Taslima Nasreen was welcomed by West Bengal Government and treated as a State Guest by Rajestan Government. Ironically, former was run by CPM and the latter by BJP. Both have sudden love for this lady not because she needs help but because she wrote something against Islam. Similarly, Salman Rushdie, another big muslim hater found refuge in Britain and elsewhere after he wrote his infamous "Satanic Verses" a book against Islam. These unislamic persons are welcomed in India. Why so much rush to help Taslima. If she has done something wrong let her face the justice in her own land. Why give refuge to such people. It does no good to the image of India, but it will carry negative tidings for all the muslim world that anybody who writes against Islam is welcomed in India. Budha and Rajascindia beware of this danger. Dont let your antagonism against Islam and muslim ruin the India's secular image abroad, particularly in the Muslim World, where in gulf many of our Indians are earning their bread and butter. These acts should not endanger our brothers working in the gulf countries. Let India carry a message of peace and love for Islam and muslims. These blashphemy writers have no place in the country. Let them write in their own land and face the music, why come to India and create all sorts of problems for already problem infested areas. Indian government will do well to advise these State Governments to keep the Indian image clean.
RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by MGR Fan on Nov 25, 2007 09:37 AM Permalink
Mr Jamsheed, are you ready to say the same about Mr. Karunanidhi, who keeps insulting the sentiments of crores of Hindus. I agree that Taslima must be deported,but same should apply to Karuna too.
RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Bhardwaj Velamakanni on Nov 25, 2007 09:43 AM Permalink
Lolz What would Jamsheed lose if Karunanidhi is deported? :))
I asked him about MF Hussain and he is yet to respond :))
RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by jamsheed abumohammed on Nov 25, 2007 12:43 PM Permalink
Mr. MGR Fan, Mr. Karunanidhi, is a legendary statesman. You cannot equate him with anybody. He is above all, tallest among the politicians. He has a right to express his opinion and whats wrong in it. He never insulted any religion so far. He only expressed his views and thats not wrong at all. India is a democratic country and every citizen has his right to say what is constitutionally and legally correct. Anybody disputing such utterances should fight him equally with facts and figures and quotes from history. Karunanidhi is an astute politicians and his knowledge of politics in unique and unparrellel. Can anybody match his political acumen and satirical comments. Long live Karunanidhi and he will continue to work for the welfare of muslims in particular. Look how he made reservations for muslims and christian at 3.5% in employment and education. Did anybody have the guts to make such announcement. It is only DMK and Mr. Karunanidhi alone could do it. The BJP and Congress are equally guilty of playing caste politics and dividing people, while Mr. karunanidhi and DMK have always championed the cause of minorities and muslim in particular. We are eternally grateful to Mr. Karunanidhi and he is real answer to the BJP in North. We the muslim will continue to rally behind Mr. Karunanidhi and DMK in all the years to come and see BJP is uprooted from the south. All right thinking people should join us in uprooting the BJP from the peaceful south. Karnataka has done well recently
RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Bhardwaj Velamakanni on Nov 25, 2007 02:20 PM Permalink
If Karunanidhi is the tallest among politicians then Taslima must be a Nobel Peace Prize winner Lolz :))
If you say Karunanidhi has not insulted anyone then I can say Taslima is the best human being who didnt write anything at all against anyone :))
RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by arvind rb on Nov 25, 2007 08:34 AM Permalink
Can you tell me one thing that she wrote against Islam ... you have a mojor problem ... You have no Brains .... All she wrote is about Hindus girl being raped in bangadesha nd their plight ....Peoiple like you hate and hate and then you have the counter hate of Hindus like in form of Gujrat... it is always the muslims who start it all
RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by balaord on Nov 25, 2007 08:52 AM Permalink
why cant Hindu organizatons take Bangla govt to some international courts if what they belive in Taslima?when they can do it for so many things,atleast these oraganizations can run some campaign to highlight that "plights"!!!
RE:RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Bhardwaj Velamakanni on Nov 25, 2007 09:01 AM Permalink
By the same logic, why didnt the Muslim Organizations take Taslima, Modi or Rushdie to the courts instead of protesting on the streets? One rule for you and another for the Hindus? LOLZ
RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Bhardwaj Velamakanni on Nov 25, 2007 08:30 AM Permalink
Why the hell do we need to care about the Gulf countries? Which country supported India's stance on Kashmir except Iraq? We dont need to give any importance to those countries which are not worth even a mention.
Talking about Taslima, How come I didnt find a name that sounds like MF Hussain in your message? Is blood really thicker than water?
You guys support Hussein but oppose Taslima and BJP opposes Hussein but supports Taslima .. Big Deal?
RE:RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Bhardwaj Velamakanni on Nov 25, 2007 08:33 AM Permalink
Iraq under Saddam was the only country that was supportive of India and its an irony that India could not reciprocate. In fact Iraq was more secular than any other Gulf country and its a Pity, US attacked that country, of all the countries.
RE:RE:RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Aramac Memon on Nov 25, 2007 08:57 AM Permalink
SADDAM THOUGHT THAT INDIRA GANDHI WAS STILL RULING.. HE GOT SOME HELP IN LATE 1970S FROM INDIRA.. ON IMPROVING INDUSTRIES IN IRAQ...
RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Bhardwaj Velamakanni on Nov 25, 2007 09:08 AM Permalink
Right! We he helped them and he had been sincere and grateful for whatever little we did unlike the other countries!
RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Indo Maratha on Nov 25, 2007 08:34 AM Permalink
Well Said!!A carefully hidden threat to all Indians in Gulf. My request is if you plan to kill them, kill them when they are working. They will goto our heaven. Men who die doing their job go to heaven for us man. Thats Hinduism for you!
RE:RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Aramac Memon on Nov 25, 2007 08:59 AM Permalink
THEY WILL STOP OIL EXPORT AND YOU AND YOUR FAMILY WILL DIE IN STREETS. YOU AND BJP OPPOSED NUCLEAR DEAL. HOPE IT IS OK FOR YOU TO DIE LIKE DOGS IN STREETS OF MUMBAI LACKING IN FOOD, CLOTH, WATER AND HOSPITALS...
RE:RE:RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Bhardwaj Velamakanni on Nov 25, 2007 09:12 AM Permalink
How much Oil does India get from Gulf? If i am not wrong India gets most of its Oil from Malaysia and is now looking at Africa.
If Gulf stops oil supply US will start it .. as such US contols all the oil fields in Iraq and of course we have Russia to back it up!
Who told you I am against the Nuclear deal dude? In fact the day we start using Nuclear and Hydrogen technology in small scale .. we will be Energy Self Sufficient and hopefully the day is not far!
RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Bhardwaj Velamakanni on Nov 25, 2007 09:27 AM Permalink
My dear Professor of the World History, in India all that matters is the final number of votes a party gets - the reasons don't matter! Did you forget to read your books while asking others to do so .. hehe :))
RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Aramac Memon on Nov 25, 2007 08:50 AM Permalink
WHAT STANCE ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT. GULD COUNTRIES SUPPORTED INDIA UNTIL 1989 WHEN IDIOT VP SINGH MESSED UP WITH RUBIA SAIS KIDNAPPING AND LET TERRORIST TAKE OVER...
RE:RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Bhardwaj Velamakanni on Nov 25, 2007 08:58 AM Permalink
No Way! the OIC never agreed with the Shimla accord. Barring Iraq, they have always taken the Pakistani side.
RE:RE:RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Aramac Memon on Nov 25, 2007 09:09 AM Permalink
INDIA WAS A PART OF OIC'S PREDICESSOR (ISLAMIC COUNTRIES CONFERENCE) UNTIL 1969.. DID YOU KNOW THAT??
INDIA WAS ALSO A PART OF EARLY OIC UNTIL 1979 AS AN OBSERVING MEMBER...
India's candidature in oic was supported by several OIC members including Saudi Arabia and Egypt. But stiff oposition from Pakistan prevented India's FULL membership.
DO NOT SHOW YOUR IGNORANCE ON WORLD HISTORY- READ SOME BOOKS..
RE:RE:RE:RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Bhardwaj Velamakanni on Nov 25, 2007 09:14 AM Permalink
I am not talking about OIC membership dude, I am talking about Kashmir - Which Gulf country has support India on Kashmir issue and When?
RE:RE:RE:RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Bhardwaj Velamakanni on Nov 25, 2007 09:16 AM Permalink
By the way - Gulf History may be the World History for you .. but for me, the World is much more than the Gulf!
RE:RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Bhardwaj Velamakanni on Nov 25, 2007 09:04 AM Permalink
Indian needed their support after 1989, for that was the starting year of terrorism and those Gulf countries ditched us royally!
RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by jamsheed abumohammed on Nov 25, 2007 08:42 AM Permalink
Why should we care about gulf countries, ask thousands of Indians working there, particularly in Kerala. In Gulf countries, every body is free to practise religion and never enter into any argument or writing anything against any religion. Its only in India such a stupid thing is happening mainly because of its hate towards a monlithic religion called Islam. Muslim haters should desist from doing it. See how we are treated with dignity and honour in the gulf countries. Our Forex reserve is swelling because of the petro-dollar and lets be grateful the Gulf countries. These are the countries who came to our help an solve our unemployment problem, raised our Forex reserves, made many Indians particularly labourers wealthy. Lets not forget the charity of these big hearted muslim countries. India must be eternally grateful to the Gulf countries for making many of Indians rich and famous. Kerala and Hydrabad are the shining examples of the boom they experienced after their people migrated to the gulf countries. Every third person in Kerala an Hydrabad is in Gulf, labouring their feeding their kith and kin in India. Gulf countries gave us prosperity, lets not forget it. People are still rushing to these countries to seek pasteurs new. Ofcourse, Indians have contributed to the development of these countries, Gulf countries are fully aware of the contributions. That is why Indians are most welcomed there than Pakistanis. Lets be realistic friends.
RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by rangarajan dikhata on Nov 25, 2007 02:01 PM Permalink
Apparently u do not read the news . there are More people who becom paupers because of the unscruplous mallus there who are cheating the indian public , if u see that Andhra pradesh or hyderabad did not develop because of petro dollars it isbecause of the services sector and IT .fter all what do you muslims know abiut services and IT except for seeing the porn sites and hacking others sites .Regarding Kerala , there is no development there except the development of the liquor industry and that too with the money obtaine d by cheating the others .
RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by Bhardwaj Velamakanni on Nov 25, 2007 08:55 AM Permalink
Our Forex reserve is Swelling because of the IT Boom too ...
They have come to us for the sake of cheap labor .. not to solve our unemployment problem - The moment find cheaper labor with better skills somewhere else they will dump India ... We dont need to care a damn about such Unreliable countries.
Indian Govbt didnt request the Gulf based NRIs to gop there .. they went there on their own and they are very well aware of the risks ..
WE INDIANS HAVE GIVEN THE GULF COUNTRIES ( For the matter even the US) the prosperity - not vice-versa.
Indians living in India are more important to the nation than the Indians living abroad.
The same thing applies to me too - I have come down to a foreign nation on my own and its my problem if something goes wrong here .. I can not ask India to change her policies just to accommodate me .. People living in India must be the nation's first choice!
RE:Taslima Nasreen - Persona non-grata
by gopal popati on Nov 25, 2007 02:48 PM Permalink
Hey Jamsheeed, who are you? i don't think you are a indian.Indian People work in gulf only because they are lacking in skill & necessary knowledge? Why should we be grateful about Gulf. None of the Hindus working there is allowed to carry any picture of Hindy Gods. What kind of secularism they have? Hindus are not allowed to eat anything outside during Ramzan,do you call it freedom?. Accept the fact that muslims are safe herein india only because of peace-loving hindus. If you are so much proud about arabic countries you may go there permenamntly.Do not try to spread hate among indian for India.
