Discussion Board
Watch this board

Total 165 messages Pages < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >
What are we fighting for?
by Syed Noor on Feb 19, 2007 12:42 PM  Permalink  | Hide replies

Dear Brothers & Sisters, One question is eating my head out here... WHAT ARE WE FIGHTING FOR? A geographical border called 'India' & 'Pakistan'.. few man made boundaries? Or for the sake of Religion? I don't understand the concept of our differences... what are we differing in?

Please try and understand that.. the life is too small say around 60 - 70 years on average.. don't fight... love each other and spread the message of peace... teach to the people about good things in your respective religions... don't show them the path of hate.

It is believed in the religion of Islam that 'Killing a person is like killing the whole of humanity'; considering this... it is very clear that... a person/s killing innocent people cannot be in the fold of islam and cannot be considered as a muslim.

So My dear brothers & sisters... whoever is considerating Muslims as terrorist should check back the past... what happened in Gujrat? in UP in 1992? in Bangalore recently? or anywhere else where muslims were the target of some anti-social elements in INDIA.

I as a muslim do feel that this country is mine and i'm an indian... and i'm proud to be an indian. So please stop abusing the muslims for anything & everything, spread the message of peace, humanity and brotherhood. STOP THE NON-SENSE. I request my brothers & sisters to please avoid those people who are trying to spread hate amongst people, who are trying to destroy the peaceful INDIA. Don't listen to them.. Don't reply to them. Ignore them, Block them... Don't let them take our for peaceful nature.

If anyone feel that.. i'm on the wrong side.. please advice me... suggest me... i'm open to any kind of discussion regarding Muslims & India, provided no one should abuse any of the religion.. though it be Islam, Hinduism or anythings else. PLEASE.

I pray to God that.. May he keep all of us in peace. And Destroy the ill-minded thoughts from the heart and minds of culprits. And also guide them to right path.

Thanks & Regards
AFTAB

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
RE:RE:What are we fighting for?
by jay malhotra on Feb 19, 2007 01:40 PM  Permalink
We need more muslims like Aftab but alas we do not have that. Therefore we need more people like Narendra Modi to face the islamic terrorists.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:What are we fighting for?
by mohd amul on Feb 19, 2007 02:31 PM  Permalink
let me tell u gujarati never had a hard fight in the history. their participation in indian army is lowest. everyone know their phusique.
regarding modi, yeah he misused police. But muslim never joined hands.
why is generalisation, if some one does.
no body said when delhi pedophile is a hindu, then all hindu are pedophile.
muslims are so weak, even if u take al qaeda, even the worst military like saudi chased them down. muslim extremist are powerless. what makes them to do is ur hate, if you continue they will continue.
america labelled that term to get access to middle east wealth.
if indian hindus dont stop generalising there is civil war ahead



   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:What are we fighting for?
by mahesh kumar on Feb 19, 2007 03:59 PM  Permalink
civil war is already going on..it may become inevtiable..but then.muslims in other parts of the world are doing the same..india may be divided again,.but muslims will have as much tough time..

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:What are we fighting for?
by mohd amul on Feb 19, 2007 04:30 PM  Permalink
no dear. if one educated muslim can make a big difference. In india you will find thousands. if they enter india will shatter

Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:What are we fighting for?
by jay malhotra on Feb 19, 2007 04:51 PM  Permalink
Mr Amul,

That is the biggest problem with muslims as they think that everybody is against them. Anybody can provoke them. They dont look back what they have done in the past with countries like India and they never learn to change themselves rather proud on their past deeds.
If America is labelling muslims as terrorist who is helpint them, its Saudi Arabia. Why dont muslims raise a Jihad against Saudi Arabia. If muslims are illitrate and backward who is stoping them to read and advance in life, especially in democratic countries like USA and India.
My friend you dont need Jehad against the non muslims you need it against the evils inside you. You dont kill the infidels as if Allah is the true god their is no infidel in the world.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
RE:RE:RE:What are we fighting for?
by Bharat on Feb 19, 2007 02:23 PM  Permalink
Dear friend (Jay Malhotra),

You are 100% right..

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
RE:RE:What are we fighting for?
by ANIL DHYANI on Feb 19, 2007 02:20 PM  Permalink
Hi Bharat, I agree too for your words which are 100% correct.

Anil

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:What are we fighting for?
by sorry on Feb 19, 2007 01:33 PM  Permalink
Dear Aftab,

What do you say about these quotes in Quran! Do you say that they don't exist?

http://www.ethicalatheist.com/docs/islam_infidels.html

See here



   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:What are we fighting for?
by joen jenson on Feb 19, 2007 05:05 PM  Permalink
what the hell for them if sadam was hanged, is he ur nighbour or blood relative

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:What are we fighting for?
by ravi verma on Feb 19, 2007 01:02 PM  Permalink
Dear Aftab

Who is saying Muslims are the terrist?but the same time it is also true that wherever in the world if any terrist is captured that is muslim(99%).why just think?

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:What are we fighting for?
by ravi verma on Feb 19, 2007 01:05 PM  Permalink
Dear Aftab

Who is saying Muslims are the terrist?but the same time it is also true that wherever in the world if any terrist is captured that is muslim(99%).why just think?

and you remember only Gujrat & UP,u dont remember what happend in past and what is happening in kasmir with hidus?


   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:What are we fighting for?
by on Feb 19, 2007 01:21 PM  Permalink
I am repeating again.Let me know about one copuntry where there is terrorism and no muslim involved?

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:What are we fighting for?
by R Faisal on Feb 19, 2007 02:47 PM  Permalink
SRI LANKA ... NEPAL ... BHUTAN ... INDIA (recntly in Assam against Bihari migrant workers) ... etc in South Asia. So read the Indian and world history at least for the last 200 years, you will surely broaden your understanding.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:What are we fighting for?
by on Feb 19, 2007 06:43 PM  Permalink
There is no terrorism in Sri Lanka unless you are talking about governmental terrorism. Everyone else is fighting for equal rights.

Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:What are we fighting for?
by srivatsa yb on Feb 19, 2007 02:52 PM  Permalink
SRILANKA

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:What are we fighting for?
by on Feb 19, 2007 06:43 PM  Permalink
There is no terrorism in Sri Lanka unless you are talking about governmental terrorism. Everyone else is fighting for equal rights.

Forward   |   Report abuse
LOSE- LOSE
by Saroj Vinerkar on Feb 19, 2007 12:29 PM  Permalink 

Every one is looser, people who execute such inhuman plan and people who have lost their loved ones, people who are injured.

Such acts only shows that there are few human being who have lost their sensitivity , human touch and feelings toward human beings.

It is sad that when every one is born human, with human heart.. there are some who ashame their creater by developing so much hatred in their heart for other human being that it will ashame even ferocious and wildest animal on this earth.

Let people who are engage in this activities realise that there is no winner in such terrorist acts. Today lot of innocent lives are lost and severly affected. Let them realise that they too are creation of god, let them interiorise and introspect to see their achievements from such act. Let them realise even their own families, friends and loved ones will once be victim of achievements of some other who will achievers through such barbaric act.

No money can compensate lost lives and scars of injured.


    Forward  |  Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator. | Hide replies
RE:No hope
by imran shaikh on Feb 19, 2007 12:50 PM  Permalink
In Quran, there is no sentence like what you have mentioned - "Every non- muslim is kafir i.e 'infidel'and has no right to live".
I do not know from where you have found this. 'Muslim' is Arabic word which means 'Believer of Allah' and 'Kafir' is the Arabic word which means 'non believer of Allah'.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:No hope
by sorry on Feb 19, 2007 01:17 PM  Permalink
Check it out on your own website

http://www.answering-islam.de/Main/NonMuslims/rights.htm

Dunno when your religion will practice peace!

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:No hope
by mohd amul on Feb 19, 2007 02:38 PM  Permalink
let me tell you, even books like aristotle and all greek scientist they are translated from arabic.europe was in dark ages since the birth of human kind.
world map is drawn by muslim. since 200 yrs things have changed because of stupid leaders.
may be things will be differnt in 50yrs.
everybody know how europe and india was before industrial revolution.
let me tell you even einstein is a arab christian.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:No hope
by mohd amul on Feb 19, 2007 02:43 PM  Permalink
eistein arab jew

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Urgent Need to Stop Confidence Building Measures.
by Karan Hi on Feb 19, 2007 12:22 PM  Permalink  | Hide replies

India Should stop all Confidence building Measures with Pakistan. Please Treat this as wake up call.

Pakistan is not intrested in Indian Muslims., but only Kashmir. Thier One Point Agenda.

The People and Adminstration out thier is Confrontonist.

They are not intrested in Trade with India as they think it will swallow thier industries.

They Openly Shelter Bomb Blast Accused like Dawood Ibrahim. besides all the other ISI activities.

Please stop this non sense to appease Indian Muslims.They would be more happy in India without pakistan bothering them.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
RE:Urgent Need to Stop Confidence Building Measures.
by atindra shukla on Feb 19, 2007 01:38 PM  Permalink
Actually they are there to build confidence of terrorists.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Fellow Citizens, Pls wake-up
by Aras kumar on Feb 19, 2007 12:19 PM  Permalink 

Dear Citizens,

After going through this report of this tragedy, i would like to make awareness within our fellow citizens.

This incident shows us the "Terror" can happen by "ANYWAY". We, the citizens should help/assist the government to avoid this kind of tragedies.

Take this incident. The bombs were planted in 4 to 5 bogies and kerosene bottles were kept in all these bogies to spread the fire across all these bogies.

Anyone of the fellow citizens, sure must have seen or noticed or observed while carrying or planting or in any otherway of this terrorist activities. Fellow citizens should have alarmed the security forces and that could have avoided this tragedy. But didn't.

Our Indian Citizens are not bothered about who is our neighbour / what he is doing. Pls be understand, Indian Government alone can't give 100% security to everyone. We, the Citizens should also bother about our safety & observe the wrong thing happening around us and inform the Government agencies to act on it.

This link in India is totally missing.
Fellow Citizens, Pls wake-up and avoid this kind of terrorism to get sucess in the future.

An Indian Citizen



    Forward  |  Report abuse
hypocrats everywhere
by ANITEK BHATTACHARYA on Feb 19, 2007 12:19 PM  Permalink 

Peace talk, freindship on the one hand and training capm for terrorists on the other hand, can not exist simultaneously.
It is hyprocasy ! This msg is for Mr. Musaraff and Mr. Manmohan Singh. If it is diplomacy, then write this diplomacy with blood as Mountbatain did in prepartition year. Be bold, donot follow the legacy of Britishers. Shame !
indian

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator. | Hide replies
Message deleted by moderator
RE:Read the name...
by J S on Feb 19, 2007 12:14 PM  Permalink
Guys, all of us have been nicely conned into fighting amongst ourselves.

THIS IS JUST WHAT THE TERRORISTS WANTED.

DOES ANYONE KNOW OF THE 4000 PEOPLE WHO DIE CROSSING MUMBAI'S RAILWAY TRACKS _EVERY_ _YEAR_ ? Extend that figure to entire Indian Railways. Then, think of road accidents. Then think of mass murders in Bihar and Assam. Then think of poverty deaths and suicides. They are far far bigger issues. Think a little.

Don't foolishly _obey_ the terrorist ideology of hatred.

HINDU OR MUSLIM, ALL OF US WHO FIGHT AND HATE ARE ACTUALLY _HELPING_ TERRORISTS.

Guys, wake up, this is plain economics and politics, religion is just used to stoke people's emotions.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:Read the name...
by on Feb 19, 2007 12:18 PM  Permalink
Here comes another reformer.You should become a BABA and preach on AASTHA channel.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:RE:Read the name...
by Amit Singhvi on Feb 19, 2007 12:37 PM  Permalink
Atleast this J S he is trying to reform, babas dont talk about reform, they talk abt what is past and written. And you cant even show your name on the post to be recognise. And remember, bhagat singh was a reformer, gandhi was a reformer. Now better you dont try to analyze this. Tere bas ki baat nahi hai.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:Read the name...
by M Tabish on Feb 19, 2007 02:26 PM  Permalink
Dude, u r so overwhelmingly jealous of us Muslims that u cannot see past our names! ("name begins wid the word Muhamamd ... must be voilent" -thats wat u think and that%u2019s wat u have been made to think)

This is all of course due to the media --plus the 911 HOAX/conspiracy... ! Moot this: If 911 hadnt hppnd u wouldnt perceive us as "terrorists" !!! I cant prove to u in this short space that 911 was indeed a Goerge Bush conspiracy but if u juzz open ur minds to a slight , and very distinct possibility that 911 indeed was staged, then u can understand the hatred a "muslim" will have for USA/Israel! (and the consequential backlash)

Look at any 911 movie closely and u ll see urself how it was all done. The WTC towers came down in 8.5 and 10 seconds respectively! Thety were 1368 ft tall.. so if u know even the slightest of physics u can calculate the FREEFALL time of the towers to be = 9 sec ... Compare this time to the actual one i.e. 8.5 and 10 seconds for the north and south towers n u ll c that the towers came down at FREEFALL speeds...The only way buildings can collapse at free fall speed into their own footprints is by engineered demolition. Explosives are used to remove the support of floors below before the debris from above arrives. Otherwise, resistance is encountered and the time required for fall increases!

The "official explaination" was that the towers pancaked one floor onto another. If this was true then the towers should have come down in 1min 45 secs (calculated for pancake collapse with least resistance from each floor under) %u2013 much longer than the actual 9 seconds.

{Also, the initial fireball at the time of crash and the following few minutes consumed most of the fuel (agreed by all scientists) and the fires thereafter were not at all %u201Craging%u201D. Also, smoke is a sign of oxygen starved combustion which means that the fire is not burning efficiently. (u c all the smoke for all the hour and 45 minutes till the towers collapse.}

N where are the floors at ground ZERO.. a pancake collapse will NOT pulverize everything to dust like it was seen in the collapse. What kind of energy pulverized reinforced steel, & concrete in front of ur very eyes? THINK! Does jet fuel have that kind of energy?

I have literally tens of more eye opening points if u'd wanna learn more! (email : egonomics@gmail.com) Starting from the eye witnesses, the firefighters and ppl inside the building complaining of many EXLOSIONS --both mid level and ground level explosions --

n u ll love this one -- It is a known fact that sound travels slower than what u see --i mean, if there is an explosion far away, u ll SEE it before u can HEAR it--TRUE?
GO see the WTC collapse... the sound is heard BEFORE the collapse -- n thats the sound of the last of the BIG explosions going off -- that takes down the building! Go see it for urself!

N Read this: NO BUILDING HAS EVER EVER EVER come down due to FIRE...! True infernos have raged long and hard in many buildings burning for 20 long hours BUT not one has EVERY come down.
N on Sept 11, 2001 not one , not two, but THREE heavily steel reinforced buildings, that could stand the continuous battering of the fierce New York winds, came down. (three because South and North towers and also WTC 5 which was the STRANGEST of all the collapses)

HEED THIS: The reason for WTC Tower 5 collapse was rubble and sm fire from the North tower falling onto WTC 5! HAHAHAHAHA! DO U BELEIVE THAT???

Now why did Goerge W.Bush do all this? Why would he take down two of his finest buildings? why?

1. Main reason: To instill fear in the heart n minds of the US ppl so that they could get on board on his plan for war wid IRAQ (Afghanistan was juzz a hurdle along the road.. not the AIM)

n why IRAQ... SIMPLE ANSWER: OIL -->MONEY!

2. In Iraq again.. If US loses for example a TANK in the war, the %u2018Carlyle group%u2019, where GW Bush and his family have huge investments, makes money; and if Iraq loses a Tank i.e US wins %uF0E0 they get the OIL! (n dont even mention the PUPPET REGEIME installed by Bush in Iraq)

2. Larry Silverstein: The land owner of the WTC towers. He bought the land in July 2001, 2 months before the attack for $100 million for a 99 year lease... revamped and worked his insurance policies and after teh attacks claimed $7 BILLION for the attacks. n WHATS a fabulous return that is for his initial $100 million investment? wat say?

3. N why did they take down WTC 5 tower, i hear u ask! Well here is the list of the tenants who had offices in that WTC5 tower.
FBI , CIA, Secret service, Mayor Juliaani, and some insurance companies!
So need i say more for why they took down WTC 5?
WTC 5 was the COMMAND CENTRE from where Sept 11 was MASTERMINDED!


I m NOT getting into all the events that happend ON THAT DAY including the mid-level, ground level and basement explosions, unscheduled evacuation drills in the weeks leading upto 911 and the complete INACTION of NORAD whose sole purpose is to keep the skies secure for the citizens of US! Even if I try to get my ehad around their incompetence it is hard to believe I can understand that after the first tower was hit,
It could have been mistaken as an %u201Caccident%u201D BUT after the 2nd tower was hit and %u201CTERRORIST ATTACK%u201D was indeed confirmed and city was on high alert, how can NORAD not take action on a placne that goes dramatically off course and was heading the PENTAGON??? HOws that possible unless theyw ere asked to %u201CSTAND DOWN%u201D! n who has THAT power%u2014Chief of state George W. bush!

N the Pentagon.. who knows wat hit there? Not a commercial plane that%u2019s for sure. Firstly, the alleged terrorists pilots that manned that aircraft were flying school DROPOUTS and in their instructors own words %u201Ccould not even drive a car let alone a palce%u201D :P Sp the Pentagon claims that these dropout pilots flew a commercial plane 8m off the ground and crashed into the pentagon. Now apart from the fact that even the best skilled pilots in US cant fly a commercial plane 8m of the ground (the best can probably fly a smaller plane but not a commercial airliner), these %u201Cdropouts%u201D chose to maneuver the plane 270degrees and hit the side of the pentagon that was being renovated and not directly plunge the plane into Donald Rumsfeld%u2019s office%u2026 HOW thoughtful of them? HAHA

N Here is a lil surprise for u: Pentagon is THE MOST HEAVILY SURVEILLED AREA in the US if not in the world%u2026would u agree? Yet only two frames (not even photos%u20262 frames) of the crash were released and neither of them showed what actually hit the Pentagon. Gimme a break! N wats more, soon after the crash FBI and CIA agents drove to the nearly groceries and petrol pumps to confesticate their cameras which might have been pointing in the direction of the crash!!!
Wat else do u wanna know%u2026 Not convinced yet? I have many more but juzz cant list all the facts here! BUt i hope u get the jist.

So wats the relevance of all this IN THIS FORUM?
The relevance is this.... WE MUSLIMS have been INTENTIONALLY stereotyped to be violent and Terrorists! If u have not done a certain crime (eg.rape) and still u r stereotyped by the society to be a rapist, wouldn%u2019t u feel disgusted, revolted and rebellious? ANd specially when teh person calling YOU a rapist is himself a RAPIST? (Meaning GW bush calling Muslims terrorists!)

N THE SADDEST part of the whole story is that MEDIA (cnn, bbc, aajtak nad all Indian and world MEDIA) NEVER ever brought the whole 911 issue up%u2026 THAt it mite indeed have been a conspiracy%u2026 AS the FACTS clearly suggest.
Just this one fact that %u201CNever in the recorded history of this earth has a building come down due to FIRE %u2013not to mentioned the oxygen deficent 1 hr 45 minute long incomplete combustion (smoke) fire on 911 %u201D

I rest my case!


   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:Read the name...
by jay malhotra on Feb 19, 2007 04:56 PM  Permalink
We dont care if muslim attacjed WTC or was it George Bush.
We are concerned only to the killings in India.Now please dont say that the Mumbai train bomb blasts were done by Manmohan Singh

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:Read the name...
by junaid pk on Feb 19, 2007 12:28 PM  Permalink
hi brother, do Indian muslims need to keep on telling that we are Indians. If you are so specific on that, i will tell that I am proud to be an Indian. I also wish all the terrorists, from whatever religion they are, should be given the most severe punishment allowed in Indian Constitution. And I also request you not to blame Islam for the things done by muslims. Even if 100% of the muslims are terrorists, it cannot mean that Islam is a religion of terrorism. For that you will need to go through Quran to see what it says then you will surely come to know. Islam says that we should love our motherland and we do. May God bring properity to India. Jai Hind

   Forward   |   Report abuse
RE:RE:Read the name...
by on Feb 19, 2007 12:36 PM  Permalink
I agree with u that Islam says that one should love one's motherland but most Indian muslims feel that Pakistan is their motherland and they are still not aware that muslims who crossed over are still second class citizens in Pakistan.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
Desperate Attempt
by Sachin on Feb 19, 2007 12:01 PM  Permalink  | Hide replies

Its a great tragedy and apparently a desperate attempt to derail the peace process. But the fact remains that no amount of checking can prevent such indidents from happening. A 100 % check at Railway Stations will ensure that every train would be late by hours. But is right that this is a sensitive route and greater vigilance was required by security agencies


    Forward  |  Report abuse
RE:Desperate Attempt
by ayush kumar on Feb 19, 2007 12:20 PM  Permalink
Better if you use worst tragedy instead of great ,,,, look very bad

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Total 165 messages Pages: < Newer  | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5   Older >
Write a message