RE:What is Karnataka Govt decision?????????????
by swapna mayappa on Feb 05, 2007 03:41 PM Permalink
We all should break the rule. Should not wait for the useless govt. We should make use of our power
People who support karnataka, should realise that cauvery is covering more demographic area of TN (i.e.) more TN people are depending over it. So think over this point before you write here -VijayaRaghavan
RE:Think Over..
by ramesh r on Feb 05, 2007 03:45 PM Permalink
Do you mean to say that Kashmir should be with Pakistan as J&K State has got More percentage of Muslims? You Stupid Idiot.
RE:Think Over..
by Sunil Kumar on Feb 05, 2007 03:47 PM Permalink
Better die than making this kind of decisions coming to karnataka and staying here and supporting tamil nadu????? Go back to your state and fight from their if you can
RE:RE:Think Over..
by karthikeyan chitraipandain on Feb 05, 2007 04:03 PM Permalink
HAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAH am laughing seeing ur situation sunil...Do u stay in the farmers area or do u know their requirements its just the numeric one ur saying and crying foul and one more thing if u start agitating every IT company will move out of karnataka and u have to beg to other states..do mind that too :)))..
RE:RE:RE:Think Over..
by rohith ml on Feb 05, 2007 04:11 PM Permalink
This IT company cannot go any where other then bangalore if it was it would have moved long back only because of we kannadigas and bangalore water and climate it is still surviviing...ok
RE:Think Over..
by srivatsa yb on Feb 05, 2007 03:44 PM Permalink
what demographic area??show me the stats...just because u produce more ppl does not mean we give all our water...u start family planning
RE:RE:Think Over..
by Sundaree on Feb 05, 2007 03:51 PM Permalink
First save your bangalore. Kannada speaking peoples are less in your capital. We tamilians and Andhirites are devloping your state and your capital baganloooru..
RE:RE:RE:Think Over..
by mahadeva swamy on Feb 05, 2007 04:36 PM Permalink
hello man, if you feel like that you go and take all your people, let us see how nice our Bangalore will be. don't talk foolishly
RE:Think Over..
by Sunil Kumar on Feb 05, 2007 03:45 PM Permalink
Are you from tamil nadu so only you are writing like this.I am in I.T industry are you people work here and dont want to go back to tamil nadu also
RE:RE:Think Over..
by Sundaree on Feb 05, 2007 03:50 PM Permalink
The whole cauvery should be handed over to TN including the dams built inside karnataka. Cauvery is covering more demographic area of TN than other states.
Cauvery should be owned by TN and patriotic peoples of South india will do that and isolate Karnataka.
This is completely a bias decision. Meanwhile, there is nothing to do with public property or the Tamilians. Let's play safe law game for the right justice, not by harming the "yennadas"...
Just because tamilnadu was under british presidency in 19th century and they governed large parts of south india, they could bulldoze the mysore maharaja to do their bidding. and moreover since mysore region lacked the funds, they could not build any dams like what british government did in building mettur dam.probably if Sir Visveswaraiah had not built KRS, we would not have been eligible to draw even one tmc for our needs. Just because of mettur dam, tamil provinces increased their cultivation area and not their right because they dont get so much of rains in their area. Now that we have increased our cultivated area to take care of our food needs, tamil nadu cannot use an 150 year old story to demand excess share. Instead of wasting water and cultivating wetland cultivation of rice and shouting that they dont have sufficient water, let the tamilnadu government teach its farmers to use water in more efficient way like sprinklers, drip irrigation etc which is found to be scientifically tested method and requires only 50% of the water required. If they do so, they will have excess water .
RE:height of insanity
by srivatsa yb on Feb 05, 2007 03:40 PM Permalink
very true and well said...What will happen to future irrigation projects of karnataka??will we get more share then??there is no way that we will accept this verdict
RE:RE:height of insanity
by arnab pal on Feb 05, 2007 03:46 PM Permalink
heyee .. chil chil ... what is this u ppl are upto .. who said karnataka to plan future irrigation projects wen there was a cae pending ... now theyve gotta reframe it according to the ammendment ..
RE:height of insanity
by deepthi madhu on Feb 05, 2007 03:45 PM Permalink
I agree with u. How can we now wage war on a rule that was set up way nack on 1892. I dont understand why Tamilnadu is playing this dirtly game. This case is equal to another issue "Mullaperiyar" between Kerala and Tamilnadu. The river (Periyar) originates from Kerala, flows only thru Kerala and the DAM is also in Kerala. Still Tamilnadu wants FULL water, only bcoz of one alarming agreement for 999 years in 1890s. Since British was in power, the powerful Madars Presidency did this. Now Kerala and Karnataka have to stand united for Mullaperiyar and Cauvery issues and fight against the OLD law.
RE:RE:height of insanity
by Sundaree on Feb 05, 2007 03:52 PM Permalink
Good arguement. In that case why should we be united. Lets separate each states as each country.
RE:RE:RE:height of insanity
by deepthi madhu on Feb 05, 2007 04:01 PM Permalink
hey Sundaree. I never said that Kerala and Karnataka should wage war against TamilNadu. Rather I said to stand united and fight against the OLD law. Actually we should scrap all the pre-independence laws.
this is totally unfair....we are not going to accept this.....k'taka is always being discriminated, or water....coz no much political inflluence from elected ppl to centre...whole country believes that we are soft ppl.we will disproove this time.....
its court order.fine!!!
let there wont be a water for bangalore.....our farmers first....rest next....i am from IT industry from bangalore....but i understand the probs of farmers.coz iam from that background......what happens to everyone let it happen to me also.....
if bangalooreans want water.let they go and knock UPA or sonia gandhi
RE:dont leave water to Bangalore....farmers first, next rest
by ramesh r on Feb 05, 2007 03:53 PM Permalink
Even if we die also, UPA Govt will not react because we are having Janatadal- BJP led Govt. Sonia Gandhi and her Party wanted this opportunity and they used it in a right time. I appeal all Kannadigas not to allow Sonia Gandhi or any Central Ministers into State. Let them go to TN and do what ever they want. They dont have the right to enter this soil .
- Cauvery's total rain water catchment is 740 TMC. This includes areas in TN & Karnataka. - TN to get 419 TMC. - Karnataka to get 270 TMC. - of 419 TMC TN will get 192 TMC from Karnataka, and the rest (227 TMC) from its own rain catchment areas. - This 192 TMC (that TN to get for KA) will be measured from TN border and it is not very high from what is getting, which means Karnataka is not going to loose something much.
Could not understand why people are twisting this judgement as People in Karnataka is going to die of thirst.
People are mean that they don't understand the panel's decision bu simply accuse them of pro-tamil nadu. Shame on you uncivilized literates!!!
RE:Fools!!! Understand the Judgement.
by rational thought on Feb 05, 2007 03:48 PM Permalink
Fools - just about sums it up. This is a city in the Union of India and any Indian can and WILL live here. If it is too much for literate and illiterate fools to understand, then too bad.
RE:Fools!!! Understand the Judgement.
by SHIVA SP on Feb 05, 2007 04:08 PM Permalink
The language used by you proves first of all you are not civilized. You are just like some barbaric uncivilized brutes, who shaved the heads of some karnataka ladies who travelled in TN and spoke ion Kannada some years ago...Its very clear the judgement is biased because of UPA.......undertand this clearly TN political parties play a prominent role here. They can uproot the govt.. if verdict is not in favor of TN.......you better understand this first.
RE:RE:Fools!!! Understand the Judgement.
by Deva Pratap Saathivayal on Feb 05, 2007 04:15 PM Permalink
Mr. SHIVA SP. When I said "Fools" which is the only thing harsh on what I said, it was generic. That means I meant Fools to two set of people. 1. Those that are thinking KA will have to donate TN with 419 TMC 2. Those that think TN will get 419 TMC (from TN's perspective). Now it should be clear to you that I did not target any community. Anyway using a word Fool in a public forum like this isn't very bad but though bad and hence I apologized.
RE:RE:RE:Fools!!! Understand the Judgement.
by Deva Pratap Saathivayal on Feb 05, 2007 04:18 PM Permalink
Again, I won't agree with you that the verdict is biased. Reasons: - Congress the major party in the Central coaliation has its stakes high in KA than in TN. In TN it's almost a dead snake. - DMK can't give so much pressure on this, coz UPA is not so weak currently that exit of DMK will cause no harm to UPA. - They have done extensive study before they let their report out. They are not like you are me to discuss in something in a just way.
RE:RE:Fools!!! Understand the Judgement.
by Deva Pratap Saathivayal on Feb 05, 2007 04:00 PM Permalink
What is said above(numbers) is fact though I was harsh on that. I apologize. Anyway Mr. ramesh r, you did not tell your point yet.
RE:Fools!!! Understand the Judgement.
by abhigna ng on Feb 05, 2007 03:48 PM Permalink
You are right Mr Deva Pratap...Would be happy If you provide more info on this...
- According to you Karnataka has to release 192 TMC of water from KRS and Kabini...right?
RE:Fools!!! Understand the Judgement.
by veera guru on Feb 05, 2007 03:43 PM Permalink
Hello sir Why should karnataka ppl to loose abt 192TMC ? Tamilnadu ppl can get 227TMC from their own rain catching area know? why should they share our own achieved water from the KANNADA BHOOMI? They can happy with their own achieved from their rain catch water know?
RE:RE:Fools!!! Understand the Judgement.
by Deva Pratap Saathivayal on Feb 05, 2007 03:46 PM Permalink
To answer you sir... I need to explain lot. In short you think with in yourself, why are we sharing Indus waters with Pakistan and BrahmaPutra waters with Bangladesh.
Any river will have huge catchment area in upstream and lower catchment area in down stream. You can not split a river with political boundary and argue what you are saying is "just".
RE:RE:RE:Fools!!! Understand the Judgement.
by Sundaree on Feb 05, 2007 03:56 PM Permalink
Let us merge Tamilnadu with Pakistan and teach lessons to kannadigas thru ISI.
RE:RE:RE:RE:Fools!!! Understand the Judgement.
by Rajiv Shivashankar on Feb 05, 2007 04:02 PM Permalink
Are in yr senses? Do u want to be a Pakistani ? No cauvery dispute there. Please go and leave us to solve our problems in sensible ways. v do NOT need such comments from people like u.
Stop talking like an idiot. I am also a Tamilian. We need to make them understand that the judgement is not against them and emphasise the unity. So you want to compare with the rotten ISI of Pakistan and equate Tamilians with Pakistani. No way. Shut your provoking words.
The sc has given its judgement.If there is scanty rainfal what should the karnataka do, to give 419 tmcft. With the rapid growth of bangalore and mysore there is heavy demand for drinking water. Already bagamandala,the birth place of Cauvery is facing shortage of drinking water. First preference should be given to drinking water.
RE:Cauvery tribunal gives TN 419 tmcft, 270 to Karnataka
by Deva Pratap Saathivayal on Feb 05, 2007 03:41 PM Permalink
Mr. rajendraprasad... if there is a scanty rainfall, the jury has said that all states should bear the brunt. That means all state which get lower share, i.e. all will be equally affected.
Info on how water sharing is to be done:
- Cauvery's total rain water catchment is 740 TMC. This includes areas in TN & Karnataka.
- TN to get 419 TMC.
- Karnataka to get 270 TMC.
- of 419 TMC TN will get 192 TMC from Karnataka, and the rest (227 TMC) from its own rain catchment areas.
RE:abt verdict
by daniel on Feb 05, 2007 04:14 PM Permalink
We no need anyone's blood.. We need water for our dieing farmers.. We all here to live not to fight.. "Anbe Sivam"
