RE:But it should be within 27% quota
by siva kumar on May 17, 2007 03:39 PM Permalink
THERE SHOULD NOT BE ANY RESERVATION. BASED ON THE PERFORMANCE AND ABILITY ONE SHOULD BE GIVEN SEAT IN EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTION. RESERVATION SHOULD NOT BE EXTENDED TO THE PRIVATE ORGANISATION. A TALENTED/DESERVED PERSON SHOULD BE GIVEN THE FIRST PREFERENCE.
IN THE CASE BC/OBC/FC/SC/ST... THE GOVERNMENT SHOULD PROVIDE SCHOLARSHIP TO THOSE STUDENTS WHO ARE IN THE POVERTY LINE. NOW-A-DAYS SOME SC/ST/OBC'S ARE RICHER THAN FC'S AND OTHER.SO THE GOVERNMENT SHOULD AID FINANCIAL HELP TO STUDENTS IRRESPECTIVE WHEATHER THEY ARE 0BC,ST....AND SO ON.
RE:But it should be within 27% quota
by kumawat samaj on May 17, 2007 03:21 PM Permalink
Resvervation should be in private organisations also because there are lot of upper class people who are not eligible for admission but they are getting it through donation if a donation wala can be doctor or engineer then why not an OBC candidate by reservation
RE:But it should be within 27% quota
by manish rastogi on May 17, 2007 03:21 PM Permalink
all these percenatges are really confusing why not abolish the reservation or put all the castes under OBC because we all are still backward by our mentality.
Mayavathi's victory and change of mind towards the right direction. We can hope PM and UPA allies may understand the need. Poor has no cast no religeon. Reservation should be based on economical backwardness, appart from the minimal reservation for the backward classes continued until theyare uplifted. BJP is the only party known to their stands for supporting this issues before. Well don Mayavathi.
RE:Simple Solution for the Complicated Quota Problem
by siva kumar on May 17, 2007 03:44 PM Permalink
ITS THE RIGHT TIME THAT INDIA WAKES-UP. NO MORE RESERVATION SHOULD BE PROVIDED.
RE:Arjun Singh
by kumawat samaj on May 17, 2007 03:15 PM Permalink
no problem there are lot of upper class people who are not eligible for admission but they are getting it through donation if a donation wala can be doctor or engineer then why not an OBC candidate by reservation
RE:Arjun Singh
by dp on May 17, 2007 03:29 PM Permalink
then u must get treatment from a doctor passed with reservation card rather merit. Donation will give only admission not the degree as one need to study and pass but reservation is providing marks (killing merit) and a candidate who scores less marks then the standard will also be awarded a degree in this case. Pitty that u can't differentiate these two.
Oh how come you are not aware - Arjun Singh is lying on the adjacent bed to V P Singh. V P Singh for dialysis and Arjun is on drips - what is coming out VP goes into Arjun.
RE:RE:Arjun Singh
by RR on May 17, 2007 03:20 PM Permalink
Arjun singh is such a poisonious snake. Because of him, Congress is election after election.
I welcome the move, I feel that our leadership has awaken. I feel that any one who is having Income tax PAN no. and showing regular Income amongest backward class may be removed from the reservation Quota.
It will help all economically poor citizen of the country as such the moto of the government behind reservation is to uplift economically backward irrespective of the caste & creed.
RE:PM, Advani back Mayawati's upper caste uplift call
by mohd smile on May 17, 2007 03:21 PM Permalink
abb ja ke aayi ADVANI KO AKAL......!! MAYAWATI ji is very smart leader.BJP wale madir ke peeche logo ko bewkoof banate rahe...while Mayawati nicely united BRAHMIN and DALIT to introduce a new mODERN INDIA. YEH KAAM BJP na KAR SAKI.... WELL DONE MAYAWATI JI.
A better idea is to make scholarships and facilities rather than resrvations.Scholarships and Facilities without reservations will suffice. But reservations without scholarships and facilities benefits no one. It is only symbolic gesture.
Reservation per se is regressive. Any selection (whether for education or for jobs) or promotion should be purely on the basis of merit. It is the Sixtieth year since Independence and we still are talking about "reservations"!!! The protections to SCs, STs, OBCs and other castes and communities has seen no improvement in the social strata of the country. Its time to think for alternatives to reservations. Its time for the government to think for having more schools and colleges for education and promote entrepreneurships for job creations.
These politicians have nothing to do with the upliftment of the downtrodden, leave alone the development of the country. Whatever development we see today is just because of the contribution of the private and the service sectors. Apart from the initial infrastructure developments undertaken by Jawaharlal Nehru, noone else subsequently did anything major for this country.
So, this talk of reservations for the poor among the upper castes is nothing but just another "vote bank" creation effort undertaken by these politicians.
RE:Reservations for poor among upper castes
by brahman on May 17, 2007 03:01 PM Permalink
what we are talking about is Education for all..from the primary levels... what is the use for fighting for a reservation in elite institutions like IIT or IIMs, unless the Dalits are able to even do the elimentary education... fight for the basics first..come up in life with merits...then you don't need anybody's mercy for higher education... For your kind information, the government is fighting for the creamy layer (you know what is the meaning of creamy layer - i.e. the richer section of the so called (or labelled) OBC) people to get in to IITs and IIMs with the lowest marks.. You tell me now, how is it going to help the poor unasuming DALITs of our country?
\"equal opportunities to all\" for what ?, I think equal opportunities for all must be assured by the government in education. whether a child is a dalit, sc , st , obc , muslim or from upper cast, also he/she is from rish or poor. because education of the same quality & standard should be made available to each & every child of India & in every state upto standard 10th. because from their onwards a child has to choose in which stream he want to continue his studies. The parents & teachers can also evaluate from his/her performance based on his higher secondary level education & direct them for future studies or career.
we should not try to give equal opportunities by way of reservation, quotas etc. in jobs or educational institution. However, government must try to reach as many as childrens of the neglected communities sc/st/obc/muslims & children who can not be able to complete their education upto secondary level.
If government guarrantees free quality education to all in the country then the problem of reservations & quota can be sorted out.
RE:equal opportunities to all
by bharat pandya on May 17, 2007 03:15 PM Permalink
in that case admission to rich by way of Donation too should be stopped.Merit and pnly Merit shopuld be crietaria. But yes all economicaly poor SC>ST>UPPER>MINORITY shold be treated at par and should be given opportunity to study.Congress and BJP were using Reservation to get votes now they are talking wisely to get votes of Hindus.They were hypocrats and are Hyp. and will remain Hyp.
