RE:nothing new, this is another Telgi
by samudra blr on Feb 10, 2008 12:12 AM Permalink
Might be he has done kidney trading. What right has the media to call him Dr Horror. Look at the positive part of the story. There were many lives saved by this kidney transplants. Organ trade should be legalized and streamlined. People should come forward to donate organs for the people in need.
My post is only indicative of general publics initial reaction, which later gets tempered by the our conditioning.
It may sound medieval, but it is in a way appropriate to give a punishment by the court somewhat like a lashes in a public square!
The article says, even if he is convicted, at best he would get a 10 year imprisonment. No one in the public sees what kind of imprisonment that it is!
One of the main objectives of punishment is not only punishing the culprit but also to prevent others from committing a similar crime. But where do public see the imprisonment? 40-50 lashes in a public square make potential future culprits think twice or thrice.
When we want to spare the lashes in public, we subconsciously are saving ourselves from the unpleasantness; we are not saving the culprit from the so called inhuman treatment. It is our own fear that comes into play.
By the way, regarding your CHOODIYAN remark, you have attributed cowardice to the entire womenfolk by that comment.
Wearing bangles is not a sign of cowardice but of womanhood in certain societies. My mother, my sister, my wife, my daughter, my friends who are women wear bangles. If it is so insulting I dont mind wearing bangles. Manhood is just about sperm and the biological the ability to produce children. Whereas courage is an attribute applicable to both the genders. And some in both the genders dont possess that trait.
RE:To: Mrs. Chaddha!
by samudra blr on Feb 10, 2008 12:12 AM Permalink
Might be he has done kidney trading. What right has the media to call him Dr Horror. Look at the positive part of the story. There were many lives saved by this kidney transplants. Organ trade should be legalized and streamlined. People should come forward to donate organs for the people in need.
RE:To: Mrs. Chaddha!
by Practicalman on Feb 10, 2008 01:16 AM Permalink
I feel pity on uyou. May be you are the beneficiar from the DR. Organ Donation is a noble thing, but not the Organ Stealing. And Mr. Dr. Horror was stealing to sell them off in black market, not to needy poor patients. So he is a blackmarketer, not a Robin hood kind. He has created a bad name to the Profession of Medicinal Practice, which is being considered more nobler than any other profession. He should hv been hanged to death, cause of many innocent murderings and sufferings ( the one Kidneyed patients ). Everyone should condemned this and should ask the justice to culminate such kind of culprits. Truly he is a Horror, rather call him Terror...as people now think twice b4 going to any doctor.
Probably UPA govt nominate Amit kumar as next candidate for padmasree award, Iam telling this due to the soft corner happening from UPA towards terrorist/gundas/criminals in the last few years. Atleast he will get a seat in contesting next election.
RE:Padmasree award candidate
by samudra blr on Feb 10, 2008 12:17 AM Permalink
Might be he has done kidney trading. What right has the media to call him Dr Horror. Look at the positive part of the story. There were many lives saved by this kidney transplants. Organ trade should be legalized and streamlined. People should come forward to donate organs for the people in need. Even though many people want to donate kidneys for exchange of money our government has no proper law for it. If a donor and receiver are willing for whatever monetory or health benefits each one of them gets why should the government and legal system interfere?
RE:Padmasree award candidate
by Practicalman on Feb 10, 2008 01:17 AM Permalink
I feel pity on uyou. May be you are the beneficiar from the DR. Organ Donation is a noble thing, but not the Organ Stealing. And Mr. Dr. Horror was stealing to sell them off in black market, not to needy poor patients. So he is a blackmarketer, not a Robin hood kind. He has created a bad name to the Profession of Medicinal Practice, which is being considered more nobler than any other profession. He should hv been hanged to death, cause of many innocent murderings and sufferings ( the one Kidneyed patients ). Everyone should condemned this and should ask the justice to culminate such kind of culprits. Truly he is a Horror, rather call him Terror...as people now think twice b4 going to any doctor.
RE:Padmasree award candidate
by ajith v on Feb 10, 2008 08:13 AM Permalink
need to think before going to consult doctors, Dr, Amit, haneef, kafar, tomorrows doctors(Mbbs students studyin in HUbli college)
RE:This Dr caught......haneef escaped !!
by ajith v on Feb 09, 2008 11:46 PM Permalink
Amit cant escape as he is Hindu, Haneef is muslim so he got some type of reservation in the court also.Haneef is a mastemind of airport attach, he is a link to the mbbs sudents arrested from hubli , It lloks like 90% of muslims will be terrorist and India is like Afganistan now.
RE:Amit Kumar is Brahmin
by ajith v on Feb 10, 2008 08:15 AM Permalink
Wallstreet, do you know the caste of Supreme court judg, do you have the habit of reading newspaers or analyse how mnay are from brahmin and from other caste, dont write message blindly
RE:he came to india. Now he must be happy
by samudra blr on Feb 10, 2008 12:15 AM Permalink
Might be he has done kidney trading. What right has the media to call him Dr Horror. Look at the positive part of the story. There were many lives saved by this kidney transplants. Organ trade should be legalized and streamlined. People should come forward to donate organs for the people in need. Even though many people want to donate kidneys for exchange of money our government has no proper law for it. If a donor and receiver are willing for whatever benefits each gets why should the government and legal system interfere?
RE:he came to india. Now he must be happy
by Mrs Chaddha on Feb 09, 2008 10:54 PM Permalink
Bhaisahab to kya sab ko jail mein daal dein. sab hi paapi hain kahan tak jail bharegi ......
RE:Who gonna defend him
by Mrs Chaddha on Feb 09, 2008 10:43 PM Permalink
He is a surgeon and doctor not an animal. Where did it say that he is an animal ?
RE:Who gonna defend him
by samudra blr on Feb 10, 2008 12:18 AM Permalink
Might be he has done kidney trading. What right has the media to call him Dr Horror. Look at the positive part of the story. There were many lives saved by this kidney transplants. Organ trade should be legalized and streamlined. People should come forward to donate organs for the people in need. Even though many people want to donate kidneys for exchange of money our government has no proper law for it. If a donor and receiver are willing for whatever monetory or health benefits each one of them gets why should the government and legal system interfere?
our politians involved in this feel free and will have sound sleep. because he came back to india and india is paradise for criminals. and it seems Dr. manmohan singh personally begged napalese govt for deportation. y that much hurry i did't understand. now soon after kidney king will get congress mp ticket . like sanjat dutt sister got .
RE:now our politians will have sound sleep
by samudra blr on Feb 10, 2008 12:19 AM Permalink
Might be he has done kidney trading. What right has the media to call him Dr Horror. Look at the positive part of the story. There were many lives saved by this kidney transplants. Organ trade should be legalized and streamlined. People should come forward to donate organs for the people in need. Even though many people want to donate kidneys for exchange of money our government has no proper law for it. If a donor and receiver are willing for whatever monetory or health benefits each one of them gets why should the government and legal system interfere?
RE:REMOVE BOTH HIS KIDNEYS!
by samudra blr on Feb 10, 2008 12:20 AM Permalink
Might be he has done kidney trading. What right has the media to call him Dr Horror. Look at the positive part of the story. There were many lives saved by this kidney transplants. Organ trade should be legalized and streamlined. People should come forward to donate organs for the people in need. Even though many people want to donate kidneys for exchange of money our government has no proper law for it. If a donor and receiver are willing for whatever monetory or health benefits each one of them gets why should the government and legal system interfere?
RE:REMOVE BOTH HIS KIDNEYS!
by Mrs Chaddha on Feb 09, 2008 10:43 PM Permalink
This is cruelty. Dont give inhuman suggestions that shames you as a human
RE:REMOVE BOTH HIS KIDNEYS!
by Satish Saxena on Feb 09, 2008 10:59 PM Permalink
Mrs.Chaddha, Is cruelty only for Dr. Amit. Was it not a cruelty when this so called doctor tking the advantage of the poverty removed kidneys of poor people for gaining too much money.
RE:REMOVE BOTH HIS KIDNEYS!
by Mrs Chaddha on Feb 09, 2008 11:07 PM Permalink
but we are civilized people not talibans to prescribe such inhuman punishments. Law will take its course with appropriate penalty not calls for a jungle raaj.
RE:REMOVE BOTH HIS KIDNEYS!
by Satish Saxena on Feb 09, 2008 11:37 PM Permalink
What law and what punishment and what jdiciary. What happened to Tandur murder case, Delhi BMW killing, Illegal shooting of Black bugs by Salman Khan and Pataudi, Salman Khan killing footpath dwller while driving, Desausa drunken driving,and many other cases where moneyed people are involved.We still have to develope justice4 as in America.Justice is fast there.
We must first make sure that this brother does not belong to an oppressed community. Since time immemorial the manuvadi brahmn Sushruta has been cutting up people. We must realise that our oppressed brothers and sisters have a right to transplant upto 49.5% of the kidneys. What the upright Indian Judiciary under the benovelent guidance of Smt. Sonia Gandhiji and others is whether this gentleman belonged to the oppressed classes to which poor karunanidhi belongs and whether he did or did not exceed the Supreme Court prescribed 49.5%.
RE:Be careful
by samudra blr on Feb 10, 2008 12:22 AM Permalink
Might be he has done kidney trading. What right has the media to call him Dr Horror. Look at the positive part of the story. There were many lives saved by this kidney transplants. Organ trade should be legalized and streamlined. People should come forward to donate organs for the people in need. Even though many people want to donate kidneys for exchange of money our government has no proper law for it. If a donor and receiver are willing for whatever monetory or health benefits each one of them gets why should the government and legal system interfere?
RE:Be careful
by Amar Deshpande on Feb 09, 2008 10:21 PM Permalink
Basically he is marathi manus. Whether Raj Thakarey will honour him by making him the Secretary of his party. Because he is MARATHI PRIDE.
RE:Be careful
by Ravi mhatre on Feb 09, 2008 10:30 PM Permalink
Amar u bullshit when one of our brother(RAJ) is surrounded by enemies then u r taunting on him.ashamed to you being marathi.
