RE:DONT COMMUNALISE THE ISSUE
by Anand Vajapeyam on Jul 02, 2008 01:30 PM Permalink
ARE USMAN BHAI, IF KASHMIR IS NOT A PART OF INDIA, THEN IS IT A PART OF PAKISTAN? OR IS IT A PART OF BANGLADESH? WHAT DO YOU MEAN BY MUSLIM LAND? ALL MUSLIMS LIVING IN INDIA, PAKISTAN AND BANGLADESH ARE ONLY CONVERTS. WHAT ABOUT HUNDREDS OF MOSQUES/DARGAS WHICH ARE BEING BUILT ON LANDS GIVEN BY THE GOVT IN OTHER PARTS OF INDIA? HAS ANY BODY RAISED PROTEST OVER THIS? JANAB USMAN, THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS HINDU LAND, MUSLIM LAND OR CHRISTIAN LAND IN INDIA. IT IS THE LAND OF INDIA/HINDUSTAN/BHARATH. THATS ALL. TODAY YOU MIGHT FEEL HAPPY ABOUT REVOKING OF THE J&K GOVT ORDER. BUT DO REMEMBER THIS IS ONLY A PYRRIC VICTORY. THE CONSEQUENCES OF THIS REVOKING WILL BE BEYOND IMAGINATION. IF ONLY WE HAD SOME ONE LIKE LATE SARDAR PATEL AMONGST US TODAY, WE WOULD NOT BE HAVING SUCH ISSUES AT ALL.
RE:DONT COMMUNALISE THE ISSUE
by Anand Vajapeyam on Jul 02, 2008 01:55 PM Permalink
USMAN, YOU ARE CONTRADICTING YOURSELF. ON ONE HAND YOU HARP ON J&K IS MUSLIM LAND. ON THE OTHER HAND, YOU CLAIM THAT THE SAME LAND BELONGS TO KASHMIRIS. SO APPLYING YOUR OWN FORMULA AND ARGUMENTS, ARE YOU NOT AGREEING TO THE SUGGESTION THAT LAND IN INDIA BELONGS TO INDIANS ONLY. ALSO SUDDENLY YOU BRING IN BJP/PUNJABIS INTO YOUR ARGUMENTS. JUST BECAUSE BJP IS SPEARHEADING THE PROTESTS? THE YATRIS WHO FLOCK TO AMARNATH ARE NOT ONLY PUNJABIS BUT ALSO FROM OTHER PARTS OF INDIA TOO. BE CLEAR IN YOUR THOUGHTS AND ACTIONS. I KNOW IT IS DIFFICULT FOR A PERSON LIKE YOU, WHO HAS BEEN BRAINWASHED INTO BELIEVING THAT MUSLIMS IN INDIA ARE BEING ILL TREATED. ALSO WHY ARE YOU SO SILENT ABOUT VARIOUS MOSQUES AND DARGAS THAT ARE EXISTING/COMING UP IN OTHER PARTS OF INDIA? IS IT GUILTY CONSCIOUSNESS OR IS IT SELECIVE AMNESIA?
