Who says Foreigners cannot love India and do good for us. Why all the hatred towards Mrs.Gandhi. Please show some compassion towards a lady who lost her husband tragically. We should respect and appreciate her strength to hold on in those difficult times. I feel she is more dependable than the so called 'desh ka puttar' politicians who is looting India and doesn't care what happens to our country.
RE:You don't need to be Indian to Love India!
by ASingh on Aug 09, 2008 03:09 AM Permalink
Again you are right..but the question here is not about an individual..it is about a position..a positions which her birth country does have a law to not allow foriegn born to take..All sympathy for her family..but here the question is about right or wrong..no doubt our current breed of netas are actually biggest 'desh drohees'..assume a situation..INDIA and ITALY have a war...which country would she have to support as PM ? would she allow bombing of the town where her family resides even now ? it is hypothetical...but important..thats why most modern constituions do not allow top posts to go to foreign born.. Nothing against her as a person..but she cannot be allowed to the top post..she can be an MP or MLA..but no to PM or president posts...
RE:You don't need to be Indian to Love India!
by Aquarius on Aug 09, 2008 06:05 AM Permalink
Who are you to decide all this singh? The voters want her as leader so she is tallest leader in india.Who cares for you or your loser party.
RE:You don't need to be Indian to Love India!
by YoBro on Aug 09, 2008 03:25 AM Permalink
Well...enough of your lecturing. That's why she was smart enough to 'relinquish' the PM post to MMS? Technically, whatever you said is alright. But just to let you in on a secret - you don't have to be a PM to be the PM, especially if you're leader of the party and wield a lot of clout. Get it? Wise up.
RE:You don't need to be Indian to Love India!
by ASingh on Aug 09, 2008 04:09 AM Permalink
"You dont have to be a PM to be PM" ??? be clear...and lecturing it is...as you have no point in your garbage...be clear..or understand that she didnt relinquish the crown..rather was asked to get off by somebody called PRESIDENT...u see why he was not given the second term - you know who I am talking about...??
RE:RE:You don't need to be Indian to Love India!
by Aquarius on Aug 09, 2008 06:08 AM Permalink
All this president not allowing her to be PM is a lot of BS.She is a leader the people want. Even in america we had the Bush family and the clintons dominating the scene.So don't keep crying.
RE:You don't need to be Indian to Love India!
by desikan r on Aug 09, 2008 08:28 PM Permalink
Madame knew she and her clan cud survive only by NOT becoming PM. Why has the debate of citizens not born here holding positions of power not been sorted out?? Coz that would have seen her disqualified for life. Had she become PM, the verdict would have been out long back and she wud have got kicked out. However she refused and theres no news of the reply to the question.
RE:You don't need to be Indian to Love India!
by Postwala on Aug 09, 2008 03:45 AM Permalink
Ther was a joke on Star one..when America prides we have the finest Robot, the Indian argues...we have Manmohan Singh.
Our constitution and we fail to recognise leadership at every step and then cry foul at them. I would prefer a system of incentives and distribution rather than reservation.
Just limit the position to 2 terms (sp power is distributed), we wont have to see Sonia gandhis folowed by Rahul, lallu and aur patni's. THis bill is more important than womens quota - these guys would never agree to it, because they will all be sacked.
RE:You don't need to be Indian to Love India!
by virtuality on Aug 09, 2008 03:30 AM Permalink
Lost her husband tragically? are you trying to be comic? get the facts waronindia.com
RE:RE:You don't need to be Indian to Love India!
by Aquarius on Aug 09, 2008 06:10 AM Permalink
waronindia is a hindutva hate site.so buzz off and stop caling others who oppose you names you hindutva nut.
