I think rediff should get some better folks to comment on such matters. 1) Gorshkov has already been signed and India has already paid money...I think USD 800 millions.Beacuse of Gorshkov India signed the Mig 29 deal (naval version) and infact India will start getting the delivery from next year 2) Gorshkov was supposed to join this August but now may come in 2011 but the deal is done 3) India will get all the high tech gizmos with Gorshkov not with Kitty Hawk 4) india has lot more at stake with Russia like brahmos, Su 30, Akula, Amur Class, Frigates, Smerch, T 90s. So India is not a fool just for Kitty Hawk which itself will be decomisinoned to kill Gorshkov. 5) yes instead of refurbishing Viraat they may opt for Kitty Ahwk (as a stop gap) before Gorshkov and indegineous AC joins So rediff please do not publish such crap
RE:RE:Grow up rediff
by Vinayak bhide on Feb 27, 2008 01:49 PM Permalink
Rahul, Pl bear in mind india post independence was never a banana republic/vassal/stooge of any country.so like china trades with all like Saudis/australians/usa/sudan,we have to broaden our horizon come out of third world pshye.
RE:Grow up rediff
by Rahul on Feb 27, 2008 02:20 PM Permalink
I donot understand your point. You look all confused. You should come out of the Chinese mentality. One thing is for sure whatever you mean India has to look at it's strategic intrests and to hoots to whatever China does. As of now it looks foolish to even think of Leeting Goshkov go not foolish but childish. Someone confused like you can only think of china, russia, blah blah....Grow up you crappy
RE:Grow up rediff
by bhaswaran bhattacharya on Feb 27, 2008 01:55 PM Permalink
The Kitty Hawk is also much slower on sea in terms of speed and manuevers when compared to the Groshkov, and what such millitary battle groups needs is - quick action, as quick as possible. However, the US counterpart is larger in size and can house more aircraft than the Russian ship.
RE:RE:Grow up rediff
by Rahul on Feb 27, 2008 02:22 PM Permalink
A larger carrier doesnot mean more protection. The only good point I see in this entire deal is transfering the steam ctapult technology which only the west has and India doesnot. Apart from that if now we go for the F 18 naval version we already have ordered Mig 29, we have the Sea Harriers and the Jaguars...it will be a nightmare of platforms to handle. So better stick to Gorshkov and if viraat is decomissioned then think of Kitty Hawk. Moreover Russians have been more reliable than US and we have more at stake with Russians thank with US
