can we expect from a moronic commie. Does this not degrade the post he holds. Usual commie double talk.The A ole doesnt want to lose his post and unable to control his animosity towards the BJP as well.
Yes, it is true that the utterances of the Speaker of Lok Sabha Somnath Chatterjee has not been taken very kindly by majority of people when he said that he can't vote on an issue along with BJP in the Lok Sabha if he steps down from speaker ship as per dictum of his party. If the BJP is really a communal & anti-national, why did they ban this party? The speaker Somnath Chattejee had said that so long, he continues to be speaker, he will be a non-party person and his action will be prejudice to none and very neutral. If it is so, surely his utterances should not be taken by all of us very kindly and the BJP should move for his impeachment, if he does not step down defying his party's whim. May we suggest them though very much younger in age & being a non-politician to keep restraint while making such utterances that can be controversial & bring bad name to the incumbent of such high office!
RE:Speaker utterances not in good taste.
by Sahadevan KK on Jul 17, 2008 11:13 AM Permalink
The paid writers of Congress and BJP will understand their time and life spoiled by the corrupt leaders. Leaders supply national shame. Try to gain some job, do not confuse poor people, otherwise you will sink with these leaders' ship.
Som Nath Chatterji's remarks are are to be seen in his capacity as a Marxist and not as the Speaker of the Lok Sabha. He is a progressive Marxist and can see the good of nuclear deal and is not blind like Karat who gives more importance to his ego than to the good of the Country.
In the 'Vote on Nuclear Deal' a loss of vote for the Congress would, in fact, be a win for the Congress as then Congress would approach the Indian voter on this issue. Indian voter knows that the nuclear deal is in the best interest of the Country. In fact India cannot do without it. India has a lot to lose by not going in for the nuclear deal. The BJP is opposing it as it is unable to consume that the Congress is going to take laurels and be credited for a deal initiated by the BJP.
Indian voter would see unmasked face of the BJP once the BJP votes against the deal. If the Congress approaches the voter on this issue, it would have voter's confidence and support and other issues like rising inflation numbers would then be forgotten.
So why should the Congress indulge in horse trading once it knows it is good for it to lose as also to win. It is a 'win win' situation for the Congress.
Those voting against the nuclear deal would lose heavily in the 'people's vote' on this issue. The Indian voter would punish badly those voting against the deal.
RE:BJP lashes out at Somnath.
by Raghavendra Ravi on Jul 17, 2008 07:51 AM Permalink
BJP is not really against the deal. But Congress is making it look as though it is a matter only between itself and the left. They never discussed it with BJP. If congress really wants to do good for the country, it must dare to discuss with the opposition ( who are not really against the deal ). Narasimha Rao sent Vajpayee to speak for India when he was PM and Vajpayee sent Subramanyam Swamy to GATT on behalf of India. There is a way to utilize members of opposition in National interest. This Congress is not capable of it. even within congress this deal is only important to Manmohan Singh - not to all congressmen.
RE:BJP lashes out at Somnath.
by cool on Jul 17, 2008 07:47 AM Permalink
Just before all of u go criticizing our PM, If he had it his way this deal would have been inked by now sadly he has his hands tied with LEFT. And he had to bring in the SP to move the deal forward.. IF it wasnt for this man we would still be looking at the BJP oppose a deal which is in ALL ASPECTS a god sent for our energy straved country. BJP should have been much more responsible..
In the 'Vote on Nuclear Deal' a loss of vote for the Congress would, in fact, be a win for the Congress as then Congress would approach the Indian voter on this issue. Indian voter knows that the nuclear deal is in the best interest of the Country. In fact India cannot do without it. India has a lot to lose by not going in for the nuclear deal. The BJP is opposing as it is unable to consume that the Congress is going to win laurels and take the credit for a deal initiated by the BJP.
Indian voter would see unmasked face of the BJP votes against the deal. If the Congress approaches the voter on this issue, it would have voter's support and oOther issues like rising inflation numbers would be then forgotten.
So why should the Congress indulge in horse trading once it knows it is good for it to lose as also to win. It is a 'win win' situation for the Congress.
Those voting against the nuclear deal would lose heavily in the 'people's vote' on this issue as the Indain voter would punish it badly.
As far as Som Nath Chatterji's remarks are concerned, his remarks are to be seen in his capacity as a Marxist and not as the Speaker of the Lok Sabha. He is a progressive Marxist and can see the good of nuclear deal and is not blind like Karat who gives more importance to his ego than to the good of the Country.
RE:RE:BJP lashes out at Somnath.
by manoo kaushal on Jul 17, 2008 06:35 AM Permalink
Nuclear deal has not been debated over. It is a dangerous deal for India in the long run. Anyone who knows about the deal in detail either is silent or opposes it.
RE:BJP lashes out at Somnath.
by cool on Jul 17, 2008 07:50 AM Permalink
So in other words u know more about the deal than our PM, and also Mr Kalam..! WOw.. u r a true genius..!! A true indian Genius just like the BJP ,Only prob is when u open ur mouth people run away..!!
It has been clear that Mr. Somnath,who was once known as honest man in politics , is actually dishonest,corrupt and partial. He has been changing his statements from the day one. I have a question for Mr. Somnath if Government tables Women's bill and BJP supports the bill. Will Somnath oppose the bill because BJP is supporting it ? Somnath is Fake guy, it is crystal clear. Like Manmohan Singh , most so called honest guys in Indian politics are actually more dishonest than others. All that Glitters is not Gold thus goes the saying,nor are Somnaths and Manmohans honest but they are Fake, and puppets in the hands of likes of Sonia Gandhi. Thanks
RE:Somnath is attached to the Chair
by Palaniappan Gopalan on Jul 17, 2008 06:41 AM Permalink
TRUE...................TRUE............TRUE ...............
WHAT TO DO THE SONIA [SUNIA] IS RULING THE COUNTRY THESE THINGS WILL HAPPEN.
RE:Somnath is attached to the Chair
by Prasanta Majumdar on Jul 17, 2008 08:24 AM Permalink
If you go through video recordings of parliamene session carefully, you will find he is the man responsible for everything, he has disgraced the post of speakar, he is the worst speaker of India. He will going to play mischief in voting. Thats why he is not resigning
Upholding the highest tradition of speaker post, Somnath Chatterjee,refused to toe the line of his party from which he was elected as MP. Based on the practices of British Parliament traditions, the Speaker can be appointed unanimously once he is elected as MP from any party. But once he assumed the charge, he is relieved of his responsibility towards that party. The British tradition is that the Speaker is allowed to recontest but elected unanimously so that he can remain impartial to the House. But unfortunately this is not practised in India. The Speaker remain loyal to the Party and he seeks re-election from the same party. That has made the post of Speaker vulnerable in the case of emergent situation like the one faced today. But to the great credit of Somanth Chatterjee, he refused to resign as he would not like to act against his principled stand he took in life. That is not to allign with the communal forces. What is wrong with that stand. It is commendable. See how Karat is isolated in his own backyard in Bengal, that forced him to skip Bengal from his tour itenary. Somanth has also decided to resign from the post by announcing publicly in the House of his intention once the voting is over. That means he will not take part in the voting against the Govt and that is what irked the BJP. They lashed out at him and questioned his impartiality. If he votes with them, will he become impartial then. This is doubled faced BJP and public watching their each and evey move.
RE:Somnath Chatterjee's stand commendable
by Sahadevan KK on Jul 17, 2008 11:13 AM Permalink
The paid writers of Congress and BJP will understand their time and life spoiled by the corrupt leaders. Leaders supply national shame. Try to gain some job, do not confuse poor people, otherwise you will sink with these leaders' ship.
I have a lurking suspicion that Amar Singh (originally a Congressman - remember?)had been planted in Samajwadi Party to destroy it from within,next- deliver Mulayam Singh at doorsteps of 10 Janpath where final Knock out punch will be delivered. He has succeeded on all counts. Wheeler dealer award for the decade certainly goes to Amar Singh.
BJP questioned the impartiality of the Speaker. It is their habit to lash out at every one who does toe their line. Here in the case of Somnath Chatterjee, apart from being Speaker, he is MP representing CPI(M) and a human being too. He has own principles which he hold them dear.Rudy was reading too much into the statement of the Speaker. There was nothing wrong in his statement when he said that he would not like to vote along with BJP. He said it in the capacity as MP, if he resigns and join the voting club. He never said these statements from the chair of the Speaker. The desperation of the BJP is understandable but tirade against the speaker is unfortunate. Even among the own rank and file of BJP, some of the MPs are in favour of the deal and why not when a person like Bal Thackery could support such a deal, what is the problem with the BJP. Their main aim is to topple the Govt so that their grand old man at 81 could be installed as the next PM. The day dreaming of the BJP would remain as day dream as said by RPI MP Alvale the other day. The people of this country wants developments which the UPA alone could provide and not the communal party like BJP and allies. By winning in a few states, they think they can win all over the country. They are totally mistaken as Muslims are solidly behind the secular forces led by Congress and allies.As long as this community support the secular forces, these communal parties cannot come back to power. That is why Advani wooing Muslims.
RE:BJP's tirade against Somnath Chatterjee
by Blue Aryan on Jul 17, 2008 06:31 AM Permalink
No surprises Muslims are always behind terrorists, corrupt and anyone who is willing to lick their a-ss.
No wonder the only self-respecting,dignified Muslim of India Dr. Abdul Kalam is considered Non Muslim by Muslims.
Islam is the only religion which promotes insults towards other religion.
I just wonder if your allha was so great why didn't he created separate planet for Muslims?
RE:BJP's tirade against Somnath Chatterjee
by manoo kaushal on Jul 17, 2008 06:31 AM Permalink
you are aginst BJP because you are muslim, and BJP has questioned your nationality. Their is no real honest and concrete substance in your opposition. Your opposition to BJo is because of your fanatical nature not because political or ideological reasons. Most muslims world over can not rise above their religion and think in the right fashion.
RE:BJP's tirade against Somnath Chatterjee
by All Right on Jul 17, 2008 07:07 AM Permalink
Jamsheed:
a) If I call you a moron, will you not lash out at me? Are you not lashing out at BJP? What does it prove? You are communal? b) Kindly define the word "secular" if you can.
And last but not the least, please don't insult the intelligence of people on this forum. We hate to share space with life forms yet to evolve in the intelligence chain
It is now all clear that Communist Somnath Chatterjee is not a real Communist. He is secretly a capitalist. Now he is ready to support capitalist America. Shame on you Somnath Chatterjee!
RE:SOOOOOMNATH JEE WHAT MAKE YOU TO STICKTO THE CHIAR?
by Pradeep Kumar R on Jul 17, 2008 07:58 AM Permalink
Now communists are not opening their mouth because of Somnath Chatterji episode. He has given a big slap on CPM.
Somnath is ofcourse an intelligent guy , He knows he will not get any seat next time . So better use this chance and be with soniaji. May be next time , he will get a Governer post ..
