Ghanashyam Shah has analysed the situation perfectly. But he has missed one vital point. The crime has been executed meticulously. But hte perpetrator has not left one single clue. In the last couple of years the perpetrators of such heinous crime have eluded arrest. That means they are highly educated and trained having inside information of intelligence network. They know how to hoodwink the inteligence machinery.
Cannot they be non muslims and trying to create a situation where a particular political party would get milage in the elections? The email which came to warn of this event came from a house belonging to one Abhishek Sharma in Mumbai, who has rented it out to one Ameriacan citizen. Now nobody is discussing this on TV channels. Had the house owner been a muslim all the TV channels must have been discussing about it and would have linked it to some so called Jihadi org.
After the blast one live TV show anchor while talking to fromer DG of CBI Joginder Singh told that some of India's premier intelligence agencies's files where the officer has filed a report directly picking it up from a news paper. If the reporting and complacency of our agencies are such then why blame others and make peace loving Hindus and Muslims distrust each other? First set the house of intelligence agencies right and automatically real culprits can be caught and finally Indians can take a sig of relief.
RE:Revamp the intelligence structure
by P Raghavan on Jul 28, 2008 01:26 PM Permalink
Sure non Muslims are the problems everywhere else. 9/11, British train bombings, Madrid bombings.
RE:Revamp the intelligence structure
by Raj on Jul 28, 2008 01:26 PM Permalink
We know all muslims are not terrorists but every terrorists are all muslims. Am i right ?
RE:Revamp the intelligence structure
by Muhammed Rashid on Jul 28, 2008 01:33 PM Permalink
I have talked about intelligence failure and possible nexus between some rouge intelligence agency guy and the terrorists. Unfortunately someof our intelligence officers are saleble. Dont you have heard about non muslim people selling secrets to pakistan?
RE:Revamp the intelligence structure
by Muhammed Rashid on Jul 28, 2008 01:49 PM Permalink
What about post Godhra riots? Take post Babri Mumbai riots, who lost more lives. You cannot say that non muslims are not cruel. If so then who burned alive Graham Steins and his children? Who are the ones who burn their daughter in laws who do not bring dowries?
My dear Amit I am not talking about all non muslims but fringe elements who may be are out to create distrust and enmity towards the muslims.
RE:Revamp the intelligence structure
by Sevenrishi on Jul 28, 2008 03:39 PM Permalink
Ya i get a right person now. Ya Muhammed Rashid can you please tell me that why before such kind of terrorist activity and after also the terrorist told that ,what ever they did is correct and according to their holy book "Quran" there it is witten that "those who doesnot obey Islam, they have to die", they also decleare "jehad" i.e "a Holy war in the name of Allah"... Being a hindu i also study a little bit Koran and i also find the meaning of "jehad" as same...Does Allah is so cruel that he issue such kind saying in "koran".Why i am telling is that because after such terror strike mostly all the Muslims whole over the world are celebrating and saying "Allah has punish those 'kafer'and will provide 'jannat' to the terrorist" is it true. You will see after twin tower blast all the muslims whole over the world did like this specially in Iraq and Afganisthan. And taking ur point is u want to go to past it the muslims who invaded india and started such kind of hollocast changing of religion by pressure destruction of thousands of Hindu temples.The Mughols then Nadir shah, Chengiz Khan and so on...
RE:Revamp the intelligence structure
by Muhammed Rashid on Jul 28, 2008 05:05 PM Permalink
Quran is available in english translation. Please buy one copy and read from beginning to end. See what actually is writtten there. Half baked knowledge and heresay leads to nothing. After that you can comment.
RE:RE:Revamp the intelligence structure
by Demo-crazy on Jul 28, 2008 02:37 PM Permalink
Why the post-godhra had to happen? Why the godhra train carnage happened? you have answer in your questions.
RE:Revamp the intelligence structure
by Muhammed Rashid on Jul 28, 2008 02:45 PM Permalink
Do you know that the returning Kar Sevaks abused the daughter of a muslim vendor on the platform. This caused the mayhem. Kar Sevaks are supposed to be the people of God. Why did they do it in the first place?
RE:Revamp the intelligence structure
by Demo-crazy on Jul 28, 2008 02:34 PM Permalink
Some sense, some nonsense! The email part is still being investigated. The American person who was living there says his IP was hijacked by some hacker. This makes it complex. The house owner may not have anything to do with it, but that will be known after investigations.
If the politicians use IB to keep a tab on opposition, we have to see them file such newspaper report as intelligence. You subtly blame BJP for these blasts - that is nonsense argument!
RE:Revamp the intelligence structure
by arvi on Jul 28, 2008 01:28 PM Permalink
Would love to see such sensible things more n more in all sections...Alas..very few fall in this:(!!
