Any criminal should be punished as per the applicable laws. Execute ANY terrorist without ANY mercy... Religion / caste / nationalism must NOT come into picture at all... Supporting a criminal (be it Sarabjit / anyone) just because he is an Indian is NOT patriotism.
It's high time that we changed our way of thinking to an 'unbiased' one. Terrorists and Criminals who kill hundreds of lives do not deserve any humanitarian touch
RE:No bias
by Ashwas Gupte on Apr 18, 2008 05:22 PM Permalink
wht the hell man! even if he's a spy and he'd done all those things which led to his conviction, he'd done all that just for you and me and for our country. and now you are back stabbing him. your stabnd is totally unacceptable! so pls change it. we really hope he will get clemency as his case is genuine and is being cruisfied for mistaken identity.
RE:No bias
by on Apr 18, 2008 05:49 PM Permalink
Why India is asking for clemency? If he is innocent why can't Indian govt appoint some leading lawyer and go via judiciary process like Haneef's case and sponsor the proceedings . And If he is responsible/involved in any capacity in the bomb plast then he is right candidate for getting hanged irrespective of whether he is from our country or not.
RE:No bias
by Tera Baap on Apr 18, 2008 08:27 PM Permalink
by Tera Baap on Apr 18, 2008 08:12 PM right! what about kashmir singh who was released and openly said that he was a SPY! Should India not sent him back to PAKISTAN and get Sarabjeet instead? Is it not moral duty of any nation to punish the culprit regardless of religion/caste/creed/nature?
RE:RE:No bias
by Tera Baap on Apr 18, 2008 08:27 PM Permalink
by Tera Baap on Apr 18, 2008 08:12 PM right! what about kashmir singh who was released and openly said that he was a SPY! Should India not sent him back to PAKISTAN and get Sarabjeet instead? Is it not moral duty of any nation to punish the culprit regardless of religion/caste/creed/nature?
RE:No bias
by PKN on Apr 18, 2008 05:32 PM Permalink
Before you flourish your high moral sense ask you self these quesions ?
On what basis do you say that Sarabjit was terrorist? Which terrorist organisation does he belong to?
Pakistan DOESNOT ( read again DOESNOT) call him a terrorist ! Thty say he was an agent of the Government Of India sent to carry out bombings in Lahore! IF then Sarabjit is guilty , we have to accept that our Government of Day was responsible for acts of terror in a neigbouring country . That would be a Joke ! Since this country has never done something like this ! And I beleive and hope will never carry out such dastardly acts that take innocent lives. There is therefore more to this than merely lecturing on moral science.
RE:No bias
by MNS on Apr 18, 2008 05:36 PM Permalink
Mr PKN...I accpet u r argument..but do u really think India could do such immoral activities in Pakistan...I think The pak is always bombed by their own ppl ...How can u think of such a wierd assumption..
RE:No bias
by PKN on Apr 18, 2008 06:15 PM Permalink
Mr MMS , read my comment ! I said India will NEVER DO THIS and I hope a day will never come when India will do this ! So the whole argument that Sarabjit is a terrorist falls flat on its face !
RE:No bias
by Tera Baap on Apr 18, 2008 08:12 PM Permalink
right! what about kashmir singh who was released and openly said that he was a SPY! Should India not sent him back to PAKISTAN and get Sarabjeet instead? Is it not moral duty of any nation to punish the culprit regardless of religion/caste/creed/nature?
RE:No bias
by Yaqoot Mir on Apr 18, 2008 11:54 PM Permalink
Terra Baap has made the most logical statement, India has no case in Sarbkits case, pakistan will claim look we released Kashmir Singh and all he did was ehonorate our position that he was indeed a spy. How can pakistan trust Sarbjit and besides read my earlier post, Sarabjit has confessed to the bombings anyway during interrogation so what case does India have. And some one here made a comparison to indian citizen Dr. Haneed HOW DARE you, the good good doctor was picked up Autralia for terrorism, he was released because he was a law abiding citizen, Sarbjit my freind is NO LAW ABIDING citizen, he is a convicted facilitator and excecutor of a bombing that killed innocent citizens of another coutry.
RE:No bias
by bala sreenivasan on Apr 18, 2008 05:21 PM Permalink
if your recommendations are taken seriously, then both ISI and Research & Analysis Wing will have to closed down their recruitment division! Espionage is a part of international politics and people like Sarabjith and Kashmir Singh are just pawns who are casually dispensed with.
RE:No bias
by Jayatheerthan K on Apr 18, 2008 05:36 PM Permalink
Well, if espionage is an 'accepted' part of international politics, then let the international law treat is as a 'non criminal' act ;-)..
All that I am saying is that we should not be supporting someone just because he is an Indian / Hindu / Sikh / Muslim.. if it were true that Sarabjit was behind a bomb attack,which is a crime, then let him be punished as per the applicable laws. If it can be proved that it is a case of 'mistaken identity', then let him be freed. Supporting someone blindly for the reason that he belongs to our nation cannot be termed as patriotism.
