1)ANEEK has not used his mothertongue as RAJA does.Point is this is saregamapa in hindi.so even if aneek wants to speak in Bengali, most of viewers & judges would not understand.
2)English is so common today but RAJA has not capability even to do that simple work.
3)ANEEK said he is not conversant in hindi well.so he could not use the term"BAHEN".just imagine how much pressure & tension were there!!Remember he is now just 18 & RAJA is now 26.just no comparison about maturity level.ANEEK is so simple & innocuous.
RE:mothertongue
by Sudipto Chatterjee on Oct 07, 2007 01:44 AM Permalink
Raja had the guts to sing in bengali and you want to say that aneek lacks the guts to sing in his own mother tounge It is a fact that bengali has lots more of song in store than hindi if only you can sing that.We bengali just try to defend ourself even if we are wrong
RE:RE:mothertongue
by diya sen on Oct 07, 2007 01:49 AM Permalink
singers many times sings in different language,raja sang just 4 lines,so what revolution he did???? such a foolish comment.
RE:RE:mothertongue
by sov on Oct 07, 2007 03:05 PM Permalink
chikki,
aneek is a bengali in origin.i think everybody should accept he is far superior in bengali songs than anyone.bappida alsoknew that.so there is no need for him to reprove himself.Raja made a fine tactics to pull bengali attention towards him-self.Isn't it true?
RE:mothertongue
by Tehfeen P on Oct 07, 2007 02:15 AM Permalink
diya u sing 4 lines in hindi with out ur bengali assent then we will comment. let us see what revolution u do.
RE:mothertongue
by sov on Oct 07, 2007 01:56 AM Permalink
i didn't question anything about aneek's quality.he is the SAREGAMAPA(bengali) champ.See this is not a racial matter & it is also a debate who sings well,aneek or raja.but don't u think u r becoming tooooooo generous?also being a bengali ,aneek can sing soooooo beautiful hindi songs but i doubt how much raja can do well if he sings in bengali.u may be astonished
"ohhhhhhh he can even sing bengali!!!!how great!!!"but this is really ridiculous cerebration u know
RE:RE:mothertongue
by chiki on Oct 07, 2007 02:29 AM Permalink
MR.SO CALLED SOV.I THINK YOU SHOULD GET YOUR EARS CHEKED.DID'NT YOU HEAR THE WAY "RAJA" SANG THE SONG...."IT WAS FABULOUS".I HAVE A BIG???? MARK ABOUT THATOINK SINGING.YOU KNOW WHAT ANEEK'S SONGS MAY BE BEAUTIFUL FOR YOU PROBABLY COZ HE IS A BENGALI BUT HIS IMMATURE VOICE PINCHES ME...TELL ME FRANKLY DO YOU THINK THAT HIS VOICE IS MACHO AND SUIT'S TODAYS MEN NOT ATALL.HE IS NOT EVEN 1% OF WHAT SONU NIGAM IS.USKO SONU NIGAM KE SATH COMPARE KARKE LOG SONU KI BEIZZATI KARTE HAIN.SORRY SACH HAMESHA KADVA HOTA HAI
RE:mothertongue
by sov on Oct 07, 2007 02:56 PM Permalink
hii mr so called chikki,
I think u r claiming ur-self a magical gift of music,God provided to our world.so i suppose u should go music industry very soon instead of shouting for contestants.ohhhh yes,another word,
have u any ENT specialist nearby?i m getting worried about u.
RE:mothertongue
by Ramesh Dubey on Oct 07, 2007 12:36 PM Permalink
MR.SO CALLED CHIKKI - YOU GOT BE A GREAT MUSICIAN YOURSELF TO DETERMINE THE IMMATURITY IN ANEEK'S VOICE ! DO YOU HAVE ANY SONGS RECORDED - I'LL BUY IT - PLEASE LET ME KNOW - BECAUSE A TALENTED COMPOSER LIKE ISMAIL JEE CALLED HIM - "ALFATOON CHEEZ" - MAYBE I CAN LEARN SOMETHING FROM YOUR WORK
RE:mothertongue
by on Oct 07, 2007 02:46 AM Permalink
Raja did not sing the Bengali song as a normal part of proggramme,he just sang four lines of it to please Bappa Lahiri and at the same time the Bengali viewers. You as a Bengali viewer is so pleased to listen the lines as he is a non-Bengali singer , did Aneek do it as a Bengali singer you will never be joyous as you are in case of Raja,morever, yes, Raja is 26 and and Aneek is 18 and Raja did everything cleverly,yes, Raja and his team took it as an at the least general election, and his team captured the audience of the shooting ,messege-board with real face and in disguise used regionilism and even communalism at ease.Raja's fan fowllowers even did doubt of secular and anti-provincialism feeling of Bengal.But throughout the board I found hundreds of Ghosh,Bose,Guha or Mitra's i.e, Bengalees crying for Raja and you yourself is one of the proof of that.
RE:RE:mothertongue
by chiki on Oct 07, 2007 03:28 AM Permalink
i am not a bengali by origin nor am i a rajasthani.so communalism ,regionalism is out of ?. u've made ur message sound like a lecture on history.
if u see bengalis crying for raja(to vote 4 him) ..take some inspiration and do the same
I am a punjabi ,and i adore raja.is there a problem.
next time u write a blob please be clear.confuse karke rakh diya hai.itni khichri paka di hai politics ki ke indigestion ho gayi
RE:mothertongue
by chiki on Oct 07, 2007 03:16 AM Permalink
diya sen...do u have any other vocabulary in ur stock or these are the onle 3 words u know to use.
RE:RE:mothertongue
by Ramesh Dubey on Oct 07, 2007 12:41 PM Permalink
YOUR PENMANSHIP IS NOT THAT OF SUPERB ELOQUENCE EITHER - SHOW ME SOME REAL ENGLISH - SO FAR YOUR WRITING HAS REVEALED UTMOST MEDIOCRACY
RE:mothertongue
by tanuka banerjee on Oct 07, 2007 02:31 PM Permalink
chiki...u vote for him...n if campaigning is the task raja has bestowed on u then u will be highly unsuccessful here...coz if u can read this is aneek's profile...v dont want it virus infested.
