I really surprise when people compare Aneek with great singers like Poonam, Raja and Amanat. Poonam among them is uncomparable because of her effortless flawless singing. so far she has slipped only once... that too due to illness... she must be given another chance. Raja and Amanat come next because they have tried difficult songs and have succeeded more often.
Aneek on the other hand never tries difficult songs...he always takes simple and popular numbers (of the category of below par shows like indian idol, Voi etc.).. and so far he has succeeded in singing well.
But when we are comparing them... I think the credit should go to the singers, who at least try difficult songs.
The best way of Judging should be to call an outsider and let him give songs of his choice to the participants. (The song assignment should not be from the existing mentors so as to avoid more drama). This will be a true test for finding a great singer.
RE:True test
by Abhinav Choudhury on Sep 27, 2007 08:08 AM Permalink
Tu Ja Ke Stage Me Ga, Tab tere ko malum hoga gaana kisko kahete hai, Or tere gaane shunne ke liye bahoot sari dhobi ka gadha ayega, Hahaha hohoho hihihi
RE:True test
by babu samanta on Sep 27, 2007 09:24 AM Permalink
by satya prakash do you have any sense of music. ponaam ,raja is repeating same kind of song week after weel .and evers ong is higly pitched songa and this types of song are i short lived
RE:RE:True test
by randhir puri on Sep 27, 2007 07:22 PM Permalink
Babu ur comments are no more required.Get Lost, No Body needs your comments. Stop sending your comments to POONAM's FANZ.
RE:check...
by Abhinav Choudhury on Sep 27, 2007 08:24 AM Permalink
Also Chk Comments: http://www.besharmiya.com/2007/09/23/welcome-to-himeshs-besharmiyacom/#comment-64
hi, i just want to know if we still vote for poonam and she gets eliminated this week and next time when the votes are counted she gots lots of vote will that be useful?????????????
Friends, Just see how the Fanz of Aneek etc are afraid of POONAM, They r using her Camp. Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
.
Pls Vote and Vote only Poonam a Talented Singer.
Puri and associates:( Maya ji, Mohan, Quamm, Nitu, Panda, Abhishek, Sarojini, rajesh,Nikhat ali,Kaeri, kadambri,manna and millions viewrs and best wishers of Poonam)
I WILL BE HAPPY ,IF BOTH SUMEDHA AND POONAM MAKE IT TO THE FINAL AND ONE LADY WILL BE WINNERS . POONAM'S FANS MAY HATE ME BUT IAM ALWAYS USED GIVER HER VOTES BESIDE SUMEDHA. I ONLY CRITICISISED HER FOR SEEKING SYMPATHY VOTES. ACTUALLY IT DESTROY'S ONE CONFIDENCE . BUT ELIMINATION FROM SAREGAMA DOES NOT MEAN IT IS END OF ROADS . THROUGH POONAM HAS LACK OF OWN STYLE BUT IT IS NO DOUBT POONAM IS WRLL TRAINED SINGER. I WISH HAPPY FUTURE FOR ALL THE LADIES POONAM,SUMEDHA,MOULI ,NIRUPAMA.
RE:RE:HI
by babu samanta on Sep 26, 2007 11:28 PM Permalink
baba abhbnav ,i donot need your certificate but i know god always with me because i am not biased and true speaker.
RE:HI
by Amjad Razzaq on Sep 27, 2007 12:00 AM Permalink
puri sb yah babu kabi bhe thek hona wale cheez nahen ha.es na hamasha poonam or amanat ko critisize kia ha.
RE:RE:HI
by randhir puri on Sep 27, 2007 12:12 AM Permalink
Amjad Bhai Yeh Nadaan pagal Bawra, Issi Trah Sumedha beti ko Bolta thha ki woh Winner hai, lekin Babu ki Bewafkoofion ke karan woh bahar ho gayi,Ab yeh Nadaan pagal Aneek ?Raja ka Bhattha baithane wala hai.Ajeeb Kisam ka yeh Janwar hai.
Apni samjh ke bahar hai.Agra Mental Hospitalne iskey ilaaz baare bola hai ki Yeh tau Narak ka haq daar hai,Isko Paap kamaney do.
