Shame on Congress for 1) Taking Left support. 2) Not even talking to the opposition over such an important national interest issue.
Shame on BJP --> For not seeing larger national interest.
Shame on people of India --> For voting a Cong govt into power, when every single claim made by BJP during the shining India campaign, has been proved true. The people chose to ignore India's achievements and could not see the bright future that lay ahead... they voted like blind bats.
ONLY CPI(M) CAN HOLD ITS HEAD HIGH:
(they have discharged their duties to the Chinese govt most conscientiuously)
RE:RE:Shame on Congress, shame on BJP, Left has head held HIGH
by mariackon enigo on Nov 08, 2007 07:09 AM Permalink
Shame on you Abhishek Banerjee. Then dont live in another country and lick their legs. Live like a man not a slave. Dont blame the people of India or Congress or Communists or BJP.
RE:RE:RE:Shame on Congress, shame on BJP, Left has head held HIGH
by Abhishek Banerjee on Nov 08, 2007 07:28 AM Permalink
This is hard to understnad... in a democracy... why cant we blame our people for electing a hapless, helpless individual to the seat of power? Our Prime Minister is a sarkari babu and our prez is a small time crook... way to go in becoming a superpower.
RE:Shame on Congress, shame on BJP, Left has head held HIGH
by deep dar on Nov 08, 2007 09:10 AM Permalink
I don't see anything wrong in Abhishek's statement. Indian people are fools, of course, that's what happens if people attach importance to caste and vote for those who reinforce the caste barriers.
RE:RE:Shame on Congress, shame on BJP, Left has head held HIGH
by Dipak Bose on Nov 08, 2007 03:12 PM Permalink
Indian people are fool as they live in India but you are intelligent because you go to USA/UK to get kicks and insults for a fistful of Dollars.Bloody Slaves
RE:Shame on Congress, shame on BJP, Left has head held HIGH
by Bhakar Chatopadyaya on Nov 08, 2007 05:17 AM Permalink
The people of india have right to vote congress to power. so bjp arehave to be outside forever.
RE:RE:Shame on Congress, shame on BJP, Left has head held HIGH
by Abhishek Banerjee on Nov 08, 2007 07:35 AM Permalink
Dont be so confident... people of India have that right NOW... they may not have that right soon. The Congress is already holding up the popular mandate in Karnataka, it has done so in Goa, Jharkhand and Bihar.
RE:Shame on Congress, shame on BJP, Left has head held HIGH
by Tathagata Mukherjee on Nov 08, 2007 11:13 AM Permalink
Congress holding mandate in Bihar ?
Most of the Indian masses are biased and vote based on caste, laguage, religion or region they come from. They prefer a criminal belonging to their caste to a gentlemen from another caste. They are blind to a criminals activities if they share caste. A political party evolving out of such a society be it the BJP, Congress, RJD, BSP, Commies or anything else will be utterly corrupt that cannot even find a way to provide basic necessities to it's citizens. Shame on India!
RE:BJP is a fraud same as Congress and the commies
by Shameer on Nov 08, 2007 12:04 PM Permalink
Spot on Mr. Kumar.....
True analysis on current indian politics..... Letz hope one day people will realize that they are taken for rides by the so called stupid parties and vote out of cast ,religion,language barriers....am I dreaming... I've the right to dream....
RE:BJP is a fraud same as Congress and the commies
by Dipak Bose on Nov 08, 2007 05:32 PM Permalink
Yah, and bloody NRIs are the only people who are pure. That is the reason you want to sell India's defence to the Americans. You are slaves.
BJP should stick to joint parliamentary committee (JPC) if Govt needs approval of MPs of opposition party. In the past JPC was not formed for International deal, does not make it sound, not to form now. Past is past, present is present and it should be for the goodness of the people of India.
RE:BJP should stick to the formation of JPC (Joint parliamentary committee)
by Loan Shark on Nov 08, 2007 07:51 AM Permalink
BJP should stick to its agenda of wooing muslim voters ... even if it costs its once secured Hindu votes, BJP should continue to praise Pakistani leaders and ignore the fact that they sponsor terrorism in India.
RE:BJP should stick to the formation of JPC (Joint parliamentary committee)
by deep dar on Nov 08, 2007 09:13 AM Permalink
You can shout this from ur terrace, but people won't forget that the UPA and Commies are the masters of this game, i.e, Muslim appeasement.
Advani's statement about Jinnah was to remind the Pakistanis about the mandate with which Jinnah found Pakistan, a secular state, which is poles apart from the mess of a state they are in now. He was praising the vision of Jinnah, not the person himself. But, fools like u won't realize this as u guys prefer to be carried over by the media masala!!!
RE:RE:BJP should stick to the formation of JPC (Joint parliamentary committee)
by ebby on Nov 08, 2007 11:33 AM Permalink
WE FOOLS BOW DOWN TO YOUR WISDOM DEEP DAR!ONLY BECAUSE OF SUCH WISDOM WE HAVE BEEN IN THIS STATE FOR EONS!
RE:Why Cong is not approaching BJP?
by ebby on Nov 08, 2007 08:06 AM Permalink
one thing nobody can deny is your twisted mind & logic , Bengali babu. Your left kills any chance of a deal because of chinese leaning and why BJP is not approaching congress? They are doing so to any sundry party elsewhere.
RE:Why Cong is not approaching BJP?
by deep dar on Nov 08, 2007 09:16 AM Permalink
Loan Shark has exposed his folly and stupidity once again!!! "The caste-basis voters vote BJP and merit-basis voters vote congress."
No wonder the Congress fights for giving reservations to OBCs, who are "meritorious"!!!
Loan Shark, it's time for you to attend classes with kinder garten students!!!
RE:Why Cong is not approaching BJP?
by Minto on Nov 08, 2007 01:26 AM Permalink
India cannot take advantage of the deal of the century because of muslims. BJP also wants to play electoral politics and will not support the treaty outright even though it is in the best interest of the nation. Looks like our only option is to deport all indian muslims to Pakistan, whre their loyalty belong anyway.
RE:Why Cong is not approaching BJP?
by Loan Shark on Nov 08, 2007 06:58 AM Permalink
chahe kitna chaat le Advani Jinnah kee aur pakistaniyon kee .... muslims will never vote for BJP. Congress doesn't have to worry about Muslim votes. Hindu votes are divided. The caste-basis voters vote BJP and merit-basis voters vote congress.
BJP will soon be playing to the tunes of Congress on this nuclear deal. BJP is only going to alienate the business class and their votes if congress comes out as a business friendly party.
RE:Is Cong for this deal, or against it?
by ravikanth on Nov 08, 2007 12:26 AM Permalink
You are no 1 fool in this world. Congress is pushing for this deal. If they are not interested, the question does not arise.
RE:Is Cong for this deal, or against it?
by Pradip Parekh on Nov 08, 2007 12:02 AM Permalink
why are the muslims against this deal? why is mohamad bukhari against this deal?
ok, be that as it may, suadi arabia is a friend of usa, why is usa not roping in s.a. which can straighten out the whole mess with just one phone call to bukhari. look, sonia tried it with her china trip to get to the heart of indian commies - and failed despite surrendering on dalai lama; congress, again, can't negotiate worth a dime. but there is no way to fail if congres and usa used the saudi channel. isn't it great that india is truly an internatinal country where monotheist foreigners can pull strings?
RE:RE:Is Cong for this deal, or against it?
by Bhakar Chatopadyaya on Nov 08, 2007 06:46 AM Permalink
india is also internatinal country as advani also is foreigner born in pakistan.
RE:Is Cong for this deal, or against it?
by Loan Shark on Nov 08, 2007 07:00 AM Permalink
Should Pakistan break up, Advani will the PM of Sindh. He is already working on it with a secret deal with the Jinnah Party.
RE:This is correct stand by BJP
by Pradip Parekh on Nov 07, 2007 11:51 PM Permalink
commies killed the treaty on both sides. in the u.s.a. it was lefty activists (anti-nuke)and pro-israel (anti-iran) activists and their congressmen lantos, and in india it was commies, the partner in crime in the govt "run" by an unelected person.
RE:This is correct stand by BJP
by Bhakar Chatopadyaya on Nov 08, 2007 06:47 AM Permalink
by opposing deal bjp is hurting the country but they do not care.
RE:This is correct stand by BJP
by deep dar on Nov 08, 2007 09:17 AM Permalink
the country will sign the NPT if it signs this deal, in its present form!!!
u Bengalis won't mind, as u people vote for Commies, who owe their allegiance to China!
BJP should stick to joint parliamentary committee (JPC) if Govt need approval of MPs. uncultured "firingee" never learned how to respect opposition party. Congress party is licking are dirty spots.
What stupid leaders like Advani? They are saying India's energy concern is secondary and the strategic interest, for whatever be the unrealistic situation of a nuclear war with pakistan, is primary? This is the most stupid remark. There will never ever be any nuclear war between any country in the world.
Now BJP wants the deal but after re-negotiation. What kind of people are they? India can not start a new negotiation process, as it has been categorically rejected by the USA. After spending so much time, effort and money (for lobbying) and coming to that close where both sides agreed that they are satisfied, how can India request to start a new negotiation? On what basis India can request that? Because the government could not anticipate the protest? India will be looked as the most untrustworthy country. At this moment, it is TAKE IT OR LEAVE IT. BJP is trying to correct some wrong things they done past by protesting against the deal, but it is too late now.
RE:Stupid BJP - it is too late now. TAKE IT OR LEAVE IT
by Pradip Parekh on Nov 07, 2007 11:39 PM Permalink
liar, liar. if anybody will look untrustworthy, it would be congress. don't bear down on bjp. it was congress that negotiated badly, and then reassured all that it had the parliament's confidence. and it is sheer madness to think usa's stance is final. hyde act violated the signed treaty between the govts; on usa's side it is fault the u.s. congress which too needs a lot of discipline, specially in foreign affairs.
RE:Stupid BJP - it is too late now. TAKE IT OR LEAVE IT
by Bhakar Chatopadyaya on Nov 08, 2007 06:48 AM Permalink
bjp is most untrustworthy party as it supported terrorists and gave them freedom in kandahar.
RE:Stupid BJP - it is too late now. TAKE IT OR LEAVE IT
by Sudip Bhattacharjee on Nov 08, 2007 01:02 AM Permalink
yes, congress is the most untrustworthy party. They made blunder by assuming that they have support of the opposition and even inside their coalition. But, I was talking about BJP only. They have no right to say what is right and wrong at this moment. They just wanted to avoid the deal and now, when they are under pressure by USA, they are saying they want the deal but with a change!
RE:Stupid BJP - it is too late now. TAKE IT OR LEAVE IT
by Pradip Parekh on Nov 08, 2007 02:10 AM Permalink
i think you are misreading bjp. bjp has always been for: - debate in parliament followed by a vote on the treaty. (the best option - ie for a democracy that we all cherish). do you support this idea? yes or no?
bjp has always maintained a deal with the usa is a good idea, even a must. but congress is the wrong party to negotiate it because congress makes a huge mess of the most promising situation. this treaty is only a more obvious example.
RE:RE:Stupid BJP - it is too late now. TAKE IT OR LEAVE IT
by Bhakar Chatopadyaya on Nov 08, 2007 06:49 AM Permalink
bjp has no right to be main opposition party as they lose all elections.
Renegotiate to remove fissile material cut off from NSG deal for one as it is useless to talk fissile material cut off and deterent which means nuke weapons. You cannot have nuke weapons without fissile material. Not only can you not build new weapons, when Fissile Material degradation in the current weapons takes place they cannot be refreshed in future. so back door to CAP AND ROLL BACK TO ZERO weapons in a few years. Not something that is in security intrest of Indias Future. There is a template out there India can uses it the China -US deal.
RE:Renegotiate to get same as China -US deal
by Revolutionary Bhagat on Nov 07, 2007 10:03 PM Permalink
yes mr cia mole .. while ur at it, y not give out some more misinformation .. like usa is sponsoring the chinese space program and that china is about to invade north east...
there is no us china nuclear deal but usa wants to entrap our country so tht it can foster more mistrust b/w the poor working classes of asia
RE:Renegotiate to get same as China -US deal
by apjunkmail on Nov 07, 2007 11:04 PM Permalink
Do a google search for China 123 Agreement or U.S.-China Nuclear Cooperation Agreement ... Do not sell out nuke weapons ...
think clearly. dont just become hypnotised by the sweet sounding statements from usa which is desperate for dollar payments to infuse liquidity into its cash strapped economic system.
the G8 want to turn our country into a pawn to be used against china .. basically they want to destroy asia (india china prosperity) by turning them into enemies when like it happenned in 1961 when propaganda from the anglo saxon imperialists caused the struggling masses of china and india to turn against each other.
when the stupid dalai lama calls for fight against china and india gives him refuge without protesting his statements then wht do u expect china to do? do u think they will sit quietly?
usa exploited this mistrust and benefited from 1961 war by making 2 working classes to hate each other. remember if we are to survive and progress .. both india and china must concentrate on the extending the benefits of globalisation to their poor majority and not by having an eyeball to eyeball confontation.
but "Useful idiots of New east india INC" will not believe it
