Till date, we do not know the reasons for the BJP's opposition to the deal. The Left is against anything and anyone with even the remotest of connections to the USA and hence they oppose the deal. What about the BJP? What is their grouse against the deal? They cannot oppose something blindly because it was proposed by the ruling party. The BJP is showing the same mentality as the Congress and the Left at the time India detonated the n-bomb in 1998.
No one seems to think of the nation, but only of themselves. What a shame!
RE:BJP's oppositon to n-deal is opportunistic
by Hate Who divides on Jul 05, 2008 02:27 PM Permalink
I dont know about any party ........ But I think that ...... India needs many nuclear test to be sure of security if any threat come from china or Pakistan ............. coz what evr we tested is of 43KT which look like cracker in front of China 's weapon 4-5 MT around 100 times more powerful ......... you cannot deny the fact that all the time US want to curb India'S Nuclear Programme of weaponisation ....... thats y they formed NSG .........if you see they are not signer of CTBT but always force India to sign it ....... They already decieved us in case of Tarapur reactor ............... They also want to curb Indian FBR programme which can create weapon grade plutonium on large scale indirectly it will effect Thorium technology which are underdeveloopment in FBR at kalpakkam ......... So just for energy security you cannot compromise ... Security against threar and make wholee country energy dependent on others
RE:BJP's oppositon to n-deal is opportunistic
by Saurav Basu on Jul 05, 2008 02:45 PM Permalink
The oppposition to the deal is because of the Hyde Act. In the name of energy security, which we are not going to acheive through nuclear deal anyway [since even until 2030, Nuclear deal will supply only 5% of our total energy needs] we cannot compromise our national security. Also, there is a clause in the deal according to which India cannot import heavy water reactors, which are necessary to utilize our vast thorium reserves. Even if we operationalize the deal, who is going to supply us with uranium? Australia has already declined
There are some serious CIA agents running the country
RE:BJP's oppositon to n-deal is opportunistic
by rajkiran on Jul 05, 2008 02:25 PM Permalink
abe gadha hai kya ? .. their opposition is clear. There is hyde act due to which if we conduct n-test, fuel supplies might be cut off! -- ie after investing billions of $ for the reactors, they can run short of the fuel and will be huge financial crisis. so, renegotiate that part
RE:BJP's oppositon to n-deal is opportunistic
by menda vijaya on Jul 05, 2008 02:35 PM Permalink
So you want bombs!! well, the get your own uranium.Why beg other countries ?
RE:BJP's oppositon to n-deal is opportunistic
by rajkiran on Jul 05, 2008 02:45 PM Permalink
1) Its not about wanting bombs. Its about the symbolism of being "controlled" by external factor. 2) Now, I think whether n-deal is good or bad is a secondary thing; whts more important is the new lows in politics - primarily by non-congress; non-bjp parties and partly by congress in the sense that they are not willing to share the IAEA text publicly and even worse they are not briefing any party on such a sensitive matter. And, I dont think matters of such sensitive nature should involve this drama.
RE:BJP's oppositon to n-deal is opportunistic
by markand desai on Jul 05, 2008 02:23 PM Permalink
Read the mails and listen to TV SHOWSAll chenels are crying horse and no other news are available.BLACK OUT ON NEWS COUNTRY TAKEN TO RENSOM BY PM MMS AND PARTY.
RE:BJP's oppositon to n-deal is opportunistic
by Anand YNI on Jul 05, 2008 02:44 PM Permalink
Dear KSK,
Don't get perturbed. If you want to know the reasons for opposition to Nuclear Deal, please read the text of the 123 Nuclear Deal, The Hyde Act and the Comments by the experts that are available on the internet. Alternatively, you may ask me to send the same that is saved in mycomputer. Pl send your mail to yni.anand@rediffmail.com
