We cannot be sure about this. There has been a lot of criticism from scientists in the know and there are clauses that will ensure a non proliferation regime in future. Also nuclear power will be an expensive option at Rs 9 per unit. Overall, the Govt has no credibility and even Dr MMS has shown himself to be a liar. American arm twisting seems to be at work here. Educated Indians should draw their own conclusions. A second edition without restrictive clauses could come about if we say firm No the first time. This is not possible with a Govt that is badly compromised. This is not about BJP or CPM or anyone else. It is about what is right for India and India alone.