RE:Chief minister must resign with apologize
by Suman Bhat on Mar 15, 2007 03:09 PM Permalink
Hindus under West Bengal By Animitra Chakraborty Out of 38 arrested , 11 were alleged of violence. Their domestic lives have become miserable. It is suspected that the political highhandedness of the ruling front has made the police behave insensitively. http://www.organiser.org/dynamic/modules.php?name=Content&pa=showpage&pid=175&page=30
RE:Chief minister must resign with apologize
by Pinaki Basu on Mar 15, 2007 03:09 PM Permalink
chief minster had forget about human rights please send him to civics class of 8th std.
RE:RE:Chief minister must resign with apologize
by Debdulal Das on Mar 15, 2007 03:19 PM Permalink
and Pinki is right, we must support industry but in any other place of Bangal not to kill any one
RE:RE:Chief minister must resign with apologize
by Soham Dutta on Mar 15, 2007 03:09 PM Permalink
Lets see why he should resign--- 1. He is trying to generate more jobs, thats bad, it should never be done. Bengal should have more closed industries! 2. He is asking people to the talks table, they do not come. This is worse I guess, he should personally go and talk to the opposition leader. After all, the "lady" should be given respect! Doesnt matter if you are the CM! 3. He has openly said no SEZs in nandigram. Now this is worst of all, the opposition then has no agenda! How can that be!They shud atleast have some agenda!
So Mr Buddhadeb, must resign! Given the fact that corrupt, money lenders can stand as CMs in many Indian states.
RE:RE:RE:Chief minister must resign with apologize
by Kasyap on Mar 15, 2007 03:34 PM Permalink
congrats for speaking the wish of the so called well wishers of Bengal.. its a difficult fact for rest of India to digest that development can happen in WB and the leaders are not as worthless as their leaders
RE:RE:RE:Chief minister must resign with apologize
by Jas Sand on Mar 15, 2007 03:18 PM Permalink
Cool, will the communists follow the same policy at the National Level?
RE:RE:RE:Chief minister must resign with apologize
by on Mar 15, 2007 03:20 PM Permalink
>>Lets see why he should resign--- >>1. He is trying to generate more jobs, By killing innocent peoples?
RE:RE:RE:Chief minister must resign with apologize
by partha das on Mar 15, 2007 03:25 PM Permalink
Mr. Soham, Can't your CM see the barren lands for industry? Why in place of fertile lands and living lands ?
RE:RE:Chief minister must resign with apologize
by Debdulal Das on Mar 15, 2007 03:24 PM Permalink
do you know the Mayor of Washington resigned after a lady have killed due to accident and he cried time of resignation ?? this is a example of humanity
RE:RE:Chief minister must resign with apologize
by Bob Seth on Mar 15, 2007 03:55 PM Permalink
all these chemical industries being setup in india is because the mncs know that we have the most corrupt politcians, judical system, police machinery in place. in a case of any mishap like bhopal they can just walk away by paying some bribe to budha and guys of his ilk , no one in india bothers about envoirment no judical system will peanlise them , in indian courts only the poor are hanged.
RE:Bengali
by kaushik thakurata on Mar 15, 2007 03:18 PM Permalink
you are absolutely right.kisiko bhi jwalan a sakta hai kyunki tagore se amartya sen,noble prize winer to mostly bengali log i hay na!fir bollywood ko dekho-kajol,rani and bipasa ne to sari herion ko mar dala,music industry me abhijeet,kumar shanu,shaan,shreya sob to bengali log hi hay,classical music pe ajay chakraborty,ravishankar.......or may te bhuli gaya,oscar to ek bengali ko hi mila,satyajit roy.politics me from the very beginning,subhashchandra bose,arvindo se one of the most successful politician dr. bidhanchandra roy or mostly noted speaker somnath chatterjee.......thoda dimag pe dhaan do or statistics le kor aao tom log ki baareme.
RE:Bengali
by sarika jain on Mar 15, 2007 03:19 PM Permalink
What an idiotic statement which really shows the ignorance and foolishness on the part of the writer. This clearly states the fact who needs an allocation in a re-hab centre. People like these are not even eligible to present a mere statement leave alone a writeup or reaction to a delicate issue. It's a shame. I strongly react to the view. It's disgraceful.
RE:Bengali
by ujjwal on Mar 15, 2007 03:06 PM Permalink
Dont Say in this way beacuse India is United country and you should know the meaning of National Antheme(Did u mean the words of that?)
RE:RE:Bengali
by TSN Xumar on Mar 15, 2007 03:10 PM Permalink
The exception is not the rule. Bengal has great sons.daughters - Rabindranath , Vivekananda, Ramkrishna, Amartya Sen, Satyajit Ray, Jhumpa Lahiri and quite a few others.
But she has also produced Mamata - and many many more hot headed- blind - egocentric - emotional idiots. Otherwise, how do you account for the anti-computer agitation of the 1990s? How do you account for the anarchy of Naxalism? How do you account for the 30 year stint by one party - how do you believe in Communism - when it is proved that the philosophy doesnt work?? Why does the likes of Kabir Suman believe in Communism - and why do people in bengal call such stupidity - intellectualism.
RE:RE:RE:Bengali
by Amit on Mar 15, 2007 04:52 PM Permalink
Talking about intellectualism, I should say that Bengal produced the highest number of such individuals who are truly world class, be it arts,cinemas,sports,science,music etc. than all other states combined. Think before you speak. If you have guts speak out which community you belong to? All the non-bengalis think and speak business. The problem with them is they cannot take it lightly when they cannot do business as they want in Bengal and vent their anger against everything Bengali. Bengal does not need people like you. You are welcome to leave bengal.
RE:RE:RE:Bengali
by sumit dutta on Mar 15, 2007 03:56 PM Permalink
How do you account for incident sof sati in rajasthan,gujarat and MP? how do you account for caste based killings in UP and Bihar? How do you account for the insane adulation of filmstars and total corruption of politicians down south? or the distrust and hatred of the kashmiris and north eastern people towards rest of India? Buddha babu is a sane man with great ideas and a vision,he may have had problems with implementing them.Mamata is a stupid,mad,narchist who is hell bent upon playing the dirtiest kind of politics.Let the Nandigram issue be resolved without further bloodshed;possible only if both sides show some flexibility. To understand the 30 year stint,take a look at the bengal congress heads;I shudder to think of Somen Mitra or Adhir Chowdhury as CM.Indira Gandhi had an understanding with Jyoti Basu the smae way she had with MGR.She would see to it that Jyoti Basu/MGR will stay in power at the state level by keeping third grade people at the helm of these state units.In return,Jyoti Babu/MGR will support her at the center directly or indirectly.This way,she gets to eleminate challenges coming up from her party and also gets the desired support.If Jyoti Babu died earlier than Mrs.Gandhi,the communists wouldn't have lasted 30 years. and who's bothered with an idiot like Kabir Suman? AP has Gadar,Gujarat has Medha Patkar--even they are called intellectuals? If Naxalism is so stupid and idiotic,why is it now the biggest movement in India which has been termed the biggest security threat to India by our PM?mind you,naxalism in this form is not a contribution of bengal,it has started basically from AP.I am totally anti-naxalite,but if this movement which is actualy beig done by very poor backward people is gaining so much momentum,the conditions must be terrible enough for people to take up arms. It has been proved that communism does not work but the countries that have dismantled communism aren't doing any great even after 20 years.
RE:Bengali
by on Mar 15, 2007 03:14 PM Permalink
Which particular province do you belong to, my dear? I am asking this question because, after this messege, your state/community will start irritating me as well.
RE:Bengali
by Debdulal Das on Mar 15, 2007 03:07 PM Permalink
who are you to comment like idiotic.... yes bengali know how a real person protest against all odds... think about freedom from British, who took the lead role ????? you b. s.
RE:Bengali
by on Mar 15, 2007 03:19 PM Permalink
Probably because of the high tempered nature, Bengalis pioneered the national movements against British once upon a time :-)
RE:Bengali
by Parthaananda Subho on Mar 15, 2007 03:08 PM Permalink
You are just a stupid, what Bengalis are you need not have to difine. How much you know about Swami Vivekananda, Rabindra Nath Tagore, Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose, Satyajit Ray, Amartya Sen, Mohd. Yunus and many such gigantic person from Bengali origin. You illeterate, just tell me you belong to which provice if you have guts.
RE:RE:RE:Bengali
by Kasyap on Mar 15, 2007 03:25 PM Permalink
Intelligence of a community is not measured by whether they opposed computers or not or whether they form a union or not, you have brains, but skewed to be sure.. read up some Indian history and you'll understand contribution and position of bengal
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Bengali
by sumit dutta on Mar 15, 2007 04:04 PM Permalink
I read in the newspapers that a woman gets raped every other day in delhi.I read that in broad daylight,in front of thousands,a police officer raped a girl at a busy crossing in bombay and hundreds died sinmly because it rained.i read that an auto strike paralysed bangalore. iread that officials of the TN govt. made millions siphoning the money meant for Tsunami relief victims.I read that farmers are still killing themselves they way they have been doing for the past 10 years in AP. I dread to read about Bihar-the wild west of India!! Tell me which newspaper/magazine I should read where it states that bongs are at the bottom of the pile and the top of the pile are fellow citizens who are doing exactly the same things and worse
RE:Bengali
by kaushik thakurata on Mar 15, 2007 03:07 PM Permalink
my dear friend,dont jum to any conclusion by seeing this incident.Bengal has given this nation a lot.to name it,right from literature,culture,sports and politics and even industrial perspectives,it is one of the pioneers of this country.this issue is very much sensitive.dont hurt any people's mind.this type of racial discremenation should be avoided.....
RE:RE:Bengali
by kaushik thakurata on Mar 15, 2007 03:10 PM Permalink
hey you bloody busturd!what do you think about yourself?do you think that most of bengalis support mamata?then she should get much votes in elections......even when she called bandh earlier days,bengali people prove her wrong by working in office....so you mr. bullsheet or whatever,stop your motive to divide this country.
RE:RE:RE:RE:Bengali
by sumit dutta on Mar 15, 2007 03:43 PM Permalink
when Indira Gandhi died and the delhi wallahs were burning innocent Sardarjis,could you have asked people to atend office?when gujarat was burning ,were people attending offices? nowadays,most people go to work on bandh days unless the conditions looks certain that there is going to be violence in the streets.Anyway,me and most of my colleagues will be attending office tomorrow and we do not believe that it is a case of having balls.The way you are trying to put it,as if these things happen solely in Bengal.At least our top politicians like Buddha babu,Biman Bose,Mamata are light years of the rest of India in terms of honesty.At least we do not go on riots when our favorite matinee idol dies of old age.At least we do not kill or throw people of other provinces out of Bengal.Nor do auto-walahs abuse you if you refuse to pay 5 times the price.Neither does one bengali show blind favouritism to another in the workplace simply because he happems to be a bengali
RE:RE:Bengali
by sumit dutta on Mar 15, 2007 03:27 PM Permalink
The transition of India from the dark,middles ages of muslim rule is known as the renaisance.This renaissance started in Bengal.Behind every industrialisation(Swmai Vivekananda inspired Jamshedji Tata to setup TISCO,the first large scale heavy engineering works were taken up by Sir R.N.mukherjee),every social reform movement (Raja Rammohan roy got the practice of Sati banned,Ishwar Chandra Vidya Sagar started child and widow re-marriage,not to mention Swami Vivekananda who proved to the world that we are not a land of uncivilised savages but an ancient civilised race) to movies(Satyajit Ray-only indian to have won a lifetime achievement Oscar),literature(Tagore's 'song offerings' and subsequnet nobel prize showed the world that our literary and aestheitic senses were second to none),economics(the curent index of the World Bank and IMF is based largely on developmenal economics--a subject brought forward by Prof. Amartya Sen) "stupid ass" bengalis are everywhere.Pre-Independence,the British shifted the political capital to Delhi and post Independence,leaders at the center marginalised Bengal by shifting the financial centers to Bombay.The 1947 partition followed by 1971 war led to massive inflow of population and the infrastructure of Bengal broke down completely. A person who doesn't know the above facts may be excused for ignorance,after all,we see ignorant idiots all over the place.But,to bray like a donkey without knowing is simply unfathomable. Buddha babu is a sane man with great ideas and a vision,he may have had problems with implementing them.Mamata is a stupid,mad,narchist who is hell bent upon playing the dirtiest kind of politics.Let the Nandigram issue be resolved without further bloodshed;possible only if both sides show some flexibility.
RE:RE:RE:Bengali
by Debashis Basu on Mar 15, 2007 04:20 PM Permalink
That's Impressive. But Sumit,bengalies like us, with some brains and understanding are getting outnumbered everyday.
RE:Bengali
by sabujbaran basu on Mar 15, 2007 03:22 PM Permalink
Hi, I DONT KNOW UR PEDIGREE.IF U HAVE ANY CONFUSION ABOUT BENGALEE PLEASE CHECK OUT THE NAME OF WRTER OF UR NATIONAL ANTHEM,IF UR AN INDIAN.U MAY ALSO CHECK OUT THE RECORD OF SOURAV AS CAPTAIN. I don't support govt. action at Nandigram. Bihar was the most sage place in midienal India.U may not support politics but u should know that NALANDA was in Bihar. Sabuj.
It's a Defining moment in the histroy of Bengal and India.Central Govt has to take the action immediatly.Many families have lost their lives.This matter has to be setteled peacefully. not by violance
RE:It's a Defining moment in the histroy of Bengal and India.
by mihir on Mar 15, 2007 03:20 PM Permalink
it is very bad, that people had to shed blood for sake of industtrialisation. my sympathies with the families. I am not from bengal but I am opposed to the project, because I want all growth and industrial, IT etc; to happen only in my neighbourhood--south and west.
this incident will roll back bengal to 1990s.. bengal people dont deserve growth.
This is worse than the 'Jaliawalan babh' incident. When all govts and spineless administration are licking feet of corrupt and incensitive capitalists we can only see repitition of such events more frequently.
RE:Nandigram carnage
by Kasyap on Mar 15, 2007 03:36 PM Permalink
when they do it in other states its for development and when they do it in WB its 'Jaliawalanabagh'.. CONGRATS!!!!
It's a Defining moment in the histroy Bengal and India.Central Govt has to take the action immediatly.Many families have lost their lives.This matter has to be settele peacefully. not by violance.
RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by TSN Xumar on Mar 15, 2007 03:01 PM Permalink
Mamata as a CM = NIGHTMARE
Buddha IS THE RIGHT CM
Those who talk of peasants - forget that this violence has been incited by an unruly mob of villagers. Buddha has done the RIGHT thing - we should all support him
RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by unni t on Mar 15, 2007 03:07 PM Permalink
yes budhda did a fantastic job. bcose he had killed innocent peoples.... congrats budhdha. kill again and again and show your parties excat agenda
RE:RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by Greg Chappell on Mar 15, 2007 03:15 PM Permalink
I agree that was a wrong step by Buddha. But apart from this incident, he is the best CM in India.
RE:RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by Debashis Basu on Mar 15, 2007 03:43 PM Permalink
Yes, T Unii, you are right! Buddhababu is killing innicent people everyday!He actully is trying to catch up with other politicians with criminal records! Innocent people of Nandigram threw bombs to police and open fire with pipe guns and desi pistols.If they can be called as innocent then dacoits, bankrubbers, hooligans are to be redefined; and above all, in which category should we place ourselves??! Debashis basu
RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by Greg Chappell on Mar 15, 2007 03:09 PM Permalink
The Most unfortunate thing in this episode is lots of innocent Women and Children were killed because they were made "Bali ka Bakhra" by rebels. Buddha is a good CM. But he should have handled it very very carefully
RE:RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by Bengal Lover on Mar 15, 2007 04:30 PM Permalink
buddha is the worst kind of stalinist communist and he worst kind of despot that independent India hs seen
RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by Pinaki Basu on Mar 15, 2007 03:28 PM Permalink
then why stopped killing carry on till the last man oppose
RE:RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by Greg Chappell on Mar 15, 2007 03:51 PM Permalink
It is stopped, because innocent women and childred died in Gun battle ( Bad trick by Rebels to put them on front)
RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by Bengal Lover on Mar 15, 2007 03:13 PM Permalink
TSN KUMAR YOU MUST BE A POLITBURO MEMBER IN DISGUISE. THE DECISION FOR THE COMITTING OF THIS GENOCIDE WS TAKEN BY THE POLITBURO
RE:RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by Greg Chappell on Mar 15, 2007 03:17 PM Permalink
ELIMINATE killer Rebels(Nxals and Moists) MAMATA Things will be absolutely fine for WHOLE COUNTRY
RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by Bengal Lover on Mar 15, 2007 03:07 PM Permalink
MAMATA AS M = NIGHTMARE AS PER YOU. BUDDHA AS CM = NO DAY ONLY NIGHT. RAPE OF WOMEN. NO RIGHT TO FREE SPEECH. THE CPM CADRES DID NOT ALLOW THE MEDIA TO GO TO NANDIGRAM TO SEE THE ATROCITIES THEY WERE COMMITTING. INDER INSTRUCTIONS FROM BUDDHA. MAMATA NEED NOT BE CM BUT NO BUDDHA AT LEAST.
RE:RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by Greg Chappell on Mar 15, 2007 03:11 PM Permalink
Do tell s**t. Jyoti Basu did not do anything for WB but Buddha is doing a lots...
But this incident was unfortunate... But never think to bring Mamata in power.
RE:RE:RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by partha das on Mar 15, 2007 03:40 PM Permalink
What bad things you are expecting if Mamata becomes a CM ? Has she done anything wrong while she was in the Rail Ministry (except resigning from there) ? You can take that as a trailer. Or has her party done anything wrong when Subrata Mukherjee was the Mayor ?
ANY BODY STAYS IN POWER FOR SO LONG BECOMES ARROGANT AS WAS CONGRESS IN 70'S
RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by sumit dutta on Mar 15, 2007 04:16 PM Permalink
the 'unofficial' death toll must be much higher. None of us know what actually happened.We are all listening/reading to diff. media versions and accordingly formulating our beliefs based on our ideolgies. The death of so many people who were not,according to our Gov. HE G.K.Gandhi "terrorists,anti-nationals,foreign soldiers" is lamentable whatever be the circumstances.It cannot be 'GREAT WORK' buddha babu is in the right direction but there seems to problems regarding the implementation of his ideas
RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by Debdulal Das on Mar 15, 2007 03:13 PM Permalink
No TSN Xumar Buddha not done right, then he is like Edi Amin, Pol Pot, Hitlar, Stalin........... yes we must do industry but not on the grave of any simple people
RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by abhijeet dasgupta on Mar 15, 2007 02:55 PM Permalink
How many peasants you want to see killed in order to maintain CPI(M)'s hegemony?
RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by Greg Chappell on Mar 15, 2007 02:59 PM Permalink
I don't want to see anymore killings....neither, I want to see the "Brainless" , "Directionless", Mamata as a CM
RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by Soham Dutta on Mar 15, 2007 03:00 PM Permalink
Someone wants to change, someone wishes to bring the industries, yet, there is that someone who wont let it happen! Never been a leftist, but will always support Buddhadeb!
RE:RE:RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by sumit dutta on Mar 15, 2007 04:10 PM Permalink
Mamata is wrong in doing what she is doing and so are the naxalites .Buddha babu has to answer one question?if the mob did not have guns/other sophisticated weapons,why couldn't the police use tear gas,water cannons,rubber bullets?also,if the police had to opne fire,the standard firing position is kneeling down so that you hit the area below the knees. Once people started falling couldn't the police have dtopped and taken stock of the situation? these actions would have reduced the numbers. i speak from my experience of being in police firings
RE:RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by partha das on Mar 15, 2007 03:32 PM Permalink
So, Mr. Soham you want to say that, if Govt. wants your land for industrial growth you will give it gladly? Do you?
RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by Sanjay Baxi on Mar 15, 2007 03:16 PM Permalink
How many farmers commited suicide in Andhra and Maharashtra and Karnataka??????????
RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by abhijeet dasgupta on Mar 15, 2007 02:58 PM Permalink
mamata is immaterial here, talk about the peasants
RE:RE:How many of you want to see Mamata as next CM of West Bengal?
by Greg Chappell on Mar 15, 2007 03:06 PM Permalink
It is unfortunate to see lot of people are killed there but according to different news sources accross india, that place was full of Naxalites, who made poor Woman and Children as baricade to protect themselves. Eliminate all those Moists and Naxalites, who are killing hundreds of people per month. see the news from Chattisgarh where the rebels killed 50 policemen.
This is a classic case of state sponsored terrorism. The facts is - the left front government has become arrogant, insane, insensitive and cruel. Power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely. The CPI(M) cannot stand any opposition. If there is a whiff of miniscule opposition by a few villagers who want to stick to their only means of livelihood, the government/CPI(M) is going to kill them. That is the message they wanted to convey and they have done it successfully. My friends - I believe most of you belong to the middle and upper middle classes, aren\'t you ashamed that such murder of democracy is taking place in our own country? We the middle class is going to benefit from industrialisation, that is true. But is it worth the blood of poor peasants of Nandigram and Singur? Does it justify the petty gains we dream of in the name of industrialisation?
We condemn Jaliawalan bagh incident till date, but this is worse than that. Whole got and admin shamelessly sides with corrupt and most incensetive capitalists
Dear freinds lets support our poor farmer of Nandigram, who were being killed by self called secular and social communist demon. Lets vote out these communist and congress is also culprit in this case.
According to me shifting of power in W.Bengal is almost impossible as CPM's cadre cum Gundaas are enough strong to handle election matters,but this is strange that last 30 yrs CPM is doing this and Congress / central govt was/is sitting in the audience. Congress and BJP both shd clarify why both of them allowed to cont. the gundaraaj of CPM in W.Bengal for long long time.This is more strange that BJP also not tried to do something in favour of democracy atleast for eyewash. How CPM is so strong????????????????????????
