Muslims keep talking of anti- USA stance and are supposedly anti to anything/ anybody that hurts Muslims anywhere in the world. I would like to ask all muslims on this forum: "WHOSE SIDE WUD INDIAN MUSLIMS TAKE IF THERE'S A WAR BETWEEN INDIA & A MUSLIM COUNTRY???? Going by that logic they wud side the Muslim country as they believe, worldwide all muslims must stand united, throwing national interest to winds.
RE:IS THE MUSLIM INTEREST DIFFERENT FROM THE NATIONAL INTEREST
by Saif Nawaz on Jul 21, 2008 11:41 AM Permalink
Say If there is a war between India and Pak or Bang...then its duty of Muslim is to fight for nation...For Eg; If a Muslims home (A) is attached by another Muslim (B)...Then Muslim (A) will fight not get out of his home...India is our home and we will fight to save it..Hope this answer your question...I love my Nation India and Proud of it...
RE:RE:IS THE MUSLIM INTEREST DIFFERENT FROM THE NATIONAL INTEREST
by vspi on Jul 21, 2008 12:07 PM Permalink
So you must take the nuclear deal as a grand benefit to our developing nation which has to pay huge forex reserves to gulf nations for their oil. Why are you opposing it if the nuclear deal comes from the Americans? Doesn't 90% of the Islamic world depend on the Americans for technology, arms support etc. Even the Saudi Arabia (which houses the twin mosques) also has 90% of the Army manned by Americans. Pakistan, Bangladesh, Malayasia (largest muslim population) all live on American technology and are consdered American a$$ lickers. Why is the Al queda fighting American and the wester world using the wester technology (guns, missiles, RDX, tanks etc.) they must stick to their islamic tradition nd fight with swords & daggers as it used to happen during your prophet's days?
RE:IS THE MUSLIM INTEREST DIFFERENT FROM THE NATIONAL INTEREST
by A J Y on Jul 21, 2008 12:35 PM Permalink
Dear Nawaz, Your answer is the correct answer. Unfortunately not all your muslim brothers think like you. A small percentage of muslims even refuse to sing the Indian national anthem coz they say its Anti-Islam. If you are an Indian and do not sing the National Anthem, then it will cause pain & distrust for sure. As I said earlier not all muslims refuse to sing the national anthem .... maybe just 1% of muslims feel so radically .... 99% muslims respect & believe in the National Anthem ..... yet when this 1% of muslims refuse to sing the national anthem ..... the other 99% mulsims remain much too silent on the stupid activities of just 1% muslims. If the main stream muslims start speaking out against the 1% radical muslims, then RSS & Bajrang Dal will automatically have no issue to raise against the muslim community.
RE:IS THE MUSLIM INTEREST DIFFERENT FROM THE NATIONAL INTEREST
by Sun on Jul 21, 2008 11:50 AM Permalink
Thanks a lot Saif. But what about Kashmir. Do you approve of what is happening there.
RE:IS THE MUSLIM INTEREST DIFFERENT FROM THE NATIONAL INTEREST
by Ravin Jadhav on Jul 22, 2008 03:53 PM Permalink
Well said Saif, i'm proud of people like you true Indian, Jai Hind!!!
RE:IS THE MUSLIM INTEREST DIFFERENT FROM THE NATIONAL INTEREST
by Rash on Jul 21, 2008 11:45 AM Permalink
vspi
If our country is unjustly attacked we have a duty to defend it irrespective of religious group. But at no time our religion allows wars of aggression.
RE:IS THE MUSLIM INTEREST DIFFERENT FROM THE NATIONAL INTEREST
by ransaran on Jul 21, 2008 11:38 AM Permalink
HOW MUCH U HAVE BEEN OFFERED TO WRITE THIS BLOG
RE:IS THE MUSLIM INTEREST DIFFERENT FROM THE NATIONAL INTEREST
by vspi on Jul 21, 2008 11:59 AM Permalink
You moron, Nobody has to pay us anything, we dont stand in queue asking govt for subsidies, reservations, rights etc. WE ARE THE ONES WHO PROVIDE THRU OUR HARD EARNED TAXES TO FUND YOUR HAJ YATRAS AND MADRASSAS WHICH BREED ANTI- INDIA ELEMENTS.
