Re: Come Tata In BIHAR
by Kumar Sudhir on Sep 03, 2008 12:23 PM Permalink
Ofcourse it would be a better choice. And I think Mr. Nitish Kumar should also approach but not like what happend in Singur. Land should be provided to them but not cultivable land.
Re: Come Tata In BIHAR
by Bhupendra Singh on Sep 03, 2008 12:26 PM Permalink
Tata can make the factory in side the used mines so that no body is affected
Re: Come Tata In BIHAR
by saumil shukla on Sep 03, 2008 12:22 PM Permalink
i dont think they make cars underwater.... considering there r floods.. ha ha ha
Re: Come Tata In BIHAR
by ravindra kp on Sep 03, 2008 12:24 PM Permalink
Yes Tata should go to Bihsr River Kosi will give enough water and Laoo his henchmen, other Biharis their management skills in Kidnapping & Ransom extraction
Many of the firms like Burn Stnd., Britannia, Exide,etc were started by British as Calcutta was the Capital in those days. The generation changed particularly after partition and migration from East Pakistan. These people were always anticentre . Even the previous CM was from EB , the people who are controlling politics, a majority are from EB and they destroyed Bengal slowly and studily. They set up colonies all over India only to do this and now they will destroy the entire country as have captured the media also.
Left and Mamata are both sides of the coin. The present mamta's agitation has valid reason but these Lefts (specially CPM) are like Dog. Dog will not eat and let others to eat. That is their policy. Their laboratory is in Kerala & W/Bengal. They succefully experimented this theory to these states for the last 30 years. They always want supporters as un- educated/backward for their zindabad. So un necessary hue and cry for the Mamta's agitation is a time waste for all of us. This is a great lesson for Prakash and company
Re: Left & Mamata - both sides of the coin
by Bhupendra Singh on Sep 03, 2008 12:28 PM Permalink
Slap to CPI for their deeds when they shut hundreds of Factories in Mumbai
Re: Left & Mamata - both sides of the coin
by tanmay chattopadhyay on Sep 03, 2008 12:21 PM Permalink
CPM is for poor,. If poverty is not there then they are also not there. For their survival poverty needs to exist. If anybody opposes pl answer why the per capita income in CPM states less than Indian average.
Re: Left & Mamata - both sides of the coin
by Anil Tharikida on Sep 03, 2008 12:25 PM Permalink
That is not just for CPM. The entire Indian political system feeds on the poor and the illiterate.....So the parties have incetive to keep the public poor and uninformed...
Re: Left & Mamata - both sides of the coin
by sibby mathews on Sep 03, 2008 01:18 PM Permalink
That's a big surprise. Wonder why the CPM does not exist in states like Jharkhand, Orissa, Chattisgarh, Bihar, U.P, Rajasthan, etc. where rampant poverty is always the order of the day and Bengal would appear rich in comparison !!
Now, you sweet; from where did you get the tidbit that the per capita income in CPM states (Kerala and Bengal) is less than the Indian average ? Can you name the source you pretend to be quoting from ?
According to the CSO 2007-08 report, Kerala is ranked 7th in per capita income but 1st in mean consumption and 1st in human development. W.Bengal ranks 9th, 8th and 9th respectively.
Please answer why you sought to post a falsehood. Perhaps you expected no one to discover it ?
Re: Left & Mamata - both sides of the coin
by Praveen Menon on Sep 03, 2008 12:28 PM Permalink
There is mistake on yr statement, erala's per per capita income is on top list but that is not left's rule, it is becuase the money arriving form aborad
Re: Left & Mamata - both sides of the coin
by hello on Sep 03, 2008 12:34 PM Permalink
dear mr. praveen menon,
we should not blame left and mamta, actuall the bangli people of WB are supposed to be blamed, they have choosen these party and see what they are getting, the entire country is inviting Ratan TATA to establise factory in their state and these WB political parties, foolish, i dont know whether its true or not but i have heard that Dr. Rajender Prasad adviced and invited TATA (or some automobile) company to make factory in Bihar near his district (Jera Dai-Bihar) but the old people refused to give the land saying that what thier son, grand son will eat if they will not have land, now see do any one know where is Zera Dai (the home town of the first president of india). same mistake is repeated by these foolish bangali's, now i hope maharastra or orissa will get these project.
Trinamool Congress: Aggrassive agitation against the Tata plant. Tata: Forsed To shut Nano plant at Singur. resulting in Hudge losses to co & delay in product on which india made world surprised. Trinamool Congress: We have done nothing it is their own decision.
Such kind of politics in W.B. which is resulting bacwordnesss of the state. Once known for his industry. Now hadly any industry is left in the state. Most of them are closed or near to closer & after quit of TATA on one will come to W.B. for any industry.
Re: Tata shuts Nano plant at Singur
by springvale on Sep 03, 2008 12:29 PM Permalink
It's not difficult to make out. WB is heading straight towards bottom. If such leaders like Mamta doing "Tandava" on it's head, there is nowhere else to go anyway.
Re: kill mamata
by Anil Tharikida on Sep 03, 2008 12:17 PM Permalink
Watch out boy!!! If something happens to Mamta, your statement is in front of millions of people!!! Cops can get you easily!!
Re: kill mamata
by Guest on Sep 03, 2008 12:14 PM Permalink
Love u dear ........the best comment of the lot...............Gr8 Gr8........... go ahead........
Kerala's socio-economic conditions are conducive for TATAs factory.
The state had some problems in the past. The commies there are moving forward modeling CHINA. Any investment in any sector will be welcomed with open arms.
The company will benefit from cheap electricity, great infrastructure and the best SKILLED WORK FORCE in India.
Re: Political and communal stability in Kerala
by Praveen Menon on Sep 03, 2008 12:18 PM Permalink
You mistaken tharikida. Now they ruling Kerala so they need fund from ADB and Smart City. See they will change next turn is for UDF, then comment, ok
Re: Political and communal stability in Kerala
by Anil Tharikida on Sep 03, 2008 12:22 PM Permalink
UDF is in shambles. BJP is pure poison. Then who else is there except the commies? Granted they are bad? But what other choice?
Re: Political and communal stability in Kerala
by lungi on Sep 03, 2008 12:17 PM Permalink
I think the best solution would be to merge Kerala and West Bengal. Then the Tatas will virtuall not shift. Kaho Kya Kheyal Hai? U may contact Mamata in this regard because she is inviting all such suggestions.
Re: Political and communal stability in Kerala
by ravindra kp on Sep 03, 2008 12:16 PM Permalink
Tata's should not come to Kerala. They are once bitten twice shy with the commies
It is most unfortunate that there are people like Mamata and Karat who continue to play politics with the Nation's progress .We need leaders,politicians,actors ,scientists ,sportsmen,technocrats,workers in fact all of these to live together and work for the progress of the country .The farmers who are not satisfied with the compensation they got from Tatas can always demand and get some more for the land sold by them as land appreciates in a short time.A poor farmer sells his produce for paltry value to traders who make money and it is the urban population that consume these because they have the purchase power to buy them.By selling land which gives them nothing in return they are assured of a living for the rest of their lives.What the farmer must hold is fertile land ,cultivate them and spend money got from sale of land to industries in educating their children and also have less children .Instead what we see today is agitation by selfish politicians which will drive them to more impoverishment.
Media highlighted 90% of WB people were in support of Tata project. But what is the point of support by 90% of people? Why did they not stand up & throw mamata to dustbin? Why WB govt could not show the guts when it was needed most? I understand they were extra careful after nandigram experience, but for larger benifit you haver to act tough some times. So many so called intellectuals are talking about protecting farmers interest. The fact is always there will be blacksheeps. Even if govt would have offered few milions for per acre, there will be somebody, who will not be willing to sell his land, not because of money, just they do not want to step out of their comfort zones. In such cases, even 1 out of thousands can spoil any project.
Throghout the history, few people have been sacrificed for the bigger benifits of the society, that is not welcome, but inevitable. There should have been demand for alternate income for the displaced people, instead of that this shit lady mamata screwed up the whole project, killed both the farmers & enemployed youth all with one stroke. She is mindless, mad, hypocrtite, demagogue, may be devil personified, but why the govt was mute spectator? Why they did not come up with alternate proposal in time to tame the tide? A very costly, irreaparable damage has been done. Future gen will teach mamata her lesson in time, but the damage cant be undone, & all WB people are equally responsible for that, as they have allowed this mad dog to bark t
Re: Re: Damage can not be undone, opportunity lost for ever
by Bhupendra Singh on Sep 03, 2008 12:18 PM Permalink
hey idiot their is no benefit to the society in this project. and u are not the one displace from your own fertile land. The pain is same if u are removed from your own house to the streets. better talk sensible.
Tata is not here for any social service.They came here only for making suitable profit. They know West Bengal is very good place to set up a new Industry for making huge profit. This CPIM govt has been responsible for shut many industries since last 30 yrs. Now suddenly they are looking for industrilisation. Obvsly indeed this is a good approach, But wht will haapen to those closed jutemills and other industries which were in a very good location. Instead of giving them to promotars why not thay give them to set up industry?? It is not a question abt only 400 acres, But it should be at proper place like other Industries. This goverment handle it badly. ...........Please think twice the family those are lost thier land.
Re: We are most selfish educated person
by springvale on Sep 03, 2008 12:19 PM Permalink
now those families are more worried than everyone. At least there was opportunity for them to have a future for their future generations, mamta has thouroughly screwed it up for ever.
Re: We are most selfish educated person
by Bhupendra Singh on Sep 03, 2008 12:20 PM Permalink
CPI is being repaid in their own money.What CPI has done for decades they are getting the same.
in an era where the entire india is marching forward, bengal alone is left stagnated , and i will continue to be this way, i am a bengali by birth but i sincerely hope TATA move out of bengal if it really want to prosper..and also no other company should look towards kolkata.Kolkata is more of a holiday sopt with strikes every 2nd day...if one really wants to do something in life he has to move out of bengal.
