Pranav Mukherjee told the Indian Parliament that Hyde act doesn't apply on India. While US media squarly accused the Indian Foreign minister for telling lies to it's parliament. Hyde Act does apply to India, and this is thing they are hiding from nation. Everything is going in the right direction for the congress as per plan. The govt. will fall soon. The deal will not be signed(Sardaar has no Intention to get it signed). The media blitz and all the hue and cry over the Nuke deal was to put cover over the 4 year of dark ages of this govt. This govt. was a total failure and every MP was worried how are we going to go back to over voters in 2009. The deal is a face saver for this non-performing govt. It will fall soon, but as most of the people on this forum thinks 1000s of Indian voters will think 'Sardaar sacrificed his govt.' and he will also join Maino Antonia as a great Martyr...
RE:Pranav Told Lies in the parliamant : US media
by pruodNorth on Jul 08, 2008 06:41 PM Permalink
what failure. Did ecnomy not rise by 9%? every year.
The fail on control population rate is failure of 60 yers. which I doubt even NDA cannot do much. Only way is get most peopel out of poverty by doing such energy deals & get 9% going. No short cut method./
RE:RE:RE:Pranav Told Lies in the parliamant : US media
by Indian Indian on Jul 08, 2008 06:50 PM Permalink
Living condition of 95% people detoriated. Think about people who make 3K Rs/Month. Think about pentioners, they are not able to eat 2 times a day. Things are out of control of this govt. 9% growth rate kaa achaar daalegaa ???
RE:Pranav Told Lies in the parliamant : US media
by Indian Indian on Jul 08, 2008 06:48 PM Permalink
What did 9% growth rate gave you ? Didn't the living conditions of 95% Indians detoriated ? Think about people who earn 3k Rs/month. Think about pentioners. They are not able to eat 2 times in a day now. 9% growth kaa achaar daalegaa ???
RE:Pranav Told Lies in the parliamant : US media
by kiainth on Jul 08, 2008 06:50 PM Permalink
He is Italian Goons and will not understand common man problem of this country
RE:Pranav Told Lies in the parliamant : US media
by kieran dsouza on Jul 09, 2008 12:44 AM Permalink
Talking of 9% growth is meaningless if there is 12% or higher inflation. Growth benefits the richest and trickles down to poor. But inflation affects the poor severely.
RE:Pranav Told Lies in the parliamant : US media
by All Right on Jul 08, 2008 06:40 PM Permalink
The fact is both Pranab and the US are telling the truth. Why?
It is the 123 Agreement, wherein India & US appended their signatures, that binds both nation.
Knickerwallahs, Read 1-2-3 Agreement Before Commenting
A. If the Agreement works in detriment to India we can Terminate under Article 14
1. Either Party shall have the right to terminate this Agreement prior to its expiration on one year's written notice to the other Party. A Party giving notice of termination shall provide the reasons for seeking such termination. The Agreement shall terminate one year from the date of the written notice, unless the notice has been withdrawn by the providing Party in writing prior to the date of termination.
The Hyde Act is a domestic Act of the US and because it is so, is non-binding on India. However, technically, the Hyde Act binds the US (not us) while implementing the agreement. India likewise can have our own domestic laws that bind us not the US while implementing the agreement. So if each nation is adamant, it creates a gridlock. In practice and otherwise, international treaties supersede domestic laws.
The US-China Nuclear Agreement also contained certain clause sensitive to the Chinese. e.g. The President has to certify each year that China respects human rights in Tibet. The Chinese keep violating human rights, the US President keeping certifying.
RE:RE:Pranav Told Lies in the parliamant : US media
by All Right on Jul 08, 2008 06:43 PM Permalink
As for UPA tenure equated to Dark Ages, this is what Business Standard states:
"Start with the performance of the economy. Its growth rate last year has been upped from 8.7 per cent to 9 per cent, taking the average rate of growth in the four years of the Manmohan Singh government to 8.9 per cent. I cannot think of any other government that would not make a bit of a noise about such stellar success, and draw comparisons with the record of its predecessor (5.9 per cent over six years) — showing a jump of 50 per cent. Or take agriculture, whose annual growth during the UPA term has been 3.6 per cent — again a jump of nearly 50 per cent, and the best record since the 1980s."
RE:RE:Pranav Told Lies in the parliamant : US media
by kiainth on Jul 08, 2008 06:46 PM Permalink
All Right has come from Italy and always adocating for Sonia Maino. Sonia Maino may have got her share in this deal as has been in the past too. She is putting all efforts to sign it. She is not interested for this country. Her Munsi Ji (MMS) who was heading World Bank and now made this country KANGAL will also get berth in US. So don t believe to all these Italian Born Cartoons
RE:RE:Pranav Told Lies in the parliamant : US media
by All Right on Jul 08, 2008 06:42 PM Permalink
As for UPA tenure equated to Dark Ages, this is what Business Standard states:
"Start with the performance of the economy. Its growth rate last year has been upped from 8.7 per cent to 9 per cent, taking the average rate of growth in the four years of the Manmohan Singh government to 8.9 per cent. I cannot think of any other government that would not make a bit of a noise about such stellar success, and draw comparisons with the record of its predecessor (5.9 per cent over six years) — showing a jump of 50 per cent. Or take agriculture, whose annual growth during the UPA term has been 3.6 per cent — again a jump of nearly 50 per cent, and the best record since the 1980s. "
RE:Pranav Told Lies in the parliamant : US media
by kiainth on Jul 08, 2008 06:48 PM Permalink
All Right has come from Italy and always adocating for Sonia Maino. Sonia Maino may have got her share in this deal as has been in the past too. She is putting all efforts to sign it. She is not interested for this country. Her Munsi Ji (MMS) who was heading World Bank and now made this country KANGAL will also get berth in US. So don t believe to all these Italian Born Goons
RE:Pranav Told Lies in the parliamant : US media
by RAVINDRA SITARAM on Jul 08, 2008 06:58 PM Permalink
All right Mr.All right, can you throw some light on the issues like price-rise, inflation, slow-down of many industries?
I do not belong to any political party and certainly will respect any good politician from any party. Let us talk about the performance of the present government, the rice which I was buying at Rs.14 a kg four years back is now costing about 26 to 27, cooking oil is beyond the reach of many, pulses are costing more than 100 to 120%, vegetable prices have gone up by more than three times. The life of an average man like me, has become hell. Probably you are also facing the same situation, now tell me whether the UPA government has done well or not?
