It is shocking to say the least. The maount of hatred that has been spewed in the comments below is simply SHOCKING. Sonia Gandhi is as much Indian as any one of us. And how are these people commenting on partition? If Hindus were killed during that time, so were Muslims and till today they are being persecuted in India. I am neither Muslim nor Hindu and thank God for that! Has anyone of you ever done anything to spread the message of love and peace and think beyond your pseudo-patriotism? None of you will even help your neighbour, forget saving your country. Let me assure you, I am neither a Gandhian nor do I like the congress, but the BJP and its likes are worse for India. Do try and go beyond your religion to see how our pople really suffer. Try organising a programme where you give at least half of your money to charity and then, maybe, your hatred for your fellow beings will come down. Try doing something for your country or just your neighbour before you start questioning the decisions made by our former leaders. If you think you can do a better job, then get up and do it. Don't just stand aorund like we do in India during an accident or a fight "to watch the fun" and "criticise". Do soemthing and if oyu cannot spread positive ideology and the word of love, try, at least try, not to spread hatred.
RE:Gandhian ideology
by Piyush Bhargava on Oct 09, 2007 03:03 PM Permalink
You are niether Hindu nor Muslim,niether Congressi nor BJP.Great.Nobody grudges this fact and you need not mention it.But the fact remains that it was the muslims that started killing the Hindus during the partition.It was the muslims who sought the partition of this country.But you and others of the taliban secular brigade choose to ignore this fact. The muslims till date are now killing not any Hindus but anybody who is not a Muslim. You still choose to ignore this fact. Muslims are behind all acts of terrorism in the world.They are maiming innocent people.Slitting the throats of journalists.Blowing up Budha statues.Blowing up trains in Mumbai and elsewhere thereby snatching away the bread winners of many families.And yet you guys call the Hindus as fundamentalists.Is this secularism.You must be sick.Really sick.After all these killings you still refuse to condemn these acts.A demented mind you have I say.
RE:Gandhian ideology
by SURYAPRAKASH TATA on Oct 09, 2007 02:43 PM Permalink
SONIA GANDHI, PLEASE RACHNA DONT CALL HER AN INDIAN. I WAS HURT. PLEASE FOR GANDHI'S SAKE DONT CALL HER AN INDIAN. IT IS THE MISTAKE OF UNITED NATIONS TO CALL SONIA GANDHI AS REPRESENTATIVE OF INDIA. INFACT THEY SHOULD HAVE THEIR OWN STANDARDS WHERE THE PERSON WHO IS SUPPOSED TO ADDRESS THE UN GENERAL ASSEMBLY REPRESENTING A PARTICULAR COUNTRY SHOULD BE A NATURAL CITIZEN OF THE COUNTRY ALONE. THAT IS IMP FOR UN TO PROTECT A COUNTRY'S INTEGRITY.
IT IS IMPORTANT FOR US ESPECIALLY INDIANS NOT TO SUPPORT SUCH ACTS AS SONIA IS NEVER BEEN AN INDIAN BY BIRTH COZ NONE OF HER PARENTS WERE INDIANS. IF U MARRY A ITALIAN YOU WILL GET THE CITIZENSHIP BUT YOU NEVER BE A NATURAL CITIZEN OF ITALY. REMEMBER THAT RACHNA.
RE:Gandhian ideology
by Sathish N on Oct 09, 2007 02:56 PM Permalink
Sonia is not as much Indian as most of the folks in this board are. She may be as much Indian as you are. When reading history books, I could never understand why an Indian who in connivance with britishers screwed fellow Indians. When reading posts like yours, I can believe that such people existed. But still I am unable to understand why. Britishers and traitors called our freedom fighters trouble makers spewing hatred.
RE:Gandhian ideology
by ramakrishna reddy on Oct 09, 2007 03:21 PM Permalink
Ms or Mr.i dont who you are so i call just Rachna...u urself dont know who u are wether hindu or muslim or a chirstian...becoz all the people on this earth have a name and some religion...so first try to know about yourself and comment on rediff...NEVER DARE TO SAY SONIA IS A INDIAN...
RE:RE:Gandhian ideology
by Aby Koshy on Oct 09, 2007 03:40 PM Permalink
Hello Hot Air,
I dare you to go file a PIL saying that it is a misrepresentation of facts that Sonia Gandhi goes about claiming that she is an Indian and that she should be restricted from doing the same.
If you win, not only will I never again call her an Indian, but make every conceivable effort to propagate that fact throughout the length and breadth of this country.
But if you cannot, dont waste your breath (even the hot air) with grand statement like "NEVER DARE TO SAY SONIA IS A INDIAN"?
You might be hollow, but be kind to yourself and dont advertsie the fact, please.
RE:Gandhian ideology
by ramakrishna reddy on Oct 09, 2007 04:33 PM Permalink
dear aby koshy i think ur the neibhour of sonia or rachna..do u know what is hot air....this is the same fact i am talking about..yes..i cannot prove that sonia is not an india....all indians know that sonia is not an indian...but our fate is that we cannot prove..that is how this country is being ....(i cant use this word)congress and this also our fate that without our willingness we need to accept some bull shit government to rule the country, so poppet become prime minister, we cannot elect our president ofcourse again a poppet, we cannot say not reservations....this is what the fate of our country today becoz of exactly people like you so you can call any body as an india, joerg bush, mussharaf, laden , sonia, hasina kofi annan..if they say..they want to rule this country...its shame to see people like u
RE:Gandhian ideology
by CHOUDHARY NISHIKANT on Oct 09, 2007 02:54 PM Permalink
Dear Ms. Rachna, Pl try to iunderstand theploy still played by the white skin- DIVIDE AND RULE. Which they did it for centuries and even today we still remain as fools due to such attitudes. They will always try to inject poison in our thinking by creating such incidences and then influence our major policies tending to become their econoimic slaves. We as Indians should never allow such peoople to represent our country on world platform. The congress party is IMPOTENT as it only understands the language written on paper having Gandhi's picture.
RE:Gandhian ideology
by CHOUDHARY NISHIKANT on Oct 09, 2007 02:46 PM Permalink
Dear Ms. Rachna, It is sincerely requested to look into the facts without being biased about any person or institution and then only form the appropriate openion. Kindly try to know about the past of GANDHI- NEHRU - GANDHI then only u might change your views which are expressed here by you about Sonia Antonio Gandhi (The name suggested by MK Gandhi to Indira Gandhi after her marriage with Firoz gandhi who was Muslim and MJ Gandhi cleverly put up a smoke screen in front of we innocent Indians. (MK Gandhi belived in Truths is is said.- Does it not indicate a double standard character and we learned and educated still get carried over even today. Courage is accepting the facts as they are and learning from them to make our future bright.
RE:Gandhian ideology
by hardtruths on Oct 09, 2007 02:42 PM Permalink
idiotic crap you are.. who are you to certify that foreign lady.. have you been her PA or her child hood friend..
Just look at the evidence that those protesters had provided..
And dont ever talk of hindus or muslims.. the very partition itself was created for muslims & by muslims, and the killings of hindus is far far greater than the muslims.. and that too exactly done by the muslims..
The direct action day is a most appropriate even to describe those..
its because of you cowards that this nation has been like this so far.
RE:Gandhian ideology
by kp kp on Oct 09, 2007 06:57 PM Permalink
Your attempts of eastbalishing moral equivallency between sonia and Indians, between hindus and moslems during paritions are laughble. Sonia is not just another Indian - that is an insult to Indians. India is not a dowry given to Sonia for marrying into nehru dynasty who consider it their birth right to rule over Indians. Partition was created to create Islamic nation, not Hindu nation. Violence was forced to demand partition and purge hindus from partitioned India. It is a cruel joke to equate hindu self-defence with Islamic aggression. If you are really full of positive ideology, word of love and charity as you preach to others - than kindly try extending the same to BJP, hindus, religion of hindus, people who reject Gandhism, people who disagree with you, rather than subjecting them to hatred and calling them names. So start practicing what you preach to Hindus. Talk is cheap.
RE:Gandhian ideology
by Ishita Sahni on Oct 09, 2007 03:43 PM Permalink
please talk with facts in place. you dont seem to know anything about history and the so called great nehru family. and what muslims are is a known fact. why USA is after them is also a known fact.
people like you have made India suffer for so long. you lack guts, and thats the reason you are talking like that.
and as far as helping other is concerned you dont know how many of us do that. come and see. what you are expressing here is your unability and fear. we are the new powerful generation and are changing the face of India.
