Rediff.com |  Feedback  
You are here: » Rediff Home » Discussion Boards » Permalink
  
View : Single Message | Complete Thread | Read complete Discussion
Wrong article, Mr Mir.
by tomcat on Jun 28, 2007 03:28 PM   Permalink | Hide replies

>>> India can only resolve its disputes with Pakistan when there is a democratic government in Islamabad. If Musharraf signs any deal with India in the coming days, the next government will not honour that deal.


Mr Hamid Mir,

If I remember correctly :-) both zulfiqar bhutto and nawaz sharif were democratically elected, werent they ?

Ahh the sweet smell of irony... I just love it :)

Fact is that in Pakistan, even if free and fair elections are held, the people will vote for some radicals (like Nawaz Sharif and his Shariat bills :) )

Fact is, even the succeeding democratically elected govt will not honour that deal :-)

Sometimes, its just strange.. how much you hate us kaafirs.. that you spend most of your money in anti-India activities (eg Kashmir, Punjab) rather than trying to improve your industrial and agri base, so both countries benefit.

And please, dont talk about human rights, ethics, and lack of secularism, etc in India (or the comments here, which are much more mellow compared to what you would find in Pakistani forums). It reminds me of - pot calling the kettle black.

Regarding, Bhagwan Rana, this is an exception to the rule, isnt it?

    Forward  |  Report abuse
  RE:RE:Wrong article, Mr Mir.
by Jack on Jul 18, 2007 03:22 PM   Permalink
Well said tomcat. First Pakistani peoples must be ready for democracy rather than counting days for current dictator. Mentality of "aam pakistani janta" (Pakistani common peoples) should be ready to accpet democracy in their own country. History is proof of whom pakistani ppls has elected and what happened to them.
The first start point for them to stop hating others becuase they have nothing and others are growing.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Wrong article, Mr Mir.
by tomcat on Jun 28, 2007 03:47 PM   Permalink
Mr Mir,

Your intentions are absolutely right, I cannot find any problem with that. I wish you good luck in your struggle against the military dictator. Its good to see there are some peaceful people who are not rabidly anti-India (more specifically, anti-Hindu) in Pakistan.

>>I don't want to start a new debate that who is more violent because i respect all the religions.

Wish you really mean it, and more people in Pakistan were like you.

But to express shock (fake?) on this forum because of a few comments and lecture us on secularism is something really funny.. And this after we all know how Hindus are persecuted in Pakistan. Forced conversions, rapes and kidnaps, etc are the norm. Just the data will prove it - In India, the population of muslims has increased percentage wise, while in Pakistan, the population of Hindus has reduced drastically from some double digit figures to hardly 1% in a short span of time. Cannot deny that, can we?

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:RE:RE:RE:Wrong article, Mr Mir.
by on Aug 24, 2007 07:49 PM   Permalink
mr tomcat we have seen indian secularism when 3000 muslims were killed in india . have u seen such kind of examples in pakistan. in pakistan there were some suicide attacks on christian churches but pakistani government took steps immidiately and punished such persons &parties involved .did indian government punished such peoples like nerinder muddy.


   Forward   |   Report abuse
The above message is part of the Discussion Board:
Musharraf, the last dictator