This is horrendously weak instance of justice as the judge was under tremendous pressure for delivering an exempalry punishment on Sanjay to appease a particular section of the convicts who had been crying foul on the discrimination shown against them while announcing the verdict. When the judge himslef has clearly said in his judgement that the crimes committed by Dutt and his friends Adajania and Nulwalla were not "anti-social, ghastly, inhuman, immoral or pre-planned" and did not cause any harm to the general public and when these delinquents have been taken off from the TADA jurisdiction, there was no reason why Sanjay and his friends would be meted out such harsh punishment particularly when u know that they have conducted themselves so well in the last 14 years of your so called trials. 14 years is too long a time for any crime to stand trial of our system of justice. When your life imprisonment is only that much, this shows that your judgment against people like Sanjay, who have really suffered enough for the crime they have committed in the last 14 years of trial and so donot deserve the degree of punishment they have been handed out now. There was a clear case of treating the case under probation of offenders act. U have erred in your late justice and does not do great justice to our system of judiciary. sunil
RE:No justice
by navneet singhrajput on Aug 01, 2007 12:45 PM Permalink
balak jab tera padosi AK56 rakhega tab tum aisi mail nahi likhoge....I consider this as a great verdict and first time in my life I noticed that the law has treated all individual without discrimination and irrespective of their status. I think now Sadhu Singh, Shahabuddina nd Shibu Shiron must be thinking what is going to happen with them.
RE:No justice
by Sandeep on Aug 01, 2007 01:11 PM Permalink
Here is an append from Hemal Patel(some pages back) which goes into more details at the time. "" All of you pepople crying 'justice is done, justice is done' please read this. I am born and baught up in Mumbai. 1992 riots were unpresidented. Male members of each and every house in mumbai equipped themselves with stones, rods, chilli powder and whatever they could. I remember myself stacking up stones in my balcony. Such was the terror in people's mind without any specific threat.
Sanjay dutt got threats that his sisters would be raped and burned alive, riotors came in big mobs. He had registered compained in bandra police station, and asked for additional police protection but was denied. He saught AK56 for protection of his Family.
I can tell that each and every member posting here would do exactly what he did. Only a powerful weapon like AK56 can offer protection against a rioting mob. He got it via underworld connection which was a crime and for which he already served 1.5 years in jail and 13 years of agony, this is punishement enough. He has not harmed anyone and is not a threat to the society.
Who is going to benefit from his jail time? instead judge could have given him 6 years of social service sentence, that would be much more productive.
This is justice without heart. Its not going to benefit anyone. "" Looking at this, it seems a bit lenient sentence would have been fine. Remember also that Sanjay did not have same threat level as ordinary perso
RE:Sanjay Dutta's punishment
by cj on Aug 01, 2007 01:35 PM Permalink
supposed u lost your dad/mom/brother/relatives in bombblast at that time what u suggest punishment of that person who involved in that case, reply man
Sanjay's lawyers have already pettitioned in Supreme Court both for leniancy and probation, He will be free within no time and be in movies no doubt.But whatever justice has been served hope it will serve for other big people as well who are going scott free. Hope some one is hearing.
