Comrades are acting desparately and out of frustration of losing the trust vote, they expelled the Speaker. Somnath Chaterji conducted very decently and he deserves to continue his term as a speaker. If the expert views support his continuation, it is perhaps good.
RE:CHOMNATH DHAA.
by arkit on Jul 23, 2008 09:53 PM Permalink
There is no head and tail relation of your views. Keep taking medicines for your mental illness
RE:RE:CHOMNATH DHAA.
by neelima neelima on Jul 23, 2008 09:54 PM Permalink
You are a nitwit. How many times can you post this nonsense?! You are only exhibiting your ignorance.
RE:CHOMNATH DHAA.
by patriotsunite on Jul 23, 2008 10:06 PM Permalink
writing everything in caps doesn't make your view more clear, more louder or any more important that any other view here.
On the contrary, I as a principle never read people who write in caps as it is a) abusive b) difficult to read.
Earth is too bad for these great dignitaries. Wish them to be in heaven Lalu Mulayam Mayawati Karunanidhi Jayalalitha Advani Manmohan Sonia Amar Singh Jyoti Basu Prakash Karat Brinda Karat
Leader we need here on earth CB Naidu N Modi Buddha Bhattacharya Chidambaram
Today LEFT said on Expeling of Somanath that we Know somanath behaved as per INDIAN constitution but our party has its own constitution which is above INDIAN constitution so we expelied him from party. Again LEFT prooved they dont have any faith in INDIA and Indian constitution so why they cry for foule play in trust vote; congress also can say we have our own constitution... LEFT must take in MIND now one here is above country and country LAW
RE:Read The wording of LEFT
by SkShazid on Jul 23, 2008 09:48 PM Permalink
thats the point and i think someone sd take stringent action against LEFt after making this statement. It means tomorrow Left might even say that their party decided to give Darjeeling to China as Indian constitution is not important to them.
RE:Read The wording of LEFT
by Mahesh on Jul 23, 2008 09:51 PM Permalink
Don't confuse with what CPM did with this particular issue. I do support the nuclear deal but CPM has a right to expel the Speaker from their party.
RE:Read The wording of LEFT
by praful nikam on Jul 23, 2008 09:59 PM Permalink
"Somnath Chatterjee might have acted according to the Indian Constitution, but our party has its own constitution and decisions are taken as per party rules," Bose told reporters on the sidelines of a rally in Kolkata. This is not my wordings if u dont belive in indian parlimentry board then why u make that person speekar. Also plaese see PM's wording that left want PM to be work like a BONDED SLAVE for them, WHICH show left mentality
If he ceases to be a party member once he becomes a speaker then why is his expulsion a violation of constitutional convention? If you say his party membership becomes dormant would be understandable. Past Speakers neither became saints nor remained above party politics after the term as Speaker.
Chatterjee became the Speaker of the Lok Sabha not because he was born in a certain family or in a certain province or because he looked smart and handsome. He was made speaker because his name was recommended for the Speaker's position by the CPI(M) which for 40 years nourished and cultivated him. An Indian attache in Pakistan is expected to follow the orders of the Foreign Sevretary and the Minister for External Affairs of India. HE or she cannot say that having stayed in Islamabad for 4 years, he has to maintain the decorum that is expected out of him by the Pakistani establishment. If he or she does that he or she is liable to be sacked. Chatterjee likewise has to understand that he is a handmaiden of the CPI(M) and he is bound to follow their diktats. If he wanted independance, he should have won as an independent and become the speaker. Lamenting and provoking other bleeding hearts to pressurise CPI(M) into leaving him alone amounts to cheating. Like Vibheeshan who betrayed his brother and defected to Ram's camp, Chatterjee should now look for a place in the Congress which he helped prop up and not accuse the CPI(M) of ditching him.
RE:Somnath Chatterjee as speaker
by Mahesh on Jul 23, 2008 09:47 PM Permalink
People think once you support nuclear deal whatever UPA does and UPAs supporters do is right and whatever others do is wrong. In that mentality, right now UPA (including Speaker) can do nothing wrong.
RE:Somnath Chatterjee as speaker
by k viswanath on Jul 23, 2008 09:44 PM Permalink
That is the crux of the matter. You just cannto compare the Speaker of Lok Sabha to a diplomat in an embassy. Please note that the position of Speaker is a Constitutional One whereas a diplomat is just a government employee.
RE:RE:Somnath Chatterjee as speaker
by praful nikam on Jul 23, 2008 09:49 PM Permalink
friend viswanath whom ur explaning they are not INDIANs to belive in democracy,What PM said yesterday that LEFT want PM as bonded slave,they dont belive in indian constitution, they belive in own constitution PRAKASH KARAT constitution..........
RE:Somnath Chatterjee as speaker
by praful nikam on Jul 23, 2008 09:47 PM Permalink
Today LEFT said on Expeling of Somanath that we Know somanath behaved as per INDIAN constitution but our party has its own constitution which is above INDIAN constitution so we expelied him from party. Again LEFT prooved they dont have any faith in INDIA and Indian constitution so why they cry for foule play in trust vote; congress also can say we have our own constitution... LEFT must take in MIND now one here is above country and country LAW
the communist couple is making cpim there pocket party, they can,t contest the election on their own but expelling 10 times MP like Mr.chatterjee,Their party constitution is above the country constitution. Shame on these KARATS, & Comrades
RE:parkash & Birinda karat
by k viswanath on Jul 23, 2008 09:46 PM Permalink
Well said. Now the battle in CPI (M) is between the Bengal Lobby and the Kerala Lobby
RE:parkash & Birinda karat
by hariss hariss on Jul 23, 2008 09:57 PM Permalink
why so? did any party member from bengal oppose the decision? chatterjee became the speaker on the recomendation of CPI(M) which was supporting the UPA govt. When CPI(M) had withdrawn the support to thhe govt, mr chatterjee held on to the post of the speaker, indicating the post was beyond the party... One thing to be noted is tat CPI(M) had expelled him only after allowing him to discharge his duties as the speaker of the house... isnt it... wasnt that because the CPI(M)s respect to democracy??? CPI(M) is a party where no indvidual is above the party...
The CPI(M) has acted so desparately. It had already lost respect at large for its arm twisting methods against the govt. Why against your veteran colleague? It only completes a picture devoid of commonsense...even if the Left's arguments are correct, there is a more sensible and decent way of conducting yourself. It would have probably got more support that way... there are definitely more people opposing the deal. They could easily have been brought together and public support could have been garnered for better representation.
