"People are people onnce thay get easy money and opportunities,do you eally think thet will give up after a while?"
Ofcourse yes - thats where the creamy layer comes in - you make it a law to track these developed people and remove them from gifts.
" In US problem of majority and minority is not as complex as india,thus it is easy to maintain track and transparancy of these matters."
well, it is definitely different when India hasnt still cracked down on shameful untouchability and discrimination. There are lot of temples all over India which doesnt allow lower caste and untouchability is ramphant. So, quotas make more sense to dissolve these social injustices than US.
I agree fully with your third point - however they are already in place - tuition waivers, aids, etc. You can evaluate the progress.
