Aristotle (Greece) proposes that the Sun is a sphere of pure fire, unchanging and without imperfections...
The quran says:- the sun will finish one day after it due course...
Which now everyone knows:- o.k, tell me which other book says that the SUN will finish? No book, because you all pray to Surya devta, so how can sun die? isn't it.
RE:Aristotle the great:
by Sameer Bhagwat on Feb 26, 2008 12:03 AM Permalink
Brain, R u muslim ? Sorry i should hv asked you r u science student ? If yes can i ask you what is star ? Star is sun ? And our sun is one of millions or billions of star. As per present knowledge of mankind star can die and star can be formed. At any given time there will be star formation and star death happening around our universe.
RE:Aristotle the great:
by Sameer Bhagwat on Feb 26, 2008 12:11 AM Permalink
Why do Hindu worship sun ? Well why do Muslim revolve around that kaba stone?
Dear, something created by our forefathers so that there is some rituals which can be followed by followers.
Hindu worship star bcuaz it provides energy. Not only hindu worship sun, but mother earth, which provides everything, water-our body constitute, Air- (should i say oxygen.. hello i am making correction in my holy book here)without which we will die. And fire : which is responsible for energy as well destroying everything. It is called panchtatva
RE:RE:Aristotle the great:
by The Brain on Feb 26, 2008 12:16 AM Permalink
thats correct... anyway, we donot worship Kaaba, we only prey in direction of Kabaa, so all muslims can unite together and prey in one direction.. you must have seen that muslims pray in unity, if there was no direction, there would have not been any unity... infact, muslims can prey inside Kabaa in any direction... they can even climb on Kabba and prey...(will you put your feet on your idol... no, you wont).. the Kabaa has no power, it cant benifit me, nor can it harm me.... Muslims prey to God and you prey to GOD'S
God has created everything, so we prey god.. we dont pray things which belong to god...
what about your first point about revolution? Did you find that Aristotole already said that?
Similarly, most of the things and ideas in your religion are influenced by the local people's ideas. That is why Jews and Muslims have lot of things in common. They believe in Abraham, you too. They believe in Adam-Eve, you too. (In the same context, they do not eat pig, you too. they also cut the tip of the pen*is, you too.)
RE:RE:Aristotle the great:
by The Brain on Feb 26, 2008 12:08 AM Permalink
Great... about Revolution of sun across earth? great.. do you want me to comment it? The theory itself is wrong...does the sun revolves around the earth? Quran is beyond human brain... quran only says the Sun rotates and revolves in its orbit....It is not a copied version, to copy things of Aristotle and paste is... it never says that the sun revolves around the earth...
RE:Aristotle the great:
by Beachy Babes on Feb 26, 2008 12:10 AM Permalink
secondly, your Kuran borrowed the idea of Sun's revolution from Aristotle and says exactly the same- that sun rotates around the earth.
this is not true. sun rotates around the milky way. not earth.
in the contrary, earth rotates around the sun. if you analyze like this you will discover the wrongs things in there. So Do not believe the uneducated Mullas and do your own analysis.
RE:Aristotle the great:
by The Brain on Feb 26, 2008 12:13 AM Permalink
oh, who told you that QURAN says that the sun revolves around the earth?......... please get your fact corrected....
The quran says the sun revolves around its orbit... it is not a copy and paste material, or it would have said that the sun revolves around the earth... so simple it would have been... isn't it...
it actually meant that way. Only the modern Mullahs are trying to show it as scientific, and so telling you with diplomatic way. that was how the concept of year came. Kuran even says, "the suns sets into the sea". Now, since this is not true, do not say that Kuran was saying in a symbolic way!!
your kuran does not say about earth's rotation about the sun. why? because at that time, it was not thought like that. Earth was seen as the centre of the universe (Aristotole). Your Kuran modified it little bit and said, "Kaaba, Mecca, is the center of the earth." and so the universe and the gate to haven is just above Mecca.
