Hi Friends, I own a small portion of farmland around N-acress(single digit), I am proud of it as its an inherited land from my ancestor, WILL THE GOVT SNATCH FROM ME??????????????
RE:I own a farmland X-acres, will the govt snatch it from me?
by Im back on Mar 15, 2007 02:50 PM Permalink
well, If your land gives employment of 10,000 people and your get money for your land , will you give it for the sake of states people or will you keep it coz of the emotional feeling that "u got from ancestor" (JOKH ER DHON ER MATO AANKRE PORE THAKBEN ??)
RE:RE:I own a farmland X-acres, will the govt snatch it from me?
by bobby on Mar 15, 2007 03:07 PM Permalink
WHICH OMPANY OF TWO ARE GIVING EMPLYMENT TO 10000 PEOPLE.The source of income is very good in SO....CHI send your house women their they will generate good money & people would be busy their because of initially aid free & govt will generate good revenue
nandigram issue has became a political issue between mamta banerjee and mr. bhattacharya & Mr Ratan Tata has become a scrap goat. Mr Tata u r such big and a respsected person, y r u after a small piece of land. any state government will put a red carpet for u. Let the people of nandigram alone.
RE:political issue
by Kasyap on Mar 15, 2007 02:21 PM Permalink
get your facts right.. TATA is in singur, not nandigram.. nadigram is a law and order situation created by naxalites and jamat. Also not scrap goat.. its called scape goat
RE:RE:political issue
by Gautam Chatterjee on Mar 15, 2007 03:09 PM Permalink
Englidh is important so is the information. Most of the bloggers seem to have mixed up the issues of land with CPIM's hooliganism. I understand, the land issue should not take the front seat for banishing the atricities of the single party rule in West Bengal. We should focus our attention to the way CPIM's goondas, with the help of the so-called police force, are trying to establish their strnoghold in this small part of the state where they have literally vanished. Ego of certain political leaders are taking its toll. Both the CPIM and Trinamool are to be blamed for this. Change of power in West Bengal requires a formadible Opposition. I donot think the present Trinamool can pose itself as that. What we need today is a poilitical party people can vote when common people look for a sustitute. Blame the CPIM but a share of the balme should also be reserved for the opposition as well.
RE:RE:RE:political issue
by partha das on Mar 15, 2007 03:53 PM Permalink
When BJP was 2 have you thought they can run a Govt. ? Unless you give them a chance how will you know ?
This dictator like attitude of WB CM, which leds to this kind of situation.If he cant handle this situation it leds to more blood shed in near future.May be this is the begining of the left front era in west bengal.
RE:nandigram horror
by loganathan kommeti on Mar 15, 2007 02:22 PM Permalink
Well said see what the communist Mps has done in the parliement on the other day with the Dmk Mps. When they dont want to give their rights to what govt want's to do, how they expect a farmer to give their rights.
RE:RE:nandigram horror
by Pradipta Halder on Mar 15, 2007 02:42 PM Permalink
Well said. I would love to join hands with you to throw out this corrupt CPM and 'Hitler' Buddha. All are invited to join in this holy war.
RE:nandigram horror
by surajit sarkar on Mar 15, 2007 02:15 PM Permalink
dear roy chowdhury i agree with you.come in we all work together to throw out this govt.in bay of bengal. thank you
RE:RE:nandigram horror
by Kasyap on Mar 15, 2007 02:22 PM Permalink
and get in mamata in his place? you should be urgently thrown out for the benifit of the state
There are blatant lies afloat like "Opposition is responsible" and "Islamic or antisocial violence". Be sure of the fact that unless there is spontaneous support from within the people of the soil no such mass movement can happen. Cutting of roads and whatsoever has been spontaneous and TO PREVENT INHUMAN ATROCITIES of the ruling party. Opressing people to "hell" who own or work in their land and then you say "Govt wanted to talk" and "Govt has done the right thing" ??
Answer this :
1) Have you ever visted ONCE the affected areas ? If you can spare only 5 hours out of say 262800 hours of your life go and speak to the local people - you can find out the truth ! Then come to these boards ! ( Dont falsely say you went : that is easily caught ! )
2) Why there had has to be such turmoil ? People were working there and earning too all very peacefully! Why did you need to brutally jeopardize a good economy ??
3) Why the unutlized lands are not being used ? Find the truth : there are plenty you can see on google maps of WB !!
4) No infrastructure ? Companies not wanting to take them ? All are bogus logic. If infrastructure is not there it can be started to build even NOW and within 5 years we can have enough to lure the companies.
5) No money ? Literally huge amount of money is being stolen, millions of crores ! Add to that all sorts of corruption and inefficiency. Why not attack this menace ? All funds on agriculture has been stolen so now the industrialists' money is needed to for the blackmoney-fed people with power. Do a proper enquiry to find how much money is changing hands of the local party leader/s, various officials and others.
6) Oppostion or for that matter anyone - NONE are opposed to industrialization ! Such spread is a ridiculous LIE !! Only they are saying it should be done in unutilized land. Hey ! Will you give away your home and
and land and paaraa ???? WILL YOU ?
7) Multi-crop land are MORE precious than anything. In another 25-50 years they will be nearly as precious as fuel. WB feeds on plenty of imported wheat and other food
stuffs. Why not be first self-sufficient in food ? If in outside worlds farmers can belong to the
richer section why NOT here ? False facts such as `Not enough goodness in soil` and `low yields`
are fabricated to hide the HUGE amount of theft in agro raw materials and inefficeincy of officials
and ministers. Why NOT make agriculture itself a major industry ?? Why ???
2 easy proofs of what I say : - Go and see the lands, talk to the people ! - 30 years in power in continuation is just NOT possible without corruption and oppression. How much you may shout against this fact, the fact itself is a proof of itself.
RE:nandigram : Please know the TRUTH and act
by dipankar dey on Mar 15, 2007 02:24 PM Permalink
anybody can judge from ur words that u r a TMC guy.Better lick ur didi's feet and let the state live on its own. Don't have to think for the state. u people have given nothing but violence to the normal people
RE:RE:nandigram : Please know the TRUTH and act
by Jas Sand on Mar 15, 2007 02:31 PM Permalink
What have the communist pinkos given to the nation, other than chaos and confusion?
RE:RE:nandigram : Please know the TRUTH and act
by partha das on Mar 15, 2007 04:06 PM Permalink
Do Yoy think all the Lawyers and those people who has come to protest on roads are supporter of TMC ?
Dipankar,if you can't answer his question then just keep shut-up.
RE:RE:nandigram : Please know the TRUTH and act
by sumanta chatterjee on Mar 15, 2007 04:03 PM Permalink
Dipankar, anybody speaking truth is not a TC man. But anyone hiding the truth is certainly a comrade.
RE:plz sign and circulate the petition
by dipankar dey on Mar 15, 2007 02:24 PM Permalink
anybody can judge from ur words that u r a TMC guy.Better lick ur didi's feet and let the state live on its own. Don't have to think for the state. u people have given nothing but violence to the normal people
RE:RE:plz sign and circulate the petition
by Gundappa on Mar 15, 2007 03:36 PM Permalink
Petition for good cause is always welcome, be it from TMC, BJP, or even CPM. I have signed this letter without any hesitation.If this brutal act would have done by TMC and CPM would collect signature in protest, I would have also signed then. You people always get smell of politics everywhere! Feel for the fellow once!
Commies & their cadres were & are running parallel goverment in WB.Now commies are getting the taste of their own medicine. Whole India is praying that the people of WB would kick out all commies from the power.
RE:RE:End of Left Raj has begun!!!
by Kasyap on Mar 15, 2007 02:24 PM Permalink
whole India except for people of WB.. thats the problem with rest of India.. always hyperactive about WB.
Bhattacharya is showing all the tributes needed to become the dictator of Bengal. He talks of industrializaion in Bengal and has cut such a sorry figure in both Singur and Nandigram. Shame on u Buddhadeb. U r a disgrace to the state.
The opposition mainly TMC, SUCI and Nxalites are responsible for the situation. Mind it that this battle is no longer for acquision of land. this is political. CM had announces very next day that no land will be acquired without consent of people. still during the last two months they have isolated Nandigram from rest of WB by cutting roads. They have drove out more than 1000 CPIM workers out of their home to take political reasons. They have right to return to their homes. They did not allow police to enter the area. Maintaining peace is responsibility of not only CM but all of us. The DM had called several all party meetings but except CONG, no other party turned up. The have not let the administration to repair roads despite several request. In the last two months several oppoition leader alongwith some intectuals(??) have visited the area. But none have taken any initiative to bring nornmalcy. They have encouraged the people to continue the bolckage. By this time several people and one police officer has been killed by them. So it became the sole responsibity of administration to bring back normalcy. How long police should wait? The police entered the area not suddenly. The day and time were announced earlier. So the opposition got time to prepare. They have not entered to arrest any one. Still the people swayed by TMC propaganda resisted putting the women in front, and attacked the police with bombs. The instruction to them was given from Kolkata over mobile. Police have not fired at once but they followed the sequence.
For what is this? Not for land, but to gain some advantage in coming Panchayat election. The opposition is reduce to to a minimum in assembly (Total 63 out of 294). They are detached from people. Any move of government they oppose. They have opposed the land reform. They opposed Hladia Ptrochem and Bakreswar thermal Power Station. They know that if industry comes to WB they have to wind up thier party.
RE:Only Opposition is responsible
by Chinmoy Nandi on Mar 15, 2007 02:17 PM Permalink
WHO R U? "UR PARTY HAVE ALREADY TAKEN ANY DICISSION AS A OITHIHASIK BHUL " DO U KNOW - WHAT COMMENT WAS ABOUT-VIVEKANONDA-NETAJI-RABINDRANATH. BOGUS
RE:RE:Only Opposition is responsible
by Kasyap on Mar 15, 2007 02:28 PM Permalink
Apurba is speaking facts and has got brains.. you are speaking rubbish... when CPIM admits a mistake it becomes a news all over India and when other parties go on doing mistake whole through their existence (TMC a great example) then its a voice for the people
RE:Only Opposition is responsible
by nilmadhab mandal on Mar 15, 2007 02:27 PM Permalink
Mr. Santra,
one simple question? how come the opposition is responsible for death of children and women? Even if the villagers didnt allow the police to enter...they allowed the journalist...now on wednesday..your party workers ddint allow even the reporter to enter..your caders ddint even allow police or oppostion to enetr..so that you can run mahem within the Nandigram..is thsi rule of law??
Nobody reported that CPM workers were out of home..even if so..you killed 20 women and children to give them back home..and as the TV report shows,...all remining villagres had fled to save themselves from police..
CPM is the best party to terrorise the comon man...and streamline..any opposition ..
by the way..police office was not killed here...know the place properly..as by your own admission ..villagers ddint allow police to enetr..then how ddi they kill them...?? Be rest assured...your party will win election..and you also know ..this si to show power of Mr. Lakshamn seth (the local goon-come land graber-come MP)...all election in next 10 years will be own may be by CPM..but i will think twice to cast vote for your party..which could have been my party as well..you have lost the support of the common ppl..time you guys admit it..
RE:Only Opposition is responsible
by Renju jolly on Mar 15, 2007 02:28 PM Permalink
ur 100% right... people doesnt realise this... why r indians going abroad, coz there are better facilities ooutside.... we dont realise that 1 job of a peon in a office or company like TATA creates 4 other different jobs... the opposition parties are hopeless cases... do the farmers realise that, they will be getting 1000 times more than they can make in their life time, if these companies come here...
please allow some one as visionary as Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee to develope WB...
do u know... there were many opposition even for legendary Dirubhai Ambani...
RE:Only Opposition is responsible
by bobby on Mar 15, 2007 02:52 PM Permalink
I think instead of talking so high about your party first understand why this is happening.The reasons are many but few are as : A)The top most man in cpim , shri BUddha babu had got no credibilty of hi own.Today he wll say one thing & tomorrow he will turn down his words.IN 2004 he said book fair will be shifted in bypass, in 2005 he requested court to go ahead with fair once last time but as soon as he entered 2006 his words chaged to that this book fair is part of culture in west bengal.In dalmiyas case he openly acted as road side cheap goonda & started threating him.
B)look how angry those one thousand cpim workers were when they had been drove away from their home, they acted as goondas(though every cpim cadre is originally this) & took revenge by killing innocents.
C) What will u do if one day u had been asked to leave your home, u will also try to protect it.
D)Is this is the way industries are to be developed.Compare your stratagy to the stratagy adopted by GUJRAT government, you will find your govt is way back in development.
E)Your loose is mine gain & everyone knows how fair elctions are held in w.b., so please do not give details of seats.
RE:Only Opposition is responsible
by Raghupathy on Mar 15, 2007 02:24 PM Permalink
I completely agree to disagree. They are in power by scientific manipulation and bogus voting. Above all in many states they instigate violence in the name of benefit of common people. They blocking all bills on financial reforms. But when it comes to WB they talk everything like industrialisation. Irony is in Keral thry will not speak the same language (not literal)as in WB. For each state they have own priority. Commies are the most selfish people in the world. It is high time they are thrown out of the power,country and if possible from the entire world
RE:RE:Only Opposition is responsible
by Kasyap on Mar 15, 2007 02:34 PM Permalink
you don't stay in WB and have no idea.. TMC or congress or BJP is the most useless party that you can find on earth in WB.. inspite of all the mistakes CPIM is a peoples choice, rigging or not they will win as they don't have any alternative. And for your information, CPIM is a much better and cleaner party than most of the parties in India.. they do mistake and have also their philosophy and theres no wrong in it,they are at least brave enough to admit and analyze them
all those guys who make pro CPM and Pro budhha comments here should have the same magnamity when thier own ancestral land, ancestral home ancestral villages and employmnet oppurtunities are siezed by the corrupt govt and a few ruppes thrust on you. In case you protest the state polcie is there to bash you up. Where is the rascal Dasgupta of CPI who went to haryana when some labourers were lathi charged by the police.Now all the Communist jokers are in the hiding, all of them have dual characters.
