constitution guarantees equality and concessions for the lower castes and rightly so, as they suffered discrimintaion for 1000's of years. but consititution does not provide any reprieve for hindus, sikhs , jains , buddhists who were persecuted by muslims for the last 1000 years. By making india secular , we allowed a minority with a tyrannical past get equal footing with the majority. Its a fact that india was divided on religious grounds. muslim majority provinces walked out of india as they wanted to live in a islamic country, they did not want to live in a secular india. then what remained behind should have automatically become a hindu nation. but that didn't happen. tyrants were rewarded with a separate country and also given equal rights in this country. hindu rights were thus trampled. being the majority community in india , hindus deserved to make this a hindu country. ( with just 55% of the population , muslims made sudan a islamic country, in muslim malaysia, muslims are only 60% of the population). Only declaring india a hindu nation will complete the unfinished task of providing compensation and relief to historically oppressed people in india. WHAT DOES RAM KELKAR WANT TO SAY ABOUT THIS ?
RE:what about justice to hindus ?
by Aditya on Apr 12, 2008 08:33 PM Permalink
There are only two countries which are created on the basis of religion. Pakistan and Israel and both havent seen peace at all internally and externally since its birth. Please dont bring religion into the identity of a country. A nation is an idea and its far bigger than any religion or community. If you are a true Hindu then please go back into history the glorious and not so glorious. You will know at the most powerful empires also seperated matters of state from religion. That is the reason Kshatriyas were rulers and not Brahmins. That is why a Chandragupta Maurya was the emperor and Chanakya a brahmin priest was only a advisor. Apart from that Chanakya himself has noted that State and Religion should not mix. So dont insult hindu ethos and culture by calling to declare India a Hindu Nation.... finally a nation doesnt belong to anyone. You belong to the nation. If you dont recognise you are free to leave the country along with your bigotry.
RE:what about justice to hindus ?
by WERY AMUSITA on Apr 12, 2008 07:43 PM Permalink
Yes.. very right...very sensible arguement.But who is there to listen? the Man in suit even had the nerve to state that Muslims have the first claim to India's resources.is he in his right state of mind;to even think like that in a democratic nation? So what about the rest of us? Who is there to protect our religious beliefs,our way of life,our land???BJP failed us miserably.... Can RSS bring up new Hindu leadership other than the Jinnah worshippers and coffin dealers?
RE:RE:RE:what about justice to hindus ?
by Aditya on Apr 12, 2008 08:34 PM Permalink
There are only two countries which are created on the basis of religion. Pakistan and Israel and both havent seen peace at all internally and externally since its birth. Please dont bring religion into the identity of a country. A nation is an idea and its far bigger than any religion or community. If you are a true Hindu then please go back into history the glorious and not so glorious. You will know at the most powerful empires also seperated matters of state from religion. That is the reason Kshatriyas were rulers and not Brahmins. That is why a Chandragupta Maurya was the emperor and Chanakya a brahmin priest was only a advisor. Apart from that Chanakya himself has noted that State and Religion should not mix. So dont insult hindu ethos and culture by calling to declare India a Hindu Nation.... finally a nation doesnt belong to anyone. You belong to the nation. If you dont recognise you are free to leave the country along with your bigotry.
