Siks need to be unified to fight against such culprits. I am shocked that sikhs are being killed in a state where sikhs are a majority.Govt is saving this rapist/killer for few votes, sikhs needs to get together to uproot such evil who is hiding behind walls under govt protection and raping/killing innocents
RE:Sikhs need to unite
by Guest on Jul 19, 2008 08:26 AM Permalink
He is born into a sikh jat family. There are many sikhs in the Dera. Mostly they are of the lower classes, and that is the core issue here. It is widely believed that these lower classes supported the congress against the SAD in the elections.
RE:Sikhs need to unite
by IMPARTIAL on Jul 19, 2008 02:20 PM Permalink
Guest, Your comments are justifying the mushrooming of religions and religious sects.
Who were the sikhs of gurus ? Strong majority of them were lower caste and working class hindus including Panch Piaras of tenth guru and Bala and Mardana of first guru.
Who are majority of chri.... in India and why ????
If the people are looked at as "lower caste" and "upper caste" in any religion, sect or organisation then divide is imminent whereby these sect leaders keep running their "shops".
RE:Sikhs need to unite
by speculator on Jul 19, 2008 11:34 AM Permalink
Rajvinder I say u take care of those cowardly Hindus in your community.They are causing all ur problems.Punjab Sikhs are great but Punjabi Hindus are super cowards who hide behind them.
RE:Sikhs need to unite
by congo on Jul 20, 2008 01:39 PM Permalink
Stop bragging about bravery of Sikhs. In Mumbai-'phut gai thi sikhon ki' when Shiv Sena objected to the Sikhs' Hooliganism after that episode with Dera Baba GRRS. In Mumbai, so called Sikh leaders did not delay a day before they apologised on TV media.
IN PUNJAB YOU CLAIM BRAVERY BECAUSE YOU ARE MAJORITY . AND BLAME HINDUS SUPER COWARDS, BECAUSE THEY ARE IN MINORITY.
This shows that definition of Bravery of Sikhs varies with their strength.
RE:Sikhs need to unite
by R A on Jul 19, 2008 11:40 AM Permalink
Speculator, even if you try to misguide any community, it doesn't change the very facts and can't resolve the problem. The need of time is to let them evaluate the problem and brainstorm the reasons behind the problem. I can't understand Punjabi Hindus or this hindus or that hindus.....Hindus are Hindus....
RE:Sikhs need to unite
by IMPARTIAL on Jul 19, 2008 09:48 PM Permalink
Ravinder, Being majority or minority does not make any difference nor sense.
Does your post mean that it is legitimate to kill a minority community.
If not you, your family and some intellectual sikhs, all the remainig people of your community have watched,enjoyed,legitimised and supported the killing of hindus in punjab.
I was very much in punjab during that period. COMMON PEOPLE USED TO ASK "WHAT IS THE SCORE" ? Which meant ,how many hindus are killed today.
All the sikhs of punjab must read the comments of Mr Congo below and beashamed of themselves. Mr Congo's post is the essence of your history, present and future.
RE:Sikhs need to unite
by speculator on Jul 19, 2008 11:57 PM Permalink
Why should sikhs be ashamed.I have interacted some of these Punjabi Hindus and even though I am not from south the disparaging opinion they have about people from south always made me wonder where is the sense of one people, being part of one country one great culture is.Even I heard from these Punjabi Hindus it's better to break up the country.At least Sikhs are honest, these Punjabi Hindus deserve a kick in their butt.
RE:Sikhs need to unite
by R A on Jul 19, 2008 08:56 AM Permalink
Rajivinder, one need to understand the real reason why sikhs are against him. Its not because he is killer. If this is the criteria then Bhindrawala is also in the same category whose photo u decorated in the gurudwara. The real reason is that his sect is attracting more and more sikhs and you are afraid of it. You don't wanna see the strength of your religion trimming like this. Why sikhs are going to his sect, u need to ask this question to ur leaders.....There must be some flaw in ur system (not religion). Govt is obligated to protect all his citizens no matter if he is rapist/killer. Constitution will take care of this but the way sikhs are handling this issue by taking the law in there hand and terrorising the general public is not correct. At the same time everyone shud have religious freedom. Why sikhs don't allow them to do naam charcha, u know better....but in my views, it shudn't be. This incident also occured bcoz sikhs went there to stop the naam charcha whereas constitutionally, they dont have any such right. And unfortunately, the incident took ugly turn and one person lost his life.
RE:Sikhs need to unite
by Sameer Bhagwat on Jul 19, 2008 10:55 AM Permalink
I fully agree with you Sikhs are leaving sikhism for Dera because of flaws in Sikhism and these people are reacting violently to that.
My advice to sikhs is to come back to Hindu fold and to the castes to which they actually belong so that the system established by our ancestors a million years ago can be further extended.
RE:Sikhs need to unite
by speculator on Jul 19, 2008 11:32 AM Permalink
"ancestors a million years ago can be further extended " The planet was still cooling one million years ago and Neanderthals were non-existent let alone homosapiens.Which ancestor u r talking about?? T-rexes??
