Please note that verdict does not say that Karnataka should release 419 TMC to TN. It only says that TN should get 419 TMC out of total of 740 TMC available in Cauvery. For TN to get 419 TMC, Karnataka needs to release only 192 TMC. TN gets rest of water from Cauvery water capturing area in TN itself. This is 13 TMC less than tribunals' interim award of 205 TMC.
Out of 192 TMC that TN gets from Karnataka, it has to release 30 TMC to Kerala and 7 TMC to Pondicherry.
So, unlike the media projects, verdict is not against Karnataka. It is more or less in line with interim verdict only.
Infact karnataka get more share than TN. Understand the reality..
RE:RE:cauvery tribunal water
by Balaji M on Feb 05, 2007 08:54 PM Permalink
yes this is fact but media is not giving actual picture to people, i don't understand media ppl hide and seek game. All, read the baove for actual and correct share of water b/w south indian States.
This verdict has actually decreased the amount Karnataka needs to share with Tamil Nadu (by way of interim order), hence Karnataka should be happy with the verdict. It is more or less preserving the status quo and looks like a fair judgement
RE:Victory for neither state
by on Feb 05, 2007 04:52 PM Permalink
Karnataka and Karnataka Economy depends on Others.. esp TN. Think before what you say.
RE:RE:Victory for neither state
by Balaji M on Feb 05, 2007 08:59 PM Permalink
hey who is this? what Tn is doing for KARNATAKA's economy? what are you saying? an new NEWS to Nation? Bangalore ahs its name in WORLD IT Industry and has its own share to Nation's economy by other sources AGriculture, irrigation, farm, Spices, Intelligent people, why you think this? correct yourself and if you have got this information form friends then inform them to discuss actual things not to just say words which are not going to count with other people!
RE:RE:RE:Victory for neither state
by suresh n on Feb 05, 2007 09:27 PM Permalink
Balaji, Bangalore is not just made by kanadigias.... its made up by Indians. Tamils, telgu's, north Indian's do have a great share for bangalore development. Take Care, nsuresh_rasr
I'm slightly disappointed with the verdict, I expected 50:50 for KA & TN. But I do belive that tribunal hv done fair study on the needs of both States., These numbers has got nothing to do with Rain gods, let us pray that we get sufficient rains every year..
If you were expecting a 50:50 verdict and now disappointed with the verdict - then it clearly shows that you haven't read the verdict properly. So request you to please go through the verdict in detail - so that you won't get disappointed unneccesarily. Cheers, Venkatesh.
Please note that verdict does not say that Karnataka should release 419 TMC to TN. It only says that TN should get 419 TMC out of total of 740 TMC available in Cauvery. For TN to get 419 TMC, Karnataka needs to release only 192 TMC. TN gets rest of water from Cauvery water capturing area in TN itself. This is 13 TMC less than tribunals' interim award of 205 TMC.
Out of 192 TMC that TN gets from Karnataka, it has to release 30 TMC to Kerala and 7 TMC to Pondicherry.
So, unlike the media projects, verdict is not against Karnataka. It is more or less in line with interim verdict only.
Infact karnataka get more share than TN. Understand the reality..
RE:Cauvery Tribuna's Verdict......First Check this out....
by Syed Meeran on Feb 05, 2007 04:51 PM Permalink
Good data. Rediff - Please carefully form the content titles. The title "Cauvery tribunal gives TN 419 tmcft, 270 to Karnataka" provokes unnecessary hatred among the people of tamilnadu and karnataka.
RE:RE:Cauvery Tribuna's Verdict......First Check this out....
by Thiagarajan Venkatesh on Feb 06, 2007 05:01 PM Permalink
Exactly - Media is just interested in sensation. Expect rediff to come with a detailed analysis and let the viewers know the facts.
Tamil Nadu has intelligently used its clout in politics and bureaucracy and has managed this award. There is no scientific logic or reasom in this decision at all. Our good old politicians have only been finding ways to outdo each other in local politics. Arise Kannadigas, you have tolerated enough until now. Let us not accept such step motherly treatment. We can share water when we have enough.
RE:Injustice to Karanataka - whom to blame.
by K Chandru on Feb 05, 2007 05:04 PM Permalink
Infact, Tamilnadu is the only state where are other language people live without any fear and speak their mother tongues freely without any hatred stares from others. I was in B'lore for three years and heard abuses like, "nodu! Katpadi badhidhaaney!" They call Tamils as `Katpadis'. There was a mass ire and beating up of Tamils during that time. Can anyone recall any such atrocities against linguistic minorities anywhere in Tamilnadu? I'm proud of my state where none feels left alone and everyone feels part of the main stream. I request people like Mr. Mohan to learn coexistence from Tamils and shed his partisan attitude forever!
RE:RE:Injustice to Karanataka - whom to blame.
by vivek jauhari on Feb 05, 2007 05:20 PM Permalink
But dear it is true too... have u see any tamilian who think they r indian. I saw lot of tamilian who alwayse said they r tamiliyan and never want to speek with any north indian guys. I feel bangalore is a safe place for all. Even if u speek about food in tamilnadu.. what we will get accept idly or sambhar.. if we get also it will not be eatable. at least bangalore is good in this point too. better u should think for contry not like non educated persons.
RE:RE:RE:Injustice to Karanataka - whom to blame.
by buska O on Feb 09, 2007 07:32 PM Permalink
comeon guy, dont tell something which is something unbelieavable , now also. "I saw lot of tamilian who alwayse said they r tamiliyan and never want to speek with any north indian guys. " good joke man
RE:RE:RE:Injustice to Karanataka - whom to blame.
by on Feb 05, 2007 06:55 PM Permalink
Hi Vivek, You may be right to certain extent abt Tamils not speaking with other states people. This is not totally the public fault. Since DMK came into picture, they corrupted the minds of us and stopped us from learning Hindi. In the name of protecting Tamil, they close down hindi school. this has happened from 50s to mid 90s. Only now, the youths realising the importance of learning national language etc after getting jobs in other placed. Also, non-tamil don't want to us bcos of language issues. If you don't know a language its very difficult to engage in a chit-chat and informal type conversation which is normally how friendship develops. So, we are getting isolated. Hopefully, in future, this will change. By the way, I'm both a tamilian and Kannadiga. My parents our last 3 or 4 generations are from TN eventhough we speak Kanada at home which is our mother tongue.
RE:RE:RE:Injustice to Karanataka - whom to blame.
by suresh n on Feb 05, 2007 09:32 PM Permalink
Dude, there are so many people thinking u the same way... Wht do u want us to do??? If INdia loses the match in chennai, then throw stones and stop the match??? Have u ever seen Kalam telling he is a Tamilian & not an India.... this is stupid man.... YES we dont speakl with north Indian's just bcos we dont share the same language. Can i blame North India for not speaking with Tamilians???
RE:Injustice to Karanataka - whom to blame.
by K Chandru on Feb 05, 2007 05:06 PM Permalink
Infact, Tamilnadu is the only state where are other language people live without any fear and speak their mother tongues freely without any hatred stares from others. I was in B'lore for three years and heard abuses like, "nodu! Katpadi badhidhaaney!" They call Tamils as `Katpadis'. There was a mass ire and beating up of Tamils during that time. Can anyone recall any such atrocities against linguistic minorities anywhere in Tamilnadu? I'm proud of my state where none feels left alone and everyone feels part of the main stream. I request people like Mr. Mohan to learn coexistence from Tamils and shed his partisan attitude forever!
RE:Injustice to Karanataka - whom to blame.
by jayaramaiah MV on Feb 05, 2007 06:00 PM Permalink
I fully endorse your views. We have all along been suffered in the hands of these politicians as our state has no much representation in power.
It is a great news but natural resource is the one which should not go through verdicts and disputes. It is natural so let us share it without any disputes... let us all be indians
