What is happening in Karnataka is very bad sign for the democracy. Governor is working as a political person belongs from congress, why he is waisting the time in taking decision. however MLA's has been meeting with him they have proved their number in the Rajbhawan. It is upto governor how he wants to make his image in the country & perform his job honestly without biasness because this is not only related to him but also for others as well as for coming generation. As he had sworn in the name of god for the same at a time of appointment for justice to all. Meanwhile this case should be decided by President of India that Governor will continue or take final decision
RE:Report from Governor Rameshwar Thakur
by dinesh shivhare on Nov 06, 2007 02:43 PM Permalink
agree, this is a job of Governor not the President, there is no role of The president or Home Minister.it is only a dirty politics
What is happening in Karnataka is very bad sign for the democracy. Governor is working as a political person belongs from congress, why he is waisting the time in taking decision. however MLA's has been meeting with him they have proved their number in the Rajbhawan. It is upto governor how he wants to make his image in the country & perform his job honestly without biasness because this is not only related to him but also for others as well as for coming generation. As he had sworn in the name of god for the same at a time of appointment for justice to all. Meanwhile this case should be decided by President of India that Governor will continue or take final decision
RE:Report from Governor Rameshwar Thakur
by hari prasad on Nov 06, 2007 02:45 PM Permalink
Dear Mr. Dharmendra, one should understand that the constitutional limit in india. The governor can easily call these BJP & JDS people to form the government. But what is the guarantee that this will stand for another 19 months? initially there was a greement between the JDS & BJP for 20:20 months. Even gowda was opposed this deal. later he agreed & given certificate to his son that he is doing well.
after 20 months, the power transfer suppose to be automatic like in jammu & kashmir.
after thier period, if they refuse to give the power & later again came back with support. is there any meaning for the democrasy? what is the faith that karnatak people will have on thire leaders?
governer may thinking to invite a mejority group to form the government.
we have to wait & watch as per the constitutional codes, the power transfer may happen..or the assembly can be disolved.
both these parties can again go back to people of karnataka & come back to power.
RE:RE:Report from Governor Rameshwar Thakur
by Vikas on Nov 06, 2007 02:53 PM Permalink
All ur arguments are absolutely baseless. The constitution clearly says that a person with a majority MLAs in assembly should be called to form the goverment. Any other arguments have no place in the constitution.
Anytime, every party have full freedom to support or withdrw from a goverment. thats democracy. There is nothing wrong in this. Its completely legal.
Can anyone predict the future ? What about the UPA govt in Cetre ? The Left parties are always fighting with Congress. Left keeps shouting that they will withdraw support. Whats the guarantee that they rule properly , and don't fall before completing the term? By ur argument, the UPA should not rule in the Centre? What a bullsh1t argument. It only shows that u are ignorant of Indian Politics & constitution.
RE:RE:RE:Report from Governor Rameshwar Thakur
by innocent on Nov 06, 2007 03:01 PM Permalink
vikas, are you a constitutional expert. the governor to use his wisdom, if he has. I think in this case, he is using his wisdom man. merely to count numers, we dont need a governor, mere a watchman is sufficient. all the rules to be applied with caution and all, may be you are lacking or blind on this issue.
RE:Report from Governor Rameshwar Thakur
by innocent on Nov 06, 2007 02:59 PM Permalink
mate, you think too correct, which you should not. it is politics and no one want to remeber, what happened yesterday, and you analyse clearly of the events back 20 months. all the best, still we have many persons like you. so GOD can save us.
President = puppet of Congress Governor = puppet of Congress
- report contained several annexures in the form of newspaper clippings and also letters written to the Governor by Congress leaders. - This is bullsh1t. Its only delaying tactics of Congress. When did the news clippings and opposition party letters become criteria for deciding the majority in assembly ?
RE:Congress tactics.
by Vijay alias Teesmar Khan on Nov 06, 2007 02:28 PM Permalink
If all the decisions are to be taken by central govt, then why the hell governors are there in states? Don't they head any mind to think what should be done in which condition?
RE:Congress tactics.
by jagadeesh g on Nov 06, 2007 02:37 PM Permalink
you are absolutely right. its waste to spend money for that post( Governer ) who cannot make decision on his own.
RE:Congress tactics.
by dinesh shivhare on Nov 06, 2007 02:47 PM Permalink
In this suitation,Becouse of uneducated or less educated persons sit on the higher position,abd they can't apply their mind and always depends on others decision.
RE:Congress tactics.
by Bharat on Nov 06, 2007 02:34 PM Permalink
By the way what our so called president is doing nowdays . we haven't heard anything after she got elected other than that she is finalizing which of her potrait or picture should be used in govt. offices. any thing on nation's interest front for underprivileged or women.nothing .
RE:Congress tactics.
by Vikas on Nov 06, 2007 02:46 PM Permalink
maybe researching how to help congress to grab power in states ruled by opposition parties.
I think at this point president rule is good for the people of my state. BJP or JD governmt won't do any good. I think the centre and state should stick to the president rule.
RE:president should be ok
by MOHAN PYARE on Nov 06, 2007 02:30 PM Permalink
What Mr.sixto dsilva has expressed is the typical mindset of the congress. If they can cobble up a majority, any kind of coalition is okay. If they do not get a chance to rule, other parties should not get a chance. After all, they have the dubious distinction of dismissing several elected governments starting from the first communist government of Kerala.
RE:RE:president should be ok
by praveen on Nov 06, 2007 02:25 PM Permalink
president rule can't be for more than 6 months. What after 6 months... election and use of our tax payer's money. After election also more or less, similar to the current situation would prevail.
Now if there is possibility of govt. formation and then why not give a chance. Also nothing is happening here in an unethical manner. There is no force. congree was trying to break JDS and that would have been a bad example.
RE:president should be ok
by Vikas on Nov 06, 2007 02:22 PM Permalink
President = puppet of Congress Governor = puppet of Congress President's rule = Governor's rule = Congress rule.
U must be either ignorant of Indian politics, or a CONGRESS SUPPORTER.
RE:RE:RE:president should be ok
by Vikas on Nov 06, 2007 02:44 PM Permalink
... led by former bar waitress, and her mentally retarded and drugg addict son.
The BJP must take congress and pseudo-secular opportunist Gowda by horn. Show the nation how a congress Governor is killing all the democratic norms by sitting in office.He must atleast follow some norms. Have some moral values? VKK
RE:Well Done BJP
by on Nov 06, 2007 02:28 PM Permalink
bjp is nuts. BJP and JDS washing dirty und**s in public first get us into this mess and then the governor is to blame? huh?
RE:Well Done BJP
by Vikas on Nov 06, 2007 02:40 PM Permalink
BJP JDS have 129 MLAs. The total size of assembly is 224. So, they have a clear majority. Governor's job is to call them to form the goverment. All other arguments are baseless in democratic rule. Remember Congress and Left parties contested against each otehr in Kerala and W Bengal, and even now they are against each other in those states. Still they are ruling together in Centre.
Governor being a congressman, wants to help congress to rule indirectly.
President = puppet of Congress Governor = puppet of Congress President's rule = Governor's rule = Congress rule.
RE:Well Done BJP
by Vikas on Nov 06, 2007 02:23 PM Permalink
President = puppet of Congress Governor = puppet of Congress President's rule = Governor's rule = Congress rule.
Only Supreme Court can save constitution and democracy from the clutches of Congress.
At the time of Gujrat riot, what the centre did, can u remember, when at the time president Mr.K.R.Narayanan want send troop to gujrat, what Vajpayee did, after three days only he send the troops. if we tell this, then the bjp supports will send a message that what you have done in godhra carnage or see one more congress support is here.
RE:RE:Well Done BJP
by Vikas on Nov 06, 2007 02:57 PM Permalink
Law & Order is a state subject and Centre should not interfere in state subjects - BJP didn't say this, ur CPM said.
Narayanan was a congressman and as president, he always tried to support congress and ridicule BJP. There was nothing great in his actions.
In Indian independence movement martyrs struggled by sacrificing their life against the bullet of British. They contributed to the nation in that way. Deve Gowad can also contribute to this country by sacrificing his life against his own bullet.
RE:puppet president
by chandran ravindran on Nov 06, 2007 02:28 PM Permalink
I will fully endorse your view. she wii have to get back to her congress bosses before she responds
RE:RE:puppet president
by vinod kumar on Nov 06, 2007 02:21 PM Permalink
I agree with you. This is the congress culture. The puppet PM & President. VKK
