Shiv Sena is also supporting N-Deal then why BJP is not supporting N-Deal. Is BJP is doing this only because of opposition party. Now i feel guilt to support BJP blindly from last 20 years.
RE:Shiv Sena is also supporting N-Deal.
by P Zipk on Jul 03, 2008 09:51 PM Permalink
Don't feel guilty. The Hyde act might come in the way of Indian energy security. The enrgy security is one of the most important national security issues in the 21st century. Once the deal is signed, the first order India will receive from the US is to cut off the relation with Iran. While Iran is no saint, India has to make that decision based on her own interest.
I am very pro-US and very anti-Commies. But knowing the history of the US relationship with other countries, the US will not heisitate to choke India using the Hyde act when it feels India is rubbing against the perceived US interest.
And there is no reason why this deal has to be done in a big hurry. I know Mr.Singh wants to go down in the history as the architect of this deal, but that is good for his personal achievement not necessariy for the country. If we afreaid the new US president might be aginst this deal, then we really should not hurry to get this deal done with the current president.
RE:Shiv Sena is also supporting N-Deal.
by Indian Indian on Jul 03, 2008 09:22 PM Permalink
It is for the Hyde Act. Which restrict India to do Nuclear Tests also the way the deal will work, US can make amendments to it without even notifying Indian govt. There are endless loopholes in the deal, this govt. is rushing on it as they know it cannot be signed and they are just trying to get sympathy votes from people like you who don't know enough about the deal, All they want to do is make an honourable exit from the govt. and make Manmohan Singh a Martyr who would sacrifice his govt. for the good of the country
RE:Shiv Sena is also supporting N-Deal.
by Sudip Bhattacharjee on Jul 03, 2008 09:35 PM Permalink
That is nonsense. No one will stop India to detonate a nuclear device. But the more important question is why on what circumstances India will need to detonate a nuclear device? I don't think there will ever be any need for doing so and India will make a Himalayan blunder, possibly the greatest blunder since independence by not accepting the deal. It is ridiculous to reject the deal in the pretext of being able to conduct nuclear tests.
RE:Shiv Sena is also supporting N-Deal.
by Vikas Bhatt on Jul 03, 2008 09:41 PM Permalink
India may need to carry nuclear tests to show strength to keep Pakistan at bay as and when required since Pakistan is alway trying out new missiles with nuclear carrying capacity to show us down all the time.
RE:Shiv Sena is also supporting N-Deal.
by JI HUA on Jul 03, 2008 09:49 PM Permalink
now we can carry a stimulus nuke test we donot need a real one and save a lot of money
RE:Shiv Sena is also supporting N-Deal.
by JI HUA on Jul 03, 2008 09:35 PM Permalink
Mr advani has said publically they will accept this deal if they will be in goverment
also now no real nuclear test is needed for the development of a nuke warfare in India's case "quote vajpayee and advani last election statement" also america can do changes without informing India but India can reject the changes (after they are made) also they have to syop the changes right then and their but US will have power in that case to suspend further helping India for nuke power
