RE:And the reason for his defiance after getting arrested is
by kamal jha on Feb 10, 2008 04:43 PM Permalink
what happend this all thing in india now only one side is save from corruption that's HIGH COURT & SUPREME COURT dont b eligate our respected judge withowt any proof. Please...
There is a very high demand for organs. If Dr Amit does not supply, someone else will.
This demand will only increase. If a poor person is willing to give one kidney for rs 1 lakh, whats the harm? Poor man gets the money he needs and the dying rich person gets the kidney. Everyone is home happy, noone is harmed.
RE:Dr Amit is a victim of supply/demand
by kamal jha on Feb 10, 2008 04:49 PM Permalink
dear friend govt has doing more thing for poor people to encourage him but that's a fact if we reachesr person w'll give his all money to all poor's within 3 day the all money w'll get back by reach's by his mindblowing brain dear who all's r poor they r 100% self responsoble for it not any other.
RE:Dr Amit is a victim of supply/demand
by Kumbakonathan on Feb 10, 2008 11:36 AM Permalink
100 % agree with you. It is only media painting a horror picture.
shame on them. they can twist any matter for circulation/TRP rating
RE:Dr Amit is a victim of supply/demand
by amarjitsingh on Feb 10, 2008 03:27 PM Permalink
mr kumba .please note that only blood relatives can donate kidneys.if you really care for genuine patients awaiting kidney transplant then you can give your address and under the act you are entitled for this but your kidney will be transplanted by only qualified surgeon and you will defeinetly get more than 1 lac .
RE:Dr Amit is a victim of supply/demand
by anil neema on Feb 10, 2008 04:18 PM Permalink
If this is such a noble cause, why not we all work for this !! Its a social work with good money !!!
That Dr. horror to b punished severely, his both the kidneys to b removed, n both the eyes to b removed, n both th hands n legs to b removed....n to b thrown on road.. ot show the peoples that playing with the lives of poor peoples is not so easy...
RE:Dr. Horror..to b punished
by Sam on Feb 10, 2008 11:03 AM Permalink
Kidneys removed, hands removed?? This is not an Islamic republic of Arabia. Any punishment given has to be by the book.
RE:Dr. Horror..to b punished
by Palani on Feb 10, 2008 11:08 AM Permalink
yes it is good you bring islam here. anyway for my part i would like to say that India TV has gave this message that the doctor had connection with chota shakeel of Dawood company
RE:Dr. Horror..to b punished
by shobana nair on Feb 10, 2008 10:14 AM Permalink
For the crime he has committed against the poor no punishment will be big enough for him.Shame oin him a trading doctor,who leaves in luxury he earned by the money killing and harming the poor and the innocent who trusted him.He is a shame on human values.
RE:Dr. Horror..to b punished
by Sampath Kumar on Feb 10, 2008 10:22 AM Permalink
Same Genre of people who rape minors and kidnap ladies for forcing them into prostitution.
Our politicians will pardon them. Best is to kill them in encounter...
RE:RE:Dr. Horror..to b punished
by Abhay Kumar Dubey on Feb 10, 2008 10:25 AM Permalink
dear shobana, will he get a punishment? the nithari accused are still free!!!
Getting a convict extradited from Nepal is the biggest diplomatic victory. Best I think that can be managed in current scenario.
Punishing him or not is the matter with Congress' estimated fortune in coming elections. Sonia JI is capable of Pardoning criminals like Afzal, why not this...
There is no doubt that renal transplants are life saving. For a patient with renal failure the chance of living longer is significantly better with a transplant. This is also associated with reduced expenditure over a period of 2-3 years compared to dialysis.
The ethical questions remain difficult. The main argument against a paid renal transplant is that this effectively rules out patients who do not have the means to pay. Having said that the it does not prevent people from resorting to illegal means to get there. Legalising it would ensure a certain accountability on behalf of the docotrs and the recipients. Eliminating the middleman would ensure the donor is adequately compensated. Evaluating the donor is very importnat to ensure he has a very low risk of future renal disease. These are very complex issues that need to be tackled as our society gets more mature.
We need to begin with promoting deceased donor transplants. A central databse would be a first step in this direction. Each state needs to designate key hosiptals in this regard.
Doctors in India do have to recognise their responsibilities and trust placed in them. In turn the community needs to recognise their value and compensate them appropriately.
Lol, I think the point we are missing here is DR Amit Kumar is a great Surgon.How many people died at his hands while kidney transplany? Answre is NONE. I think he has done a fantastic for the job at hand.
RE:He is great doctor
by Brozen Basumatary on Feb 10, 2008 07:20 AM Permalink
So no court in India can jail him or sentence him guilty. As simple as that. I am sure he will be put in bail like million others in India and will resume his office very soon.
RE:RE:He is great doctor
by Brozen Basumatary on Feb 10, 2008 07:22 AM Permalink
My advice is he should join politics and he will he saved. Any idea which caste/religion he belongs to.
Looks like you have difficulty identifying what is wrong and what is right. That's what happens when you live in a totally corrupt society.
Open your eyes. The fellow tried to profit from selling kidneys of the poor. That's the problem. And he deserves to be behind bars. Agreed, it might be better to have legislation that legalizes the sale of kidneys in a transparent manner by those willing to do so. But, middlemen (the unscrupulous Indian middle class) who try to make money out of it should be punished.
RE:Blinded by corruption?
by samudra blr on Feb 10, 2008 08:24 AM Permalink
Might be he has done kidney trading. What right has the media to call him Dr Horror. Look at the positive part of the story. There were many lives saved by this kidney transplants. Organ trade should be legalized and streamlined. People should come forward to donate organs for the people in need. Even though many people want to donate kidneys for exchange of money our government has no proper law for it. If a donor and receiver are willing for whatever monetory or health benefits each one of them gets why should the government and legal system interfere?
If someone is willing to donate his kidney for a price and this guy is willing to do it, what's the problem? This is a poor country and for many people, their body parts are the only things that will fetch money which they got. Why is this guy getting a bad rap?
RE:Poor guy
by daimavane on Feb 10, 2008 06:21 AM Permalink
He is supposed to have stolen kidneys. Even Otherwise, consider this.
If you sell me two bananas , but I pay you for one what you do? You'll likely beat me up. Losing banana is not going to kill you. Now suppose you sold me a kidney and I pay you only half. Kidney is not a banana , lack you one can kill you. Now what do you do? Won;t you be out there to kill me?
RE:Poor guy
by pranam on Feb 10, 2008 04:55 AM Permalink
If Dr Amit did not arrange for donors.(ethically wrong).but did the surgery and gave second lease of life to recipients without in any way affecting the quality of life of donors what is wrong?This story of people being drugged and kidney forcibilly removed is all cock and bull story.Do u mean to say donors were not informed?then who signed the consent letter before surgery?Stupid laws make a normal citizen into an unlawful one
