The closer India gets to the US, the more the chances of the Communist parties being decimated from the country. Communism has proved to be a failure in the former Soviet Union, and exists only due to suppression and victimisation of a vast majority in China. It has no place in a democratic set up. It survives in India in West Bengal and Kerala by means of suppression, domination, victimisation, marketing and propaganda. In Kerala, they have 3 channels-Kairali, We and People. Let them stop their rhetoric that the only reason they are opposing the deal is because India's national interests are affected, and admit their concern that communist & marxist values will be eroded if India gets closer to the US.
I think BJP should support the deal. But problem is Govt (congress) is not trasparent about the deal.
Moreover they even do not go for the extensive debate and vote. That would be healthy democracy. Joint Parliamenttary committee would be another healthy approach. If Vajpayee or Narashimha Rao would been there, then could take most intellegent approach. But MMShing is a puppet PM, he cann't go beyond Sonia Maino...Because she does not like BJP or respect opposition.
Here Congress is doing some dangerous mistake and they cann't and should not say "no international deal should pass through the parliament" What a nonsense logic ! Then whatever other country tell India, India should sign the deal....NOT ACCEPTABLE any time...
RE:Govt (congress) is NOT transparent about the N-deal
by Mahendra Patel on Sep 23, 2007 03:07 AM Permalink
You are right, Congress was not open about it, But Still, it is IN INDIA'S advantage.
If this Go through and it will, You will see overnight, Change in Prestige of INDIA, all the EUROPEAN,ASIAN,AFRICAN,NORTH-AMERICA,CENTRAL- AMERICA and SOUTH-AMERICA.
All will visit India for Friendship, treaty,Colaboration,Scientific Exchange-You never Dreamed of.
This is Going to be SECOND BIRTH OF INDIA, A NEW REAL, PROUD,INDIA.
RE:Govt (congress) is NOT transparent about the N-deal
by Mahendra Patel on Sep 23, 2007 03:33 AM Permalink
I think Left in India has outdated thinking,they do not want USA tie up with INDIA. but in doing so they are hearting INDIA's progress. I do not know Where their Loyalties are. Communism as Philosophy has lost its Steam after collapse of Former USSR and China Tied with USA. Though Carl Marx had Valid arguement agaist Capitalist Greed- That was in EUROPE.This is India.
India is mature enough to handle any Country, so why fear USA, It is in INDIA's HUGE benifit to go ahead with deal, I would say Bengali Left are pragmatist, Keralite experience with Left is a failure in Economic sense, I see many Come to GUJARAT for Job. This said and done. There is still time for Left to reconsider.
This deal will not Go through if Bush is not president in USA, I am in USA. So wise up.
What we need is Grass Root education about what is at Stake, for India and Howmuch to loose for few's STUPIDITY.
My personal opinion is, this Deal will Go through with or without LEFT. Only thing is LEFT will loose credibility on issue of LOYALTY to Country.
Though they have solid base in two states, out of two Bengal will come out as Pragmetic realist, the other as Idealistic without foot on reality as is present today's state of World.
Time to Ponder and Think right for Party and Country, in Final analysis no one is going to hold our hand, Neither China nor Russia.
At present Geopolitical Shifting reality, our Aspiration are in Synchrocity with USA, So it is time to Grab opp
RE:Govt (congress) is NOT transparent about the N-deal
by raj on Sep 23, 2007 05:29 PM Permalink
Mahendra Patel , You are right. As long as Mr.Bush is in the White House deal will go thru.Iam in the US too. When these communist supporters going to realize , Communism is DEAD where it was born. MR.BARDHAN SOVIET UNION IS GONE. RED FLAG IS NOT FLYING THERE ANYMORE. WAKEUP YOU IDIOT. LET THE INDIAN ECONOMY GROW. YOU AND OTHER IDIOT NAMED KARAT BOTH OF YOU ARE NOT FOR INDIA'S INTEREST. YOU BOTH ARE CHINESE AGENTS. YOU GUYS WORSHIP KARAL MARX,LENNIN,STALIN,AND,MAO. THESE KILLERS ARE YOUR LEADERS FROM PREVIOUS CENTURIES. THAT IDEAOLOGY IS NOT WORKING IN ANY COUNTRIES IT IS A STUPID FAILD SYSTEM.NO MATTER HOW YOU TRY US HAS ITS INFLUNCE IN THIS WORLD YOU CAN'T WIPE THAT AWAY. YOU MR.KARAT YOU DIDNT GO TO CHINA OR RUSSIA TO GET EDUCATED INSTEAD YOU WENT TO UK? WHY? YOU ARE A DAMN HYPOCRAT.
