Government must immediately ensure reservation in private sector jobs. The fact is that hardly there is any representation of SC/ST/OBC at management level in any priate sectror company.
RE:Reservation in privatge sector jobs
by Bharatvasi on Apr 15, 2008 04:34 PM Permalink
Do u want to spoil whole India? Develop talent and compete with others dude. Do not bank on quota like a handicapped person.
RE:Reservation in privatge sector jobs
by arun singh on Apr 15, 2008 04:42 PM Permalink
You mean private sector till now is managed by talented people? Who can believe this crap when one finds that hardly a single company in India is world class and hardly any Indian product is world class. Even after 60 years of Independence, private sector has not been able to register its presence anywhere. Let vast majority of people of Indai, that is SC/ST/OBC get a chance to participate in the running of private sector. I am sure India then will become an economically developed country. You can not develop Inda by forcing its majority of people to live a live of second class citizens.
RE:Reservation in privatge sector jobs
by on Apr 16, 2008 11:22 PM Permalink
There are many world class companies. There will be more since the government has loosened its grip on private sector. Just look at the inefficiency in our govternment offices. Atleast spare the private sector and allow India to compete in world market.
RE:Reservation in privatge sector jobs
by atanu on Apr 15, 2008 04:56 PM Permalink
Yeah, after your tribe comes to manage pvt sector through backdoor, it will become world class. my foot
RE:Reservation in privatge sector jobs
by TheOneAndOnly on Apr 15, 2008 05:09 PM Permalink
It is a waste to discuss with these street fellows. Believe in the Courts And Fight there. Did you think they didn't know they are undeserving and worthless fellows ? The Govts Attroney Himself Acknowledged It in front of the Supreme Court's Ultimate Bench with CJI. Did they ask for an Apology from the Solicitor General of India ??
Why do you unneccesarily discuss with these Lost Cases ???
Talent is Running Not just this country but the Entire world. Stop working whenever they want a protest. And Let the Economy go to dogs. They will get to know their place immediately.
RE:Reservation in privatge sector jobs
by arun singh on Apr 15, 2008 05:15 PM Permalink
Atanu, TheOneAndOnly, Dangerous, Why do you hate your countrymen so much? Are you afraid that soon you guys will be shown the doors? Or, you are so much into exploitation business that you are afraid that the new upcoming class will put you to accountability?
RE:Reservation in privatge sector jobs
by Dangerous on Apr 15, 2008 05:27 PM Permalink
which country r u talking abt...its sun going to become a country of beggers...donkeies can never bring abt ny revolution...so dont dream that u all would herald ny new dawn in this country
RE:Reservation in privatge sector jobs
by TheOneAndOnly on Apr 16, 2008 01:13 AM Permalink
Upcoming class ????????
ha ha ha haaaa
It never came. And Shall Never Come. that is what we are saying.
The Fact the Solicitor General of India Admitted in the SC, That with removal of creamy layer, No one will be eligible for admission. Means, No ONE IS UP COMING. ALL ARE JUST BEING PULLED UP. HELD on UP.
AND Leave for a moment And THEY will fall down.
Ask the Solicitor General of India to APOLOGISE. But SC will not anyway change its verdict.
RE:Reservation in privatge sector jobs
by Dangerous on Apr 15, 2008 04:55 PM Permalink
who is forcing them to live a life of 2nd class citizen..beggers cannot be choosers...if they have talent let them fight for the jobs... first deserve then deserve...who said no indian comapanies r of world standard...update ur knowledge...tata,reliance,infosys r better than many foreign comapanies...
RE:Reservation in privatge sector jobs
by Kris iyer on Apr 15, 2008 07:19 PM Permalink
PLEASE Hold On, everyone of you. All of us are neighbours and must share this neighbourhood - india. Arun Singhji, the vast majority of Indians are for a fair opportunity for every citizen of India, from whatever background. 1) You know, we have applied "reservations" for nearly 60 years now. 2) There has NOT been any serious review of the RESULTS of this vast exercise, covering hundreds of thousands of people, who have come through colleges, government jobs, promoted and now some of them are retired, through reservations. 3) Without any idea of the RESULTS, why does the government continue with MORE AND MORE OF THE SAME? What is their MOTIVE? Elections are due this year? 4) If life of the BCs,OBCs,SCs are difficult, life for the FCs is NOT such a smooth ride, as the government and the media seem to assume. Average middle-income FC families are paying almost 40% of their income towards educating their children. After graduating, only the private sector offers recruitment on merit. [ There are many,many able SC,ST,BC and OBC people in the private sector. In the years to come there would be CEOs from these castes.] 5) Therefore, there is frustration on the part of these families against the government, blocking the path of merit even in the private sector. Every other path is blocked or complicated. Now the government wants to bring caste into the private sector also. Is "caste" the only REALITY? Isn't economic disadvantage a fairer basis?
RE:RE:Reservation in privatge sector jobs
by on Apr 16, 2008 11:28 PM Permalink
Any policy we implement must be evaluated for the result and untoward effects it produces. Unfortunately reservation policy is an exception. To continue to do the same again and again and expect different result is surely a sign of mental retardation.
RE:Reservation in privatge sector jobs
by Satya on Apr 15, 2008 09:35 PM Permalink
In fact,economic disadvantage/backwardness and merit alone should be the criteria for 'reservation'.It is a pity that the SC was not really 'judicious' in this matter of allowing reservation for OBCs,since it is a fact that it is the OBCs,especially the rich ones,who oppress and discriminate against the dalits/SCs/STs in the rural areas.As far as the cities are concerned,nobody is bothered about anybody's caste.So there is no question of any discrimination.It is the political mafia leaders who belong to the SC/ST/OBC who want the reservations to continue,so as to appropriate all the 'goodies' for themselves and their kith and kin. If they had any feeling for their less-fortunate brethren,they would not want the 'creamy layer' to be retained.
RE:Reservation in privatge sector jobs
by Rupakshi on Apr 22, 2008 11:10 PM Permalink
Private sector means, no tax money is used. Private funds are used to generate the income from which they pay the taxes. It is illogica to say that if I earn I not only pay the taxes which are used for reservation, but also take what ever money I use to make business for my living should be partitioned. My tax money itself should not be used as legal bribe to win seats in the legislature-that itself is immoral-the second demand has no sense what so ever. You would convert India into Somalia. The only rule you can have is that no one should be discriminated on the basis of religion or caste or gender. Forcing a reservation is not just dumb, it is disgusting.
RE:Reservation in privatge sector jobs
by Dangerous on Apr 15, 2008 04:34 PM Permalink
if donkeys take up the roles of managers all companies would have to shut thier operation in india
