MAN the Marxists are like a disease, thy wont grow neither thy will let others grow, look at china, only the rich gettin richer n poor bein more poorer, shame on Marxists of India, as the author told, Marxists belive china is our country, same as muslims Paki is our country, doe not matter thy liv in india n eat india's food, best example kerla n calcutta, worst place, no growth from last 50yrs
I could not understand after reading your article that your main topic of discussion was 123 agreement or proving China as our enemy or proving CPI(M) as Chinese agents.
You are an esteemed and learned person who was with government of India.
So I request you to enlighten us by writing a little more detail about what is there in this 123 agreement. I think everybody who is voting for and against this agreement should know in the first place what it is. We are talking about the agreement, so the question of China and CPIM should not be mixed up. After all you know that neither China nor CPIM are communists. So once people of India knows the actual truth about this deal and have the right to decide then all agents or non-agents will fall in line of the people. So please enlighten about the deal.
If you are talking about China, then of course we have to keep in mind the history of 1962. But then history is a long chain of events. So please keep in mind the history of 5000 years also. Having done that then establish a full proof theory that Chinese are our sworn enemies, I shall be ready to accept. Then also if you ask me, it is not wise to stir up enemity within a nation or within an individual or within the hearts of enemy. Gandhiji has already proved that non-violence is the only way to win over enemies. We have driven away the mighty British empire. We can handle others also if somebody becomes our enemy. While you formulate your theory of China as enemy
RE:please give facts
by Swarup Choudhury on Aug 19, 2007 07:49 PM Permalink
ya u r right man, ghandhi, the most useless fella in world n history, the person who crippled india to this point, hv u ever heard, the value of blood, man no freedom is valued unless u shed blood to get it, look at america, japan, where thy r now, thy did not follow damn old ghandhi, thy fought n now thy value it
this matter is better to be given to professionals to sort out.Politicians on either side of the spectrum will give biased views.We in the bargain will loose the plus points gained by economic team lead by our P.M whose integrity is beyond dount and the team which has proved that they can deliver and take India to a desired destination.
RE:nuclear deal
by lakshmi narayan on Aug 19, 2007 08:02 PM Permalink
what ever may be the scenario, Communists don't have a good foreign policy nor the experience... they just know to call/lead bundh's and put the people of India into trouble. As history says, then didnot take part in freedom struggle which is an open truth. Anyway's communists are a pain for India growth.
They should have been banned forever. The INDIAN worker needs to enlighten himself that his interests are best preserved by parties such as BJP, SP and Congress. The INDIAN worker needs to re-dedicate himself to the NATIONAL COMMUNITY instead of the INTERNATIONAL PROLETARIAT. It is best for the INDIAN worker to distance himself from Communist parties. The non-communist parties in INDIA should do their best to earn the loyalties of the common INDIAN worker. Raising the minimum wage earned per hour by coolies will go a long way in doing this. You can also have subsidized vacation packages for Indian day labourers which are allocated once every in 5 years of work. This kind of incentive will promise the INDIAN worker that we are concerned about him and fervently care about his welfare. We as a people need to stop looking down upon manual labour as inferior. A National Labor Service which includes people from every section of the society should be instituted so that we can speed up the infra-structural revolution in our country. Every person signs up in the Labor Service for one year. In Israel they have this policy.
It is a shame that BJP is using this moment to pull down the strength of India. In this situation, they are a powerful Hanuman with fire on the tail - difference is that they are setting fire to Ayodhya and not Lanka. Pray to Ram for wisdom, and behave like a responsible Indian party; else history will remember you as a traitor. You owe it to Mera Bharat Mahaan that was proudly presented two years ago; if you have forgotten it, you will be crushed under the elephant.
RE:Playing with fire
by Swarup Choudhury on Aug 19, 2007 07:44 PM Permalink
MAN the Marxists are like a disease, thy wont grow neither thy will let others grow, look at china, only the rich gettin richer n poor bein more poorer, shame on Marxists of India, as the author told, Marxists belive china is our country, same as muslims Paki is our country, doe not matter thy liv in india n eat india's food, best example kerla n calcutta, worst place, no growth from last 50yrs.
RE:Playing with fire
by Hari on Aug 19, 2007 07:55 PM Permalink
I suspect the chinese must be funding the Communists in India, and getting there work done. Otherwise, getting visas for 1000 engineers is impossible.
Why am I not surprised? Has there been one single occasion, when communists did anything constructive? ...Neah, not really. The Big Daddy across the tibetan province really matters when communists in india make a choice between India and China. Except Bengal and a few pockets in south, left has always been a party, not in power. But most of there leaders are a little more affluent than average indian, the naxalites and workers of CPIM et al get the arms and ammunitaion of the latest type. Why have we never digged there. They support division of society in castes and dont agree that creamy layer should be out governmental priviledges. And now when, India has a chance to stand as a global power, Uncle Chang may not like it. What is important is they are willing to join hands with any political party just to stick to the power. In fact they should be left alone from indian politics, not as left parties in a democratic structure, what they dont believe in.
my fellow comrade karat great job!!! Capitalist pig give you bad Nuclear deal. we real india friends. We give you better deal.... Capitalist pig give you only nuclear fuel . We will give you nuclear bomb and teach how to explode in comrade lands like kolkutta.
When Smt. Vrinda Karat, Sri Somnath, Sri Prakash Karat, Sri Harkishen tells you that they are doing it for the good of Nation%u2026think again before believing them. WITH ALL ITS SHORTCOMINGS, THERE IS STILL NO ALTERNATIVE TO DEMOCRACY. West Bengal has gone into comatose during the last 28 years (as also Kerala & Tripura) rule of CPI(M), it has shown what a Communist outfit can do, even within a Democratic Environment. Pray that does not happen to our entire Nation
RE:WE CAN PRAY
by sanket on Aug 19, 2007 07:40 PM Permalink
communists are anti national elements present in our midset, whose only purpose is to see the indian ship sink and to see that china controls the world and india remains a third rate nation. terrorists use guns to do this, at the behest of pakistan and communists use the legitimate means of parliament and elections to do this, at the behest of china. communists are the largest single threat to india,even more than kashmir terrorists. These anti national elements like yechuri, raja and karat must be identified and thrown out of the political system. godforbid china conquers india, these people will celebrate.
RE:WE CAN PRAY
by roopesh raghavan on Aug 19, 2007 07:47 PM Permalink
Any parallel organization, miniscule it might be, can only run in West Bengal/Kerala, if it has authorization from CPI(M) Party. In this process Ramkrishna Mission Institute was also challenged by CPI(M) few years back, fearing their large following might become point of worry in future. They are under close watch at local levels. So are other religious and other outfits
RE:RE:WE CAN PRAY
by swan on Aug 19, 2007 07:57 PM Permalink
u r true ....such organizations can only run in west bengal & kerala. the reason is people here r cowards n on top very greedy(i mean majority). they dont have selfrespect n can stoop to ne level for money which is understood as these people had never seen money n luxries ....so now they r crawing for it at the cost of the nation.
RE:WE CAN PRAY
by swan on Aug 19, 2007 07:38 PM Permalink
is vrinda karat the same lady who had once put allegations on baba ramdev???? if sehz the same then i wonder how females like her get support from common people ??
RE:WE CAN PRAY
by roopesh raghavan on Aug 19, 2007 07:41 PM Permalink
Smt. Vrinda Karat%u2019s shouting against Swami Ramdev is only a replica of the West Bengal scenario. CPI(M) noticed that Swami Ramdev%u2019s influence was getting increased, everyday, even within some of their cadres, hence Swami Ramdev had to be challenged. Smt Karat is least bothered about doing good for Nation, by testing and standardizing ayurvedic medicines, that is only a frontal posture, her main interest is only to demean Swami Ramdev and such other organizations so that they are effectively neutralized and cannot influence large section of population. Smt. Karat is only doing what her Party has told her to initiate. THERE CANNOT BE ANY OTHER ORGANISATION HAVING MASS FOLLOWING. HENCE IDENTIFY AND DISMANTLE SUCH ORGANISATIONS.
RE:WE CAN PRAY
by swan on Aug 19, 2007 07:53 PM Permalink
she tried her best to demean Swami Ramdev but as always true came out stronger. this stupid lady even got some people to speak against swami ramdev but nothing worked n she had to hide her face . shez luks n behaves like a witch.
CPI(M) runs a Party System whose only work is individually identifying contrary thinking in every area and then isolating the person to terrorise every family member of the person, so that he or she never can stand up to ventilate his or her free opinion
