The Minister has since tried to explain it off as the scenario when the Kashmir question is settled - that is when an independant Kashmir is established. This is a view shared by a number of Kashmir observers and political analysts. In 1948 there was even a UN resolution that a plebiscite should be held to decide the question. But this has got submerged in later political turmoil. Now if the plebiscite is held in accordance with the resolution there little doubt that the third option-Independent Kashmir- will be the obvious choice.
RE:RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by vikal on Jan 05, 2008 06:08 PM Permalink
Our history is witness we have never attacked any country and never occupy the terrtory of others and also we have never run a hate wave for any one. you kashimiri are independent because India is an independent country. you can move around anywhere in this country without gun and granedes. Love would be replied love and gun by a gun. We have this simple theory.
RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by junaid on Jan 05, 2008 06:17 PM Permalink
If India is not forcibly occupying Kashmir, then why don't they ask Kashmiris for what they want. If Kashmiris are free they should be free to decide the future of their land
RE:RE:RE:RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by junaid on Jan 05, 2008 06:06 PM Permalink
It is a Kashmiri name. All Kouls are Kashmiris. All Pandits are Kashmiris. Kashmiri Muslim and Pandit unity Zindabad
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by rahul gupta on Jan 05, 2008 06:15 PM Permalink
gr8 then , why did milions of Kashmiri Hindus were massacred and driven out of Kashmir ?????
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by ChamanLal Koul on Jan 05, 2008 06:08 PM Permalink
we love each other all kashmiris and you indians and pakis are making all confusion amongst us ..we will be free and will fight until ages to come
RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by aandhi on Jan 05, 2008 09:47 PM Permalink
Readers Read junaid for ChamanLal Koul. Junaid is a double He can never b true. Not to be true is his birth right I mean religious right.
RE:RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by the nation on Jan 05, 2008 05:57 PM Permalink
that's not hate u a**hole rather our patriotism for our undivided motherland unlike u and ur community members who have proven track record of aligning with murderers, looters, terrorists like osama bin laden rather then with our nation's national heroes like Narendra Modi
RE:RE:RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by ChamanLal Koul on Jan 05, 2008 06:35 PM Permalink
Narendra Modi ..National Hero...National Joke...where else can India be..wish u all the best with an idea of a HITLER..O GOD save INDIA from dividing..i will pray for you even when you dump bullets to our people in kashmir.
RE:RE:RE:RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by ChamanLal Koul on Jan 05, 2008 06:46 PM Permalink
there is only a million population of kashmiris in kashmir ..by your words then no pandit will be surviving...and it was your giv formula to drive us out to give it a communal touch ..ask any pandit who suffered
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by aandhi on Jan 05, 2008 09:50 PM Permalink
Readers Read junaid for ChamanLal Koul. Junaid is a double He can never b true. Not to be true is his birth right I mean religious right.
RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by shanehind on Jan 05, 2008 05:52 PM Permalink
That should be your Dream, Are you an Indian? Pakistan is the Intigral Part of India and will Remain to be, The day will come when the Muslims will be shot like mad dogs in the state, I prey Lord such incident comes and all the ehsaan faraamosh be killed who are a menece to this country and for the man kind as a whole.
RE:RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by DINESH BABU on Jan 05, 2008 05:57 PM Permalink
This column cleary explores the Patriotic feeling many of our Muslim friends.
RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by ChamanLal Koul on Jan 05, 2008 06:22 PM Permalink
your muslim friends in india must be having some feelings ..explore them and settle it amongst your self..well kashmiris are a diffrent story and we kashmiri hindus and muslims do not belong to you or your neighbour ..you dont make us scapegoat and settle your issues amongst yourself.leave us alone
RE:RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by ChamanLal Koul on Jan 05, 2008 06:37 PM Permalink
Then i will not target pakistan you insane..you both countries are the same with same mentality of hatered..get lost
RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by dinesh kumar on Jan 05, 2008 05:48 PM Permalink
if some wronge decision have been taken in past that doesnot meens that it can not ractified today. If you think in same way then dont you think somewhere you want again a pakistat still after geting so much of eduction you think against your own country. agreement can be saked for the wellness of country. Dont you think so
RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by junaid on Jan 05, 2008 05:51 PM Permalink
Yes it was a totally wrong decision to occupy Kashmir without Kashmiris accepting it. India should rectify it..
RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by PKN on Jan 05, 2008 06:14 PM Permalink
Your chances of getting an independent KASHMIR is almost nil. If in the very unlikely event that India were to give up Kashmir, Pakistan will take it over. What is the justification for a Plebisite ? If a plebisite should be held why not one for Tamilnadu , why not one for UP and why not one for Orrissa? If the justification is that Kashmir is a Muslim Majority area why not have a plebisite for all areas with Muslim majority ? But for an incompetent Indian leader called Jawharlal Nehru the Kashmir question could have been sorted out in 1948 itself!
RE:RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by ChamanLal Koul on Jan 05, 2008 06:24 PM Permalink
Incompetent Indian leader is the weakness of INdia...rest than other states in India occupied kashmir has a UN resolution for plebiscite
RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by avinash on Jan 05, 2008 05:51 PM Permalink
Igonrance is all pervading. Mr. Ajit do you know other conditions that came before plebiscite? It was withdrawal of troops from occupied Kashmir. Did our counterparts ( I presume you belong to this country by heart and soul) complied with that condition?
RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by Ajit Mohammed on Jan 05, 2008 07:48 PM Permalink
It is true that Jinnah didn't withdraw his troops from Azad Kashmir, but neither did Nehru from the Indian side. The reasons were obvious. Jinnah wanted a Pakistani Kashmir and Nehru wanted an Indian Kashmir. Neither of them could agree to leave the issue to the sons of the soil %u2013 the Kashmiris - to decide. The result is what you see in Kashmir today. The question of where the son of Kashmir should live and become part and parcel of should not be decided in Islamabad or New Delhi. It should be decided in Srinagar.
RE:RE:RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by junaid on Jan 05, 2008 05:54 PM Permalink
Do you mean to say that India will conduct plebiscite if Pakistan takes out its troops from POK. At the same time, Avinash, UN had asked India to bring its troop level to a bare minimum. The troop cut was to take place in tandem. With Pakistan withdrawing all, and India reducing its military almost all..
RE:RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by ChamanLal Koul on Jan 05, 2008 06:06 PM Permalink
Independent kashmir ..a future reality??long live kashmiris long live kashmiriyat
RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by Shanker Shetty on Jan 05, 2008 06:00 PM Permalink
GIVEN THE POTENTIAL, KASHMIR CAN BE A GOOD PLACE FOR TOURISM INDUSTY LIKE IN GOA, WHICH IS UNTAPPED DUE TO INSURGENCY. WITH THE HELP OF KASHMIRI PEOPLE, THESE CAN BE RESOLVED. SO MUCH MONEY CAN BE GENERATED. JUST BECUASE OF ILLITERACY AND POLITICS KASHMIR IS LOSING OUTB BADLY. THIS IS A GAME OF POLITICS AND COMMON MAN IS SUFFERING! KASHIMIRI GILRS ARE SO BEAUTIFUL LIKE TOMATOR...........
RE:RE:Seperate currency for Kashmir
by junaid on Jan 05, 2008 06:04 PM Permalink
shanker shetty tu bhi zyada daer ander rakh nahin paya apni zalaalat ko...
foolish mujahideens of Kashmir are talking about being a separate country by itself?? Kashmir don't have the required fartile-land and industries to sustain itself - it will immediately become dependent on Pakistan. Pakis in return will take away all the hydro powers for pittance and the kashmiris would be hated all over pak. It is in the best interest of Kashmir that they remain part of India - as they are already getting best possible treatment. They only need to compare the condition of the Pak-occupied-Kashmiris with themselves to realise it. Shame on the minister who could be so short-sighted.
RE:How would a free Kashmir feed itself??
by ChamanLal Koul on Jan 05, 2008 05:50 PM Permalink
Biswajit Ghoshal..or whatever It is easy to sit at home in a metro and speak what you read or see in news.First things First we are not a part of india but Kashmir is an ocupied part by both India and pak.Second we have enough resuorces to take care of ourselves and a fraction of your population as well..we are even economically opressed by India and all of your fund to kashmir goes to army and rest is diverted to jammu..so know the facts before commenting.we will be in a better position than being with you or your neighbour
RE:How would a free Kashmir feed itself??
by Biswajit Ghoshal on Jan 05, 2008 06:05 PM Permalink
You are telling this out of your ego. While with India, you can get yourself good education and jobs in and from anywhere in India. You can explore the Indian market with the Kashmiri products like shawl, carpet etc. Besides who'll protect you if Pakis attack and capture Kashmir?? In your best interest, stop your separatist ideas and take advantage of the booming Indian economy - otherwise you'll only be hurting yourself.
RE:How would a free Kashmir feed itself??
by ChamanLal Koul on Jan 05, 2008 06:19 PM Permalink
why the hell on earth you realte kashmiris to pakis always..we are not pakis and they are not going to capture kashmir ..wehn they will have to leave their part how can they capture the whole country then..it is just your hate with pakistan that you want to make kashmir issue a scapegoat ..go and settle your issues with them .bomb them whatever you want to do with them but leave us alone both of you countries ..we are fed up of you and your hatered..kill each other we dont care
RE:How would a free Kashmir feed itself??
by rahul gupta on Jan 05, 2008 06:34 PM Permalink
y dont u talk about the million of Kashmiri Pandits who were massacred and driven out of kashmir
RE:sala Kashmiri Mother choder
by MP on Jan 05, 2008 05:33 PM Permalink
BINA BAAP KI PEDAISH SALA Tariq Hamid Kaarrah.
Please some body file a treason case against him and shoot him. We should follow the Russian example of suppressing any internal uprise of independence with utter ruthlessness.
All the Ulfas, Simmi, tamils, muslas,kashmiri seperatists, maos should be captured and shot without trial
RE:sala Kashmiri Mother choder
by dinesh kumar on Jan 05, 2008 06:02 PM Permalink
your thinking is very good & its a need of time. otherwise it will be very late like pakistan is burning today.
RE:sala Kashmiri Mother choder
by trikarn on Jan 05, 2008 05:40 PM Permalink
tamils? ur congress govt is depending on the black glass party to surviuve! and when did tamils go the other way? i thik u confuse lanka tamils and tamil nadu tamils. pls be updated in your knowledge of current affairs, before writing balderdash.
