now. How come you guys still dreaming, still think your system works? Wake up!!!
RE:Sangh Parivar, Dalai Lama, Americans are united to implement american democracy in china, what they imposed in iraq. WHAT A SPIRITUALITY!
by raj kumar on Mar 21, 2008 12:51 PM Permalink
what is Chinese democracy? Tinamaen sqaure type? Indian communists are blind.Communism is worse than Hitlers democracy . .In American democracy you are allowed to protest.But in Chinese communism if you protest, you will be rolled over by tanks like in Tinamen Square and Tibet. American democracy is 100 times better than chinese communism. A miniscule type of chinese communism is vitnessed in Kannur,Kerala
RE:Sangh Parivar, Dalai Lama, Americans are united to implement american democracy in china, what they imposed in iraq. WHAT A SPIRITUALITY!
by Ariel Katz on Mar 21, 2008 12:52 PM Permalink
THe idiot is back. Either Sahadevan is a moron or in any case is fit to be put in a mental asylum. China does not give a damn to world opinion or for human rights. It is a rogue state. And members of the Communist Party Idiots (CPI)of which KArat, Sahadevan and his ilk extend support to the atrocities committed.
RE:Sangh Parivar, Dalai Lama, Americans are united to implement american democracy in china, what they imposed in iraq. WHAT A SPIRITUALITY!
by talk cool on Mar 21, 2008 01:00 PM Permalink
the last person China blames is India. We have such a great NEUTRAL record.
RE:Sangh Parivar, Dalai Lama, Americans are united to implement american democracy in china, what they imposed in iraq. WHAT A SPIRITUALITY!
by R A Swaminathan on Mar 21, 2008 01:44 PM Permalink
sahadevan ?u are back again with your antinational-prochinese blabberings.persons like u should be kicjed out of india and sent to china which is your father/motherland.pl let only indians live in india. i am sure ur name is original.must be a facade. can i see a reply from u condemning the chinese for claiming arunachal and also tibet which is a seprate country bartered away by nehru in that graet betryael.he was amply rewarde by chinese aggressins and now their claim on indian territory and arming our neighbours against us. indians,let us unite to defeat chinese expansionism.
RE:Sangh Parivar, Dalai Lama, Americans are united to implement american democracy in china, what they imposed in iraq. WHAT A SPIRITUALITY!
by Hum Hindustani on Mar 21, 2008 12:52 PM Permalink
Ho Ho Ha Ha !!!!! What a PJ...!!!!
RE:Sangh Parivar, Dalai Lama, Americans are united to implement american democracy in china, what they imposed in iraq. WHAT A SPIRITUALITY!
by Erasmus on Mar 21, 2008 12:34 PM Permalink
I agree foreign policy is difficult to comprehend. But its not a "kichdi" or curd rice that you mix everything up.
RE:RE:Sangh Parivar, Dalai Lama, Americans are united to implement american democracy in china, what they imposed in iraq. WHAT A SPIRITUALITY!
by abdul on Mar 21, 2008 01:25 PM Permalink
wah wah....
RE:Sangh Parivar, Dalai Lama, Americans are united to implement american democracy in china, what they imposed in iraq. WHAT A SPIRITUALITY!
by Sahadevan KK on Mar 21, 2008 12:41 PM Permalink
Leaders do not know. but people know everything.
It is in India`s interest to actively negotiate for Tibet's autonomy and freedom.
It is a major foreign policy tool, strategically speaking for the Indians to show the world that they have arrived.
Those who live in fear of china and think of pleasing. This is exactly what we did in 1950`s when we have them a free run and they stabbed us with 1962. They will do that once more in Arunachal- Tawang.
So wake up, smell the reality. A free tibet is right for tibetans. A free tibet is right for India.
RE:RE:Tibet and INdia
by Birajashis Pattnaik on Mar 21, 2008 01:08 PM Permalink
I compltely agree with you. I do not understand , why India's approach in Tibatian policy is so timid? Just do a tit for tat approch who betrayed us.
