I think our beloved PM is pushing India into a trap in the name of nuclear deal. Why the deal was not made known to the public earlier,if it is beneficial for the national interest.Once the deal is placed, it is also clear that the deal will be governed by the bilateral 123 agreement.But the 123 agreement is untenable, because the agreement is anchored in US domestic laws,which include Hyde act. Hude act contains several stipulations which are extraneous to the issue of bilateral Nuclear Cooperation,including foreign policy and behaviour which India needs to adhere to--if the deal is to be kept alive. Some scientists argued and wanted to clarify-Decision taken today do not prohibit India's future ability to develop and pursue Nuclear Technologies for the benefit of the Nation. Govt. should go ahead with the deal considering all aspects. Ambiguity of the language of the deal must be taken into account. Our PM should not ignore the general consensus.
RE:Nuclear Deal
by max pack on Jul 15, 2008 01:15 PM Permalink
I am sure the sceintists and strategic experts of India have more brains then you. Therefore they went ahead with this deal. Agree or not all leftists only create problems for India and are more loyal to the Chinese. For your kind information it was only Pakis and Chinese who had sent their envoys to various countries to request them not to endorse the deal after July 18,2005. And here we are, unfortunately idiots like you are doing exactly what are notorious neighbours want.
RE:Nuclear Deal
by Kishan Solanki on Jul 15, 2008 01:15 PM Permalink
The view of our PM is non to support for many reasons like:
1. The draft agreement with IAEA does recognised India onlt as nation with Advanced Nuclear Technology, whereas in fact, its should recognise India as Nation with Nuclear Weapons. This is required to protect Indian Interest in case of any disagreement that may arise later on. This is the first compromise our PM has made.
2. The deal with US will be subject to strictest safeguards which cover guidelines in existence as well that may be prescribed later by the IAEA. India cannot have any say for the same. This is our Second compromise.
3. When the deal was in favour of India, why the PM was hesitating to make it public and not showing to allies of UPA, whereas the IAEA has made it public within one day after PM has referred to it when our PM does not have Vote of Confidence at the moment. This is the incidence of Third Compromise
Dear PM, Please listen to voices of people of India and use your conscience & prudence.
SAVE INDIA - SATYA MEV JAYATE 4. There is no Guarante that it will be IAEA will compel the Members of IAEA to continue to provide nuclear fuel for civil reactors in the event if India make any test for Nuclear Devices / weapon at a later date. This is the Highest level of Compromise our PM has made - who has yet to prove his majority in Loksabha. People of India will never forget this type of Compromise made by our PM.
RE:RE:Nuclear Deal
by Guest on Jul 15, 2008 01:36 PM Permalink
Prakash Kharat ( communist leader ) is real internal enemy of India. He and his party will jump as per instructions from China. This deal is very important for us. Deal will create jobs ( for every one). Please support PM ( thou you oppose UPA / congress). After so long we got honest PM ( unfortunately he is not a politician)
RE:Nuclear Deal
by chemmanur jacob on Jul 15, 2008 01:03 PM Permalink
china has signed this agreement about 20 years back. if china can still be an independent country then india will stand independent. we need not worry. so far we have suffered a lot. we must get advance technology without losing much time.
RE:Nuclear Deal
by Bikash Saha on Jul 15, 2008 01:10 PM Permalink
You are very much ignorant. China has not signed the same deal. They are under NPT. There policy is not guided by any US laws (like Hyde act in our case). What's the matter? Sometimes you show china as worst country and sometime say to folllow them?
RE:Nuclear Deal
by S Shrikanth on Jul 15, 2008 01:53 PM Permalink
This is true. China declined the deal. Thats why US is so desperate to sell it to poor India.
