Robin Uthappa-1/10 -was hyped as a replacement for Sehwag. proved it by getting out like him. didnt do anything of note even against minnows Saurav Ganguly-5/10-played well but not upto his potential. failed in crunch game Virender Sehwag-4/10-Started to look like he was coming to form till stupidly gave his wicket in crunch situation as usual Sachin Tendulkar-0/10-failed miserably against banglas and Sri Lanka, Innings against bermuda doesnt count if we consider him a great batsmen Rahul Dravid-5/10- played well in crunch game but was poor in 1st match, not an inspiring captain must have felt frustrated at failures of top batsmen Yuvraj Singh-4/10-played well in 2 matches but out at crucial times in 1st and last match. should learn to carry the innings with more responsibility Dhoni-0/10-Failed miserably against all, though everyone thought the boundaries will be to his liking Agarkar-3/10-why is he in the team when Pathan can bat better and can bowl well if he bowls within himself Harbhajan Singh-3/10-in the team to take wickets and tie up one end neither of which he could achieve Zaheer Khan-5/10-bowled well in patches but what happened to his batting. was known to be able to hit the ball a long way and defend for hours to give support to other batsmen Munaf Patel-5/10-bowled well in patches but not at his fastest Kumble-5/10-difficult to say anything based on performance against bermuda as even our batsmen were made to look world class against them when in reality they were not upto scratch Greg Chappell-0/10-couldnt motivate the team, why did he insist on playing tendulkar down the order when he plays best as opener.took Indian team from bad to worse, couldnt come up with any ideas regarding team composition and strategy .failed as a coach as compared to tom mody who had similar resources as chappel. seems to have demotivated the players rather than motivate them
RE:Player rating for Team India
by Meghadoot Chaudhuri on Apr 08, 2007 09:56 PM Permalink
YOUR UN-BIASED WAY OF ANALYSING REALLY DESERVE RESPECT. IT SHOULD ATTRACT SUPPORTERS OF ANY LOBBY EXCEPT THE EXTREMELY BIASED ONE. EVEN I MIGHT DIFFER WITH YOU IN SOME INSTANCES; STILL I SUPPORT AND HAIL YOUR UN-BIASED ATTITUDE.
