Rediff.com |  Feedback  
You are here: » Rediff Home » Discussion Boards » Permalink
  
View : Single Message | Complete Thread | Read complete Discussion
Cause of disaster
by Anurag on Apr 10, 2007 09:58 AM   Permalink | Hide replies

Responsibility of WC,07 disaster are as follows:

60 percent--Coach Chappel
30 percent--Captain Dravid
10 percent-- BCCI


    Forward  |  Report abuse
  RE:RE:Cause of disaster
by Siva Kumar on Apr 10, 2007 11:32 AM   Permalink
Not even 1% India losed because of Team Performance ?? Strange anaylsis - You mean to say that all players gave 100% effort??

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Cause of disaster
by Rajesh Singhania on Apr 10, 2007 10:04 AM   Permalink
In a Similar fashion,
Debacle of WC-2011 will be as :
100 percent - BCCI

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Cause of disaster
by ganesh v on Apr 10, 2007 10:09 AM   Permalink
responsibility share for WC disaster.
10% chappell
40% Dravid
40% other players
10% BCCI and selectors

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:[object]
by Suman Bhat on Apr 10, 2007 10:50 AM   Permalink
Beleaguered Indian captain Rahul Dravid is under pressure from the senior players who are operating like a %u2018mafia%u2019, according to a private TV channel.

Quoting unnamed sources, the TV channel said the senior players in the team were operating like a %u2018mafia%u2019 and coach Greg Chappell had expressed his anger with the player's %u2018mafia%u2019.

The sources were quoted as saying that the senior players "hammer and abuse" juniors and don't give them a "chance".

They said that Chappell was not averse to staying on as the coach provided the same sets of players were not retained.

The growing rift between some players in the team has been widely reported in a section of the media in the recent past. After India's disastrous first round exit from the World Cup last month, there have been several reports of the players being divided into camps and not acting like a team. Quic
k decisions are needed since India are due to visit Bangladesh in May for two Tests and three one-dayers, a tour that has assumed greater significance since Bangladesh's stunning win over the Indians at the World Cup.
A recent CNN-IBN television poll of 60 former and current first-class cricketers showed that a majority wanted Chappell and Dravid to continue, but hoped Tendulkar will quit one-day cricket to concentrate on Tests.
Chappell secured 48 percent of the votes, followed by former India star Mohinder Amarnath with 30 percent. Renowned Australian coaches John Buchanan and Dav Whatmore managed just two percent votes each.
Dravid was favoured as captain by 86 percent of the cricketers, but 56 percent of those polled wanted Tendulkar to play only Test cricket, while 33 percent felt he should quit the game altogether.
Meanwhile, officials will continue to milk the cash cow, irrespective of the team's performance.
India are scheduled to play 15 Tests and a minimum of 40 one-dayers at home and abroad over the next 12 months, besides the inaugural Twenty20 World Cup in South Africa in September


   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Cause of disaster
by us on Apr 10, 2007 10:16 AM   Permalink

blame should not go to selectors.
coach and captain got their team.
coach did not get team because of his captain and vice versa.

So responsibility
99% (chappell & dravid). Last two years they were doing nonsense experiemnts.
1% BCCI.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Cause of disaster
by Suman Bhat on Apr 10, 2007 11:25 AM   Permalink
batsman failed to deliver when team required in crucial matches....
With Greg Chappell resigning as India coach, it is interesting to take a look at the senior players? and India?s performance in international cricket under the Australian since his appointment in March 2005. The full details are :
Batsmen       Category       Matches       Runs       Highest       Avg       100
Virender Sehwag      Test cricket       17      993      256 &nb sp;    36.78      2
      ODI cricket       54      1518      114 &n bsp;    29.77      1
Sourav Ganguly       Test cricket       9      486      101 &nbs p;    40.50      1
      ODI cricket       18      665      98 &nbs p;    44.33      0
Rahul Dravid       Test cricket       17      1455      146 &n bsp;    58.20      3
      ODI cricket       58      1945      105 &n bsp;    41.38      2
Sachin Tendulkar       Test cricket       12      534      109 &nb sp;    29.66      1
      ODI cricket       36      1205      141* & nbsp;    40.16      3
V.V.S.Laxman       Test cricket       16      917      140 &nb sp;    39.86      3
      ODI cricket       3      29      22       9.66      0
Yuvraj Singh       Test cricket       13      528      122 &nb sp;    31.05      1
      ODI cricket       49      1852      120 &n bsp;    51.44      5

Note : Matches played by Sehwag and Darvid during the Super Series in Australia are not considered here


   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Cause of disaster
by Ravi chandran on Apr 10, 2007 10:45 AM   Permalink
100% - faith by fools llke us

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Cause of disaster
by us on Apr 10, 2007 10:01 AM   Permalink

very true.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Cause of disaster
by Suman Bhat on Apr 10, 2007 10:48 AM   Permalink
team india was broken ship when dravid made captain and ranked No8 in ICC ranking ( even now it is ranked No6)This WC team India %u2018s early exit, b%u2019cuz some players delieberatley palyed negative cricket and betryed team and dtiched dravid.ateam. If players are not ready to support team cause what capatain.some players fielding and body language was visible that as if they were playing an practice match and gifted match to Bangladesh an early exit from WC means dravid is not good captian and ganguly%u2019s records not harmed
When players only go against captain and coach and betray teammates why blame captain or coach??If player can not perform for team what is his role ? He should be kicked out team
IF players can get negative inspiration why could not players did not perform for team??how can cricket expert say that captain is not motivating player?/ WC is the biggest event of cricket and those players who get chance to play this on behalf of team India?chappel tried to push the palyers comofrt zone and bring professionalism. Many players do not like
this Dravdi was the guy showing the fight against SL...but who supported him? Dravid accepted the responsiblity for defeat in front of media he will resign Sewag selection was questioned by Chief slesctor HE IS HIGHESTRUN GETTER Dhoni, harbajan, sachin, completly failed the worst thing there is groupism and politcs in team and it was visible dufing match against SL and Bangaldesh ganguly is selfish politician He and his group deliberately played negative cricket , played big role in defeat and took revenge for his outset. he is cunning politicain not a team man main culprit to sabotage team WC capaign. He betrayed dravid. when he was captain it was dravid performance, hardwork brought him succes as captain. In WX2003 india reached final b`uz of sachins brillinet performance. not b`zu of ganguly`s captiancy or agression. it is ganguly, zahirkahn, dhoni, harbajan should be kicked out


   Forward   |   Report abuse
The above message is part of the Discussion Board:
'Dravid has proved his ability'