Very poor stand by GOI.. Are they behind person who is partially or fully guilty..? How a educated man like Dr. can gave Sim Card without knowing intension ???
Ausse did for their security of nation ...and in braket of LAW only..
RE:Poor stand ....support to person who is partially guilty...or may be fully..
by Indian Muslim on Jul 17, 2007 02:27 PM Permalink
hello manish, he had given his sim card one year back. he is not an astrologer to predict
Dear PM...Manmuslim Sigh.. You can use this opportunity to ask the Australian government to provide 5% quota for Muslim doctors..!! Bloody idxxts...You are living the minority appeasement agenda....too much...
RE:Revolve a license for...
by vinay kumar thakur on Jul 17, 2007 02:29 PM Permalink
Hi,Do you remember Purulia AK-47 arms dropping incident.our able police caught the British piolet of the very plane which dropped the arms.What happenned??This same Congress govt released him and now when court needs him to be here for investigation,we just cannot get him..Minority appeasement and shameful foreign policy is the way congress has survived.
UPA is concern about fair treatment of one muslim terror suspect where as in middle east so many indian migrants are given unfair treatment on daily basis about which Sonia and UPA is least bothered..........!!!!
RE:Haneef Issue
by Manjunath on Jul 17, 2007 02:15 PM Permalink
Dear Gokhale IN MIDDLE EAST THEY ARE NOT TREATING BADLY BUT OUR OWN PEOPLE ARE EXPLOITING US.THE BLOODY AGENTS TAKING MONEY IN INDIA AND SEND THE POOR PEOPLE HERE TO SUFFER WHY EVERY TIME EVERYONE BLAME UPA FOR ALL.BULL SHIT
RE:Haneef Issue
by Srini on Jul 17, 2007 06:33 PM Permalink
Dear Manju, Isn't that the responsibility of UPA govt to stop the exploitation of poor by these agents and help those suffering in middle east to return to India. Victims of terrorist voilence in Mumbai train blast have not received any succor till date, even after a year. In such a scenario the PM's hurry in expressing his sympathies with Hanif's and his cousin's families the very next day of arrest of Hanif, while the Australian authorities were still investigating into his culpability, exposes the bias and highlights the current government's appeasement policies. This can be justified, unless Manmohan presumes that he is the PM of just the Muslim population of India and his government is only reponsible for them.
hum india se bahar rehte hai aur ye bahout aam baat hai ki log apna sim apne doston ko ristedaaroon ko dete hai isse ye baat sabit nahi hooti ki haneef galat hai ya shahi hai
aur hum sab ko uska santh dena chahiye ye koi nahi janta ki vo atankwadi hai ya nahi aur jab tak ye sabit nahi hoota kisi ko kuch bolne ka adhikar nahi hai aur musalman hone se pehle vo ek insan hai aur kisi musalman ko gali dene se pehle ye socha kare ki ye indiand ki pechan nahi hai humare adarniya president ek musalman hai ustab bismala khan sahab ek musalman the sur unki subha gnaga shnan se hooti thi apne aap ko banto nahi na kisi ki mooka do ki vo aap ki kamjoori ka phayada le ye bhoi to hoosakta hai ki india ke against ye sab hoo rahah hai india ne aaj tak UK ya US ki koi bhi fijul baat nahi mane aur progress kar rha hai india unlike pakistan aur nahi bhulna ki UK aur US ki policy hai ki kisi bhi growing power ya economy ko vo age nahi aane dena chte they dont want to loose their position dimag se soche kuch likhne se pehle jo aap likhenge vo sari duniya dekhte hai apni aur bharat ki image na kharab kare jai hind jai bharat
RE:all the indians
by on Jul 17, 2007 02:31 PM Permalink
Ham Anubhuti tiwari saheb se poori tharah sahmath hein. Jab koi videsh jaatha hey tho ki vo zaroor apna sim card kisi ko dekar jayega. Ya tha isko legally prohibit kar dein. Ya jab thak aisa koi paabandi nahi hey, isko galat nahi maanna chahiye. Politics door rakhiye aur apna insaaniyat math bhooliye,Kannan.
RE:all the indians
by Abdul Haseeb on Jul 17, 2007 02:26 PM Permalink
thanks anubhuti for your outstanding piece on this otherwise hate board. i have been living outside india too and know this is very common to share the sim cards and other such things amongst family and friends. in fact, i am using a sim card which is issued in the name of a non-muslim friend of mine.
RE:all the indians
by vinay thakur on Jul 17, 2007 02:41 PM Permalink
Dear Anubhuti, It is not the question of exchanging SIM card only.Dr.Haneef had been to india couple of times prior to this incident and he has made some provocative speeches in Banglore.But taking lessons from such incidents our govt likes to close their eyes instead because it involves a certain vote bank.I also live abroad and very well aware of the working of our MEA and indian missions outside.They are mostly very cold to local indians working overseas.Same beurocracy!! Image of india has been a secular nation where even muslims interest are protected unlike some muslim countries.If we keep on protesting with foreign ministries without strengthening our internal intelligence soon terrorists from across the world will make india base for their activities. Congress govt is acting like Ostrich bird who while knowing danger is looming prefers closing the eyes.
RE:it is purely muslim appeasement
by Ameen on Jul 17, 2007 02:19 PM Permalink
What is this vote bankpolitics? whenever there is some news related to muslim/christian name these people accuse congress with vote bank politics. Why don't you understand if they try to appease minorities( 15%) they loose a big share of vote (80 %). So the people who are silent on this matter are playing vote bank politics.
RE:it is purely muslim appeasement
by Mandar D Great on Jul 17, 2007 02:22 PM Permalink
If you dont understand the dynamics of election process, dont open your mouth using simple maths...
RE:it is purely muslim appeasement
by rijish rajan on Jul 17, 2007 03:16 PM Permalink
its vote bank politics for the following reasons its really easy to please minority imposing the concept of minority in to them(what every political party is doing) The majority in every community never stand organised and togather so every political party try to influance at least one minority
Else BJP will be the sole winner after the 1992 Ayodya issue. (leave behind the 80% vote if they could assure 40% of the hindu vote)
so every political party divide the population based on religion cast for their convenient. if people does not divide they plan some riots(Gujrat, Kerala, and many more) and fill hatred in to common mans mind and then drink their blood.
almost every riots or communal tension was created by politicians for their benefits. if you dont believe so tell me a single one in the resent past that happened for any other reason.
RE:RE:it is purely muslim appeasement
by Saccha Hindustani on Jul 17, 2007 02:22 PM Permalink
Ameen, If they understand this logic they will overcome all barriers but problem is not VOTE bank its HINDUS vs. MUSLIMS!
RE:it is purely muslim appeasement
by vinay thakur on Jul 17, 2007 02:48 PM Permalink
Dear Protecting indians seems to be a laughable thing when it comes from our MEA and foreign missions.They have never invloved seriously in protecting indians abroad.They even let foreign criminals who has done offenses against national interest beyond doubt go off under foriegn pressure.. You guys remember Peter Bleech....piolat of the airplane which dropped AK-47 in our country??Despite court case going on..the same govt handed him back to britain where he is living quite comfortably.
RE:it is purely muslim appeasement
by Saccha Hindustani on Jul 17, 2007 02:11 PM Permalink
kaushik, Think rationally. Every muslim is not a terrorist, first of all. Secondly, Entire world has potrayed muslims as being terrorist and doing all sorts of illegal things.
In this modern era have tried to think what is the root cause of all this?
Firstly, US and Secondly people like you who rather then respecting people evaluate them on the basis of cast/race/religion! And call them secular!
Now bashing congress is not a solution to the problem as BJP and all INDIAN political parties have done same in different manners. If you call saving INDIAN citizen "MUSLIM UPEASEMENT" then what will you call BJPs policy to favour HINDUS in secular nation?
Rather then giving cheap and foolish comments like most of the people on rediff think well and be well educated!
RE:it is purely muslim appeasement
by Shankar Eppoor on Jul 17, 2007 04:14 PM Permalink
Dear Hindutani, Who are planting car bombs in Iraq every other day? Is is by amny Hindu or Christian? For your kibnd information, Congress and Communists call BJP a Communal party but these shameless dogs had not shied away from having an elctoral alliance with various groups of Muslim League, which party is responsible for partition of India on the basis of religion. At least BJP is having Naqvi as their general secratary. Is any Hindu atleast a member in ML ? Will any of the Muslim aided college give preference to Hindu Students? All the Madarasas are preaching hatred in West Bengal where the Communists are ruling for the past 30 years? is it not anti-national.
RE:it is purely muslim appeasement
by Indian Muslim on Jul 17, 2007 02:12 PM Permalink
Its indian govt raising concern for an Indian citizen .try to first understand why they r doing
RE:it is purely muslim appeasement
by chandrammohan kausik on Jul 17, 2007 02:21 PM Permalink
Can any one say that ever muslim has pointed another muslim (ie he is involved in terror activities), every muslim is not a terrorist but What about their loyalty to India? Think in kashmir rs 55000 crores (majority of the money is fron Hindu taxpayers is going to just muslims for simple reason that they call you there as Bharathvasi.
RE:RE:it is purely muslim appeasement
by praveen kumar on Jul 17, 2007 02:16 PM Permalink
ur name should be ideally muslim indian not 'indian muslim' as u muslims rate ur relgion first than ur mother country ..so change ur id first
RE:it is purely muslim appeasement
by Madhu Jha on Jul 17, 2007 03:17 PM Permalink
peep inside yourself first, Mr grat son of india, people who cannot respect a fellow religion can never have respect for anything
RE:it is purely muslim appeasement
by Ravi Kumar on Jul 17, 2007 02:44 PM Permalink
Of course, you are aware that there is an election in Australia in two months time and the John Howard government has done nothing under its 2004 Terror Laws. In fact a former Australian judge has been quoted as saying that the Haneef arrest will go well with the voters. So while it is nice to talk about vote banks in India, please do not forget that just because Howard and his cabinet wear suits and speak English, they are still politicians with a hunger for power.
Such concern for a terrorist... Ok, he may not be guilty(though most likely he is), but then there are many other citizens of India who are languishing in foreign jails just on the trivial matter of lost passports... what has the Indian government done about them...
I appreaciate Indian Government for taking this step. I strongly believe, if Haneef is guily, punish him, should be relieved if found innocent. Let them conduct fair trial.
