Rediff.com |  Feedback  
You are here: » Rediff Home » Discussion Boards » Permalink
  
View : Single Message | Complete Thread | Read complete Discussion
Trust Vote and CPM
by Vishwanath Nair on Jul 22, 2008 10:04 PM   Permalink | Hide replies

The result is very much convincing for the entire India except the people who support the CPM and the follower-less CPI. If Mr.Singh lost the trust vote, then Mr.Prakash Karat will become king and he will dictate their own PM designate Mayawati to implement the Marxist Agenda, which is very dangerous to India. Mr.Karat wanted India to become as like Kerala and Bengal, where there is no industry, no job, no earning and If the agenda implemented, then india will become a consumer country as Kerala and Bengal. Therefore, the winning of trust vote by the UPA is good.
From the BJP point of view, they were not at all interested in bringing down the government. They voted against the government for the sake of sitting in the opposition. They wanted the Government should continue their 5 year term. Everybody knows that Mr.Advani is not interested for 100 day PM.
Now, if Congress wanted to sustain, they should replace Mr.Singh with Mr.Rahul Gandhi, both are same, both came four years ago in politics.
Best wishes for the congress.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
  RE:Trust Vote and CPM
by sarnab poddar on Jul 22, 2008 10:06 PM   Permalink
Hi all,

I know there will be slanging and cursing against the communists, mainly because REDIFF or any site on internet is mainly crowded with the capitalists who would prefer to buy thier wife a 250 crore aircraft than trying to look into the problems of our country, the people who would prefer to buy out india for 3 crore each than making it a perfect democracy,
Today I am down and out by even thinking that my country doesnt have a voice of its own, people fight among themselves just as they did before East India Company came to India and took control of us, Common my fellow citizens dont go by the general feeling, start thinking deeply, I am not against the Nuclear energy being used , but cant US help Indian companies producing on thier own if they had to help, Is it mandatory for US companies like GE entering Indian lifeline (energy) and taking control of each and evry thing in India?, along with US visiting each and every nuclear reactors to cross check India isnt making nuclear weapons? Common people may be you are not supporting communists or any party but cant yu even think by yourselves what is happening and what might happen.

Regards,
Your brother,
Sarnab


   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Trust Vote and CPM
by nisha on Jul 22, 2008 10:15 PM   Permalink
Are bangla bhaia sarnab.Your understanding is short sighted.where do you stay in kolkata?.Then step outside into tamilnadu,gujrat,karnataka and you will know what is development! what tv you paln to buy..bpl or lg/samsung/sony?. Open your doors and learn from them grow and then if possible make a bigger company.
would have bajaj or TVS grown without learning tricks from kawasaki or suzuk.Besides when one foreigner comes to our house you can also take some positives from him..dress like him tidy like him, quality like his, vision like his..etc etc.

See the aborigines in africa and andaman will never grow orchange until they open their doors to the outside world.
Your fear is like that of those tribes men.
hope you are enlighteened.
thank You!


   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Trust Vote and CPM
by tar sha on Jul 22, 2008 10:17 PM   Permalink
sarnab,,

at least who buy 250 crore aircraft work hard and use their brain..they also treat their employees well..on other hand, communists will distribute that person's hard earned money equally to each and every lazy fellow who does not want to work hard and use his brain...

why dont you understand? western europe has much better socialism (in terms of healthcare, retirement benefits) then say communists's masters (china or russia)..but western europe still encourages trade and economic growth (but uses high taxes for its social purposes)..india has suffered a lot due to this mentality of communisim in the past where no one is rewarded for working hard and intelligently...

tell me , why no good individual migrates to china/russia? is there any answer with you or your communist politicians? on the contrary, how many commies' sons and daughters are in US and enjoying first world lifestyle?

why karat can get education in UK but he wants to screw up ordinary citizens who dream the same for their children?


   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Trust Vote and CPM
by rajuuu on Jul 22, 2008 10:09 PM   Permalink
I would have supported Communists if they had taken the cabinet.....it s easy to criticize anyoone on their work my friend rather than trying to do the same

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Trust Vote and CPM
by Sameer Bhagwat on Jul 22, 2008 10:14 PM   Permalink
Dude you did not read the deal.There is a clear separation bewteen India using nuclear for armoury and for power.Both will run as independent arms. So what is the problem?

You are bevahing just as some in the US first did when outsourcing started? How come you are ok with India working on the US Financial and Technology companies?


   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Trust Vote and CPM
by Roshan Jindal on Jul 22, 2008 10:15 PM   Permalink
You r right Mr. Poddar but we Indians are incapable to invent and doing research due to redtapeism and reservation.Also communist wanted to bring energy security through pakistan with the help of china ... and we all now that they r our enemy no. 1. Moreever this deal will be done either this time or few year after. BJP wants credit only and it wana deal too. I am too ashamed to be Indian that we have communist, bjp and congress who can't see national interest. It would have been nice if the nuclear deal passed by the parliament through absolute 100 % vote in favour....but also we have chinese and pakistani here..... How about L.K.Jinnah and Karat jeng lol.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
  RE:Trust Vote and CPM
by raheem vaheed on Jul 22, 2008 10:28 PM   Permalink
Vishy Nair,

I'm no friend of the commies, but i know they don't have to worry. Come election day, and the ones who line up at the polling booths will be those daily wage earners, factory workers etc....the vote bank of Commies. To them, Deal or No Deal, it doesn't matter. What matters is whether they can see a better life before they die. Sadly, this deal hardly ensures that, despite all the hype.

Remember that Vajpayee lost the election in 2004, not because he did nothing.....but because his supporters among the educated middle class did nothing on election day.....The middle class voters enjoyed in the following ways:

1. Using the cheaper airline tickets, courtesy his policy to encourage domestic travel.
2. SMSing or talking to loved ones on Mobile phones, courtesy his timely and creative Telecom policy
3. Going on long rides by own cars, courtesy of his Golden Quadrilateral Project that improved road network and the thrust given to automobile sector.
4. Enjoying a movie sitting in the cozy comforts of their own home, thanks to his govt's policy of giving tax discounts on home loans......

There are many more.....And, not for nothing is Mr.Vajpayee called the Bhishma Pitamaha of Indian Politics....he has seen all, done all....and yet remains a highly respected leader in India. MMS will do well to take some guidance from him.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
The above message is part of the Discussion Board:
Sad day for democracy, says CPI(M)