What will they do if a healthy child will become mental ill after taking birth? Parents will file a Petion that they want to kill child bcz they wanted a Tendulkar like Son, so child should be hanged.
RE:If Child will be ILL after Birth
by Gyani on Aug 04, 2008 05:49 PM Permalink
In the above said case parents should be given rights to chose whether they should give birth to child or not.
Although it should not be made a common practise but with consultation of medical & judicial authorities it should be allowed.
The consequences will be terrible.
Justice Khandeparkar observed "It is the job of the legislature to help you alter the provision. We cannot legislate the provision," my foot.
Is the court going to provide them all the financial help required throughout their future.....??? Is the court going to compensate for their mental torcher they will face throughout their life.....??? Is the court going to provide that child a good future.....???
The answer is NO. They just made a decision and ruined 3 lives. Im sure after this that couple wont dare to have another child.
I can't understand the law which is ready to destroy 3 lives to save one who is not even born......???
RE:If Child will be ILL after Birth
by Ramanath Babu on Aug 04, 2008 05:57 PM Permalink
Gyani,
Don't get emotional. Altough I don't spport abortion at this stage, I cannot but agree with the judge. Legislature and judiciary are two wings of democracy and there should not be any conflict between the two. the legislatures job is to frame laws and rules, and judiciary protect it and interpret it. Judges are not authorised to make any rule or law on their own. They can only interpret the laws that are in force. If in the current case, judges allow abortion, they would be stepping out of their limits set by the constitution.
RE:If Child will be ILL after Birth
by thebedazzled on Aug 04, 2008 05:52 PM Permalink
We see daily when courts step into legislature's area. Why today suddenly they realized that the areas are different?
RE:If Child will be ILL after Birth
by sumitra rahi on Aug 04, 2008 05:54 PM Permalink
U have been long advocating through ur posts that the concerned parents shld not terminate the pregnency .If u r feeling so much may i give u a good suggestion in place of wasting time and energy writing on this board go & talk to the parents of this unborn child & give an application in court that u want to adopt it & will take care throughtout life . OK . Let me c if u can practice what u r preaching . It is very easy to give lectures to others bcoz the problem will be faced by others and not u .
