This shrine was discovered by a muslim. The descendants of this muslim who now number about 20 families in a single village in Kashmir used to look after the Hindu pilgrimage all these years before this stupidity of the Congress - PDP Government to constitute a Board and to hand over the responsibility of the pilgrimage to this board. The responsibility must immediately revert to the Muslim brethern who have all these years been involved in the success of the pilgrimage. This is the only way to restore sanity on both sides. Stupid Government action has once again sowed the seeds of discord.
RE:Amarnath Shrine
by liaquat shah on Jul 02, 2008 02:13 PM Permalink
it is not conress-pdp government which consistuted the board. it was bjp-national conference. pl correct your info
RE:Amarnath Shrine
by Indian heart on Jul 02, 2008 02:19 PM Permalink
whoever did that.......i just know one thing.....the board shud get the land.....thats it......enough of muslim dadagiri......
RE:Amarnath Shrine
by liaquat shah on Jul 02, 2008 02:25 PM Permalink
who are u that u just know one thing.and muslims dont do dadagagiri. people like u are trying to divide the country. its not muslims or hindus. we all are indians
RE:Amarnath Shrine
by Subadhra R on Jul 02, 2008 02:38 PM Permalink
yeah right. whenever it suits u we are indians. Whenever it doesnt u become the ummah and jamaat. If u were Indians why did the mussies for Palestine, George Bush's visit and celebrate pak's victory in Indo-pak match
RE:Amarnath Shrine
by liaquat shah on Jul 02, 2008 02:45 PM Permalink
not necessary we celebrate. maybe some do but not all.u cannot judge everyone with the same stick mr Subadhra
RE:Amarnath Shrine
by raj on Jul 02, 2008 02:16 PM Permalink
Let me correct you and many ignoramuses like you. The Amarnath Shrine has been there several millenia. The pilgrimage was halted for fear of life and honour by the Hindus and heavy penalties (jazia) during the reign of vandals, iconoclasts and looters from central asia, Mongolia and Middle-east - approximately from 13th century C.E. onwards. It was only after the great Maharaja Ranjit Singh took over the reigns and liberated the suppressed populace, did the rites, rituals and pilgrimages start afresh. The discovery by a muslim and all that is a figment of somebody's imagination and subsequent validation by the 'secular'governments at the state level as well as the central level since the partition of the Indian subcontinent.
RE:Amarnath Shrine
by Mohammad Kashif Siddiqui on Jul 02, 2008 02:27 PM Permalink
your history is a complete Bull shitt, Raj (You must be a sangh man). People of India understrand that distorted mentality peopple (like you) are the biggest enemy of peace adn brotherhood in India. Infact, the History of Alok is perfectly right. You cannot understand these things. Go and see, how muslim Kashmiris are serving/helping hindu pilgrimages who are suffering because of your voilent activities in Jammu nowadays.
RE:Amarnath Shrine
by narayan saipokuri on Jul 02, 2008 04:23 PM Permalink
Dear Shah, Iunderstand your frustration of hate messages by Hindhus. I am curious to know what will be your answer to hard core islamists, SIMI who are master minding attacks and killing inocents . They have become capable of brainwashing even well educated moderate muslims like you.Eductaed muslims supporting and joing islamic terrorism is what worries irritates and genetare hate for islam even in educated Hindhus .
And what will be your answer for recent kasmiri muslim protest against land transfer to Amarnath temple?
And what will you tell about ethnic cleansing of Hindhus from kashmir ?
Bangladeshi muslims comingas refugees to earn bread and butter and then trying to kill Hindhus who gave them food??/
after all these , even the most secular hindhu starts hating islam .
once again, tell em why there is no hatred towards Budhists, Jains, Parshis, Sikhs? These all are also different religions. No one hates them . but we all hate Islam why????????
RE:Amarnath Shrine
by calmer on Jul 02, 2008 02:23 PM Permalink
I didn't know this. However, the families probably have been reaping all the "wealth" from the shrine? So be it. Now that there is a Governmental body to look after the shrine, what is wrong in allotting land to the board for development? The simple fact is that the Muslims have no tolerance and don't want any 'kafirs' or wealth attached to kafirs in Kashmir. And ofcourse our good for nothing government just agrees to any unconstitutional demands! God save India...
