Ulka Mahajan, if you are reading this, please answer this simple question if reliance doubles up the compensation say 26 lakhs per acre will you stop the agitation and if not than why ?
RE:Ulka Mahajan Please Answer this ?
by Jarnail singh on Jul 18, 2007 06:48 PM Permalink
baby moshay can you tell me why reliance wants land near mumbai@ why they do not go to the backward areas@ the main interest of reliance is to get cheap land on the name of SEZ. till the land is for farming it will not cost more than a few lacs. the moment it will become SEZ the land will be worth crores of rupees. not only crores thouosands of crores. to get this land reliance and other industry people have bribed kamalnath, our industry minister. he has invented this SEZ policy to bear expenses of next election. this is what all game is. do you know under the SEZ policy industry will have a right to build residential complexes and they can sell them. but a farmer cannot do this. this is why he will not get crores of rupees for his land. if they want a fair deal on their land whats wrong in it. if reliance will make money then nothing bad and if farmers wants more money then it is a sin, crime. the way you have write "all this agitation is for money" reflects as they want money for others land. what a hyporcrat reply. shame on you people.
RE:Ulka Mahajan Please Answer this ?
by on Jul 20, 2007 03:09 PM Permalink
If Reliance is so much for India's growth, why are they not making the cost benefit analysis public? Why are they not making farmers (who are investing their land) as pertners into the venture?
RE:Ulka Mahajan Please Answer this ?
by crashtestdummy on Jul 18, 2007 09:00 PM Permalink
aren't we self-righteous today, here's eomeone fighting for the poor and Mr Sudip can only think of money, tisk tisk
RE:Ulka Mahajan Please Answer this ?
by agnibha das on Jul 18, 2007 08:59 PM Permalink
RIL and double up compensation.....haaaa....never will.... 3G CDMA-Tin Gujju Chor Dhiru Mukesh Anil
RE:Ulka Mahajan Please Answer this ?
by Siddhartha on Jul 18, 2007 06:42 PM Permalink
Actually Usha wants to make some quick money out of this. But her dreams will not be fulfilled. Ambanis are doing the right thing. Trying to be Medha Patkar will not help.
RE:RE:Ulka Mahajan Please Answer this ?
by Dipak Bose on Jul 18, 2007 07:02 PM Permalink
If somebody will take your job, kick you out of your flat, paying you peanut to compensate, what will you do?? Farmers in Singur, Nandigram, Kalinganagar, and in Maharastra are doing what is natural because they will lose everything-- profession, land, house, for peanuts.
RE:RE:Ulka Mahajan Please Answer this ?
by praveen kumar vemula on Jul 18, 2007 07:11 PM Permalink
Its not the money paid to farmers who own lands, "Reliance will only pay the landowner but when you wipe out villages after villages and create SEZs, what about the small and marginal people? What about those who don't own that land but have depended on that land since ages? So many people lose their livelihood, homes, shops, temples, schools and many other things."
think about the pepole dependent on the land indirectly
RE:Ulka Mahajan Please Answer this ?
by Sachin Pimple on Jul 18, 2007 08:51 PM Permalink
Dude..Siddhartha; Try to be Medha patkar at least for one day...forget about knowing the meaning of your own name..Siddhartha...
RE:Ulka Mahajan Please Answer this ?
by Simply Human on Jul 18, 2007 07:46 PM Permalink
By statistics alone, the market value of any land is about 10x the book values. SO let reliance pay Rs 1.3 cr per acre to fairly compensate the landowners and 5 years worth of income to all the other people who livelihood is based on this land. All money should be given over a 5 year period to prevent any misuse. At that point, yes, the compensation could be called fair.
